What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down By Facebook Outrage: A Teacher’s Perspective
I was grading vocab quizzes at my kitchen table last month, half a cup of lukewarm oat coffee next to me, when my friend Mia texted me a screenshot of a Facebook post. Mia’s a school counselor at Stonewall Middle, a 15-minute drive from my 7th grade classroom in suburban Virginia. The post was from our local 12,000-member parent group: Stonewall just approved an LGBTQ+ student alliance club, the caption read, and it’s time to take our schools back.
I’ve worked in district schools long enough to know what comes next. This story isn’t new, but it’s one more parents and teachers need to pay attention to, because it’s playing out in small towns and suburbs all over the country right now.
The club started the way most middle school clubs do: three 8th graders got tired of seeing their friends bullied for being gay or trans, so they made an appointment with the principal. They wrote up their own constitution, said their goals were to host monthly game nights, plan a safe space day for spirit week, and give kids who feel out of place someone to talk to. They didn’t mention protests, political advocacy, or sex education anywhere in their paperwork. Per district policy, student-led clubs get approved as long as they have a staff sponsor, and Mia volunteered. Fourteen kids signed up in the first week—half of them were straight allies, kids who’d had a friend come out and wanted to show up.
Then a parent whose oldest kid graduated from the district 10 years ago spotted the club listed on Stonewall’s website, snapped the screenshot, and posted it to the Facebook group. By the end of the first day, the post had 1,200 comments. People called the district “groomers,” said kids as young as 12 were too young to talk about gender and sexuality, threatened to vote every sitting school board member out of office in the next election. The superintendent got more than 400 emails in 48 hours. Mia told me later that when she checked, almost 70% of the people who’d emailed or commented didn’t have any kids currently attending Stonewall, or even any school in the district. They just saw a viral post and jumped in.
A week later, the district put all new club approvals on hold, and Stonewall shut the alliance down. Admin said they needed more “community input” before moving forward. That’s when Mia told me about Eli, a 13-year-old trans boy who’d transferred to Stonewall that year after his old school refused to let him use the boys’ bathroom. He was the first kid to sign the club list, and he stayed after school for an hour helping Mia tape fliers to locker room doors. He told her he’d been eating lunch in the bathroom stall because kids kept calling him names, and he was excited to have somewhere else to go. When Mia told him the club was off, he didn’t cry or yell. He just stuffed his flier into his backpack and walked out. He didn’t come to school for the next two days. His mom called Mia, said he’d locked himself in his room repeating “no one wants me here anyway.”
After we met for tacos that night, Mia picking at carnitas and me stealing her chips, we started talking about what actually works when things like this happen. It’s easy to get pulled into a big, messy public fight on social media, but that’s not what helps kids right now. The first thing I tell other parents and teachers is to do this one small thing before you comment on or share a post about a school club: ask two questions. First, do you actually have a child attending this school? Second, have you reached out to the school directly to ask what the club actually does, not just what the viral post claims. Most of the time, you’ll find the outrage is built on a lie or an assumption. This club wasn’t teaching anything inappropriate. It was just giving lonely kids a place to sit.
When the formal club gets shut down, you don’t have to stop having the space. After the announcement, Mia just started advertising an informal weekly lunch bunch in her office. She didn’t label it anything political or specific. She just told the kids who’d signed up for the alliance to spread the word to anyone who needed a quiet place to eat. She moves the extra chair from her desk into the corner, pushes two small tables together, keeps a box of granola bars and a old Switch dock hooked up to her office TV. Every Wednesday, 8 to 12 kids show up. It’s unofficial, so it doesn’t get posted on the school website, and it flies right under the radar of the Facebook crowd. It doesn’t fix the big policy problem, but it gives kids a space right now. That’s something any teacher can do, no board approval needed.
For parents, if the school won’t host a space your kid needs, most public libraries will let you book a small meeting room for free for community groups. You don’t have to make a big public announcement, just ask your kid’s guidance counselor to pass the word along quietly to families who might be interested. A group of parents in our district started one a few years ago, they meet once a month, the kids bake cookies and play volleyball at the park next door, and they’ve never had a problem because they don’t go looking for a fight. They just give kids what they need.
Last week, Mia sent me a blurry cell photo from her lunch bunch. The kids were all crowded around her TV yelling over a Mario Kart race, and Eli was front and center, holding his controller, grinning, a small trans pride pin stuck to the front of his hoodie. The formal club is still gone, and the school board is still debating a new rule that would ban any student club that mentions sexual orientation or gender identity. No one knows what will happen when school starts back in the fall. But right now, those kids have a place to go. That’s enough for today.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down By Facebook Outrage: A Teacher’s Perspective