What Happened When I Decided To Stop Using AI For My Kid’s Homework And Daily Life
It was 9:12 on a Tuesday night, and there were crushed Goldfish crumbs stuck to the edge of my kitchen counter. My 11-year-old Lila pushed her laptop toward me, her half-finished science fair project display propped against the toaster, and asked me to polish her 100-word “About the Scientist” blurb. I reached for my phone, thumb already hovering over the AI app icon I’d come to rely on for every small request like this, when she tilted her head and said, “Wait, can’t you just tell me what you’d say? It doesn’t have to sound fancy.”
That stopped me. For six months, I’d turned to AI for almost every kid-related task that popped up. I’d used it to write polite emails to the school nurse when Lila needed an extra day of absences, to come up with peanut-free snack ideas for her soccer team, to brainstorm bedtime story plots when I was too tired after work to make one up, even to fix the awkward run-on sentences in her book reports before she turned them in. It was fast, it was never rude, it always gave me something that sounded good enough. But as I looked at Lila’s crumpled note card where she’d scrawled “I got interested in beans because our last bean plant died when we went to the beach,” I realized I couldn’t remember the last time I’d given her my own messy, unpolished answer instead of a polished, generic one. That night, I decided I was going to stop using AI for anything related to Lila and our daily home life.
The first week was harder than I expected. The morning after I made the decision, I needed to email Lila’s soccer coach to say she’d miss practice for a dentist appointment. I opened a blank email and stared at it for 10 full minutes. My brain was so used to letting AI phrase things “nicely” that I’d forgotten how to write a 2-sentence email. Finally, I typed: “Hi Coach, Lila can’t make practice this Thursday. We have a dentist appointment I can’t reschedule. Sorry for the late notice.” I hit send before I could overthink it. Coach wrote back 5 minutes later: “No problem, see you next week!” That was it. No fancy phrasing needed.
I started noticing how many small choices I’d outsourced without even thinking. When Lila had to write a personal paragraph about her favorite holiday for English class a couple weeks later, she finished a draft that started with “My favorite Christmas was two years ago because my cousin spilled eggnog on our dog Max and he ran around the tree shaking nog everywhere.” I immediately had the urge to run it through AI to cut the messy parts and make it “flow better.” Instead, I just read it and told her the part about Max running around the tree made me laugh, because I remembered it too. She turned it in just like that, and got a B+ with a note from her teacher in the margin: “This made me laugh out loud. Great story.” It would have never gotten that note if we’d turned in the polished AI version that cut the best part.
I made three small changes that have made this easier, and any parent can try them without rearranging their whole life. First, I moved the AI app off my phone’s home screen and into a folder labeled “Work Only,” so I don’t see it when I’m sitting at the kitchen table helping with homework or planning a weekend trip. Out of sight, out of mind, honestly. Second, I set a 10-minute timer if I ever get the urge to pull up AI for a kid task. 9 times out of 10, I can finish the task myself in 10 minutes, faster than I can type a good prompt and sort through the AI’s options. Third, I use the good enough test: if the task isn’t for my paid job, where it needs to be polished for a client, it can be good enough. The coach doesn’t need a perfectly phrased apology. The teacher doesn’t need a perfectly structured paragraph that doesn’t sound like an 11-year-old wrote it. My mom doesn’t need a perfectly rhyming poem for Grandparent’s Day.
We tested that last one last month, when Lila had to bring a poem for her grandma for Grandparent’s Day at school. I was exhausted after a full day of work deadlines, and I almost caved and pulled up AI. Instead, I sat down with Lila and we just listed all the things she loves about grandma: burnt chocolate chip cookies, singing off-key to old Taylor Swift songs in the car, letting Lila stay up 15 minutes late to watch Princess Diaries. We turned that list into a poem, it had bad rhymes and half a line that didn’t fit, and my mom cried when she got it. It’s taped to her fridge right now.
I still slip up sometimes. Two weeks ago, I was drained after back-to-back work meetings, and I pulled up AI to get a packing list for our upcoming camping trip. I looked through the list it gave me, and it had things like a portable outdoor shower and a specialized camp coffee maker that we’d never use in a million years. I crossed off everything that didn’t fit us, added the extra marshmallows Lila always begs for and the extra plastic bags for muddy shoes, and ended up with a list that was way better than the one AI gave me.
I also don’t think this is some judgment on parents who use AI. I still use it for work all the time, when I need an outline for a presentation or to sort through a messy pile of meeting notes. It’s a tool, just like any other. But for me, I realized I was letting it take away the small, messy, ordinary moments that matter for Lila. She doesn’t need perfect. She needs me to help her write a bad poem about her grandma’s burnt cookies. She needs me to tell her that the story about the eggnog on the dog is good enough, even if it has run-on sentences.
Right now, Lila’s bean plant is sitting on our kitchen windowsill, it’s sprouted two big green leaves even though she forgot to water it for three days last week. I still catch myself reaching for my phone when she asks for help with something, and I still have to remind myself to stop and think for a minute. It’s a work in progress. But so far, the messy version has been better than any perfect one AI could ever give us.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happened When I Decided To Stop Using AI For My Kid’s Homework And Daily Life