What I Learned From Asking “Mean Teachers” Why They Seem So Hard On Kids
I was leaning against a scuffed cinder block wall outside the 7th grade wing last fall, waiting for my turn at parent-teacher conferences, when I heard the two moms in front of me talking about Ms. Henderson. “She’s so mean,” one said, twisting her Starbucks cup lid. “My son came home crying last week because she embarrassed him for forgetting his notebook. No one should talk to kids like that.” The other nodded, saying she’d already put in a request to switch her daughter to another math class. I nodded along, too. My 12-year-old son Jake had been complaining about Ms. Henderson since the first week of school, calling her the meanest teacher in the whole school, so I was already predisposed to agree.
When my name was called, I walked into her small, windowless room, past stacks of graph paper and a bulletin board covered in student test corrections with sticky notes that said “Nice work fixing this mistake.” She had a chipped blue ceramic mug that said “World’s Okayest Math Teacher” on her desk, and a handful of kid-drawn magnets holding up her lesson plans. I sat down in the plastic folding chair across from her, and instead of launching into the “my son says you’re too hard” speech I’d rehearsed, I just asked: “Everyone around here calls you the mean teacher. Can you tell me why that is?”
She leaned back in her chair and laughed, not defensive at all. She said she’d been teaching middle school math at this school for 18 years, and she didn’t start out this way. “When I first got this job, I was the nice teacher,” she said. “I’d let kids turn in homework a week late no penalty. I kept a drawer full of extra calculators and pencils and notebooks, so I’d lend one out to anyone who forgot. If a kid’s phone went off in class, I’d just smile and ask them to put it away, no write-up, no detention. I didn’t want anyone to not like me.” Then, 12 years in, a group of her former 8th grade students came back to visit during their senior year of high school. One of them, a girl who’d always been sweet and funny and wanted to study engineering, told her she’d failed her first college algebra class. “She said I never made her do the work on her own,” Ms. Henderson said. “She got used to me bailing her out every time she forgot something, or turned in work late, and when she got to high school, then college, no one was going to do that. She blamed herself, but I blamed me. I wasn’t doing her any favors by being nice all the time.”
That’s when she changed her rules. No extra calculators to borrow – if you forget yours, you do the work by hand, and lose points if you can’t calculate the answers right. Homework is 10% of the grade, and it’s marked zero if it’s more than a day late. Phones go in the pocket chart by the door at the start of class, no exceptions. “Parents call me mean all the time,” she said, pulling up Jake’s grade log on her computer. “Jake here has eight late homework assignments in the first quarter. Most of them are half done. But I’ve graded his pop quizzes, and he gets 70% of the problems right when he’s paying attention. He’s good at this. He just thinks if he waits until the bell rings to do it, it’s fine, because every other teacher has let him do that.” She showed me the log, and I had to admit I’d seen that same habit at home – Jake shoves his homework in his backpack half done, figures he’ll finish it on the bus, then forgets it entirely.
I left that conference with a lot more than I expected. For years, I’d automatically taken my kid’s side when they said a teacher was mean, because I remembered what it felt like to have a teacher be unnecessarily hard on me as a kid. But that conversation with Ms. Henderson changed how I approach those conversations, for both parents and teachers. The first thing I realized is that if you’re a parent, when your kid says their teacher is mean, the worst thing you can do is complain to the principal or demand a schedule change before you go ask the teacher straight. You don’t have to be confrontational about it – you can say exactly what I said, or just ask “what small habits are you working on with the kids this semester, and how can we support that at home?” That’s way more productive than showing up ready to fight.
The second thing is that small, consistent boundaries are way more helpful for kids than being “nice” all the time. We made a five-item check list taped to our front door: backpack, homework, calculator, lunch, gym shoes. Every night after dinner, Jake checks it before he goes to watch TV. It takes 30 seconds, it’s not a big fight, and it cut his number of forgotten items from 3 or 4 a week to once a month. When he forgot his calculator again two weeks after the conference, I didn’t email Ms. Henderson to ask she make an exception. We just added a sticky note that says “DID YOU GRAB YOUR CALCULATOR?” to his locker door, and he hasn’t forgotten it since.
It’s not all perfect. Jake still complains sometimes that Ms. Henderson is too strict, and last month she gave him a detention for talking during silent work time, and he was mad for an hour after school. I also don’t think every teacher labeled “mean” is just a tough teacher with good intentions – I’ve had encounters with teachers who were burnt out and rude to kids for no reason, and that’s a different thing entirely. But asking the question straight gives you the answer you can’t get from a 12-year-old’s after-school rant or a hallway conversation with other parents.
Right now, Jake’s got a C+ in math, up from a D first quarter. Last week he told me Ms. Henderson stayed after class for 10 minutes to help him work through slope problems when everyone else left. He didn’t call her mean that time. He just said she’s actually not that bad once you do what she asks. I don’t know if he’ll end up loving math, or if he’ll ever think Ms. Henderson is his favorite teacher. But he’s learning how to show up prepared, how to be responsible for his own stuff, and that’s a lesson I couldn’t teach him at home alone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned From Asking “Mean Teachers” Why They Seem So Hard On Kids