Please Tell Me What I’m Doing Wrong: A Parent’s Honest Look at the Homework Wars
The kitchen table was covered with eraser crumbs, a half-empty water bottle, and one math worksheet that might as well have been a legal summons. My daughter, eight years old, sat with her arms crossed, staring at a row of subtraction problems. I had already said, “Come on, just do it,” at least four times. She had already said, “I can’t,” at least four times.
I took a breath. I tried to make my voice calm and encouraging.
“Yes, you can. Look. It’s easy.”
Then I did the first problem for her. I pulled her pencil across the paper and wrote “14 – 5 = 9.” I smiled. “See? Just like that.”
She pushed the paper away. Her chin started to tremble. And I felt heat rising in my own chest—not anger, exactly, but the kind of helplessness that makes a parent start saying things like “Why won’t you just try?”
I was so frustrated that I actually found myself asking out loud, to no one in particular, “Someone please tell me what I’m doing wrong.”
That night, after she was in bed and the worksheet was crumpled in the recycling bin, I sent a longer version of that question to her teacher. I expected advice about reward charts or consequences. Instead, she wrote back: “Does she know why she can’t? Ask her to tell you what feels hard.”
So the next afternoon, I tried a different line.
“Is it the borrowing? Or is it just too many problems?”
She shrugged. Then she said, quietly, “Every time I get it wrong, you sigh.”
I hadn’t noticed I was sighing. But she had heard it for weeks.
That was the first real clue that the problem wasn’t math. The problem was my face, my breath, my little impatient movements. Every time she hesitated, I jumped in. Every time she made a mistake, I explained it again, faster. I thought I was helping. She experienced it as a running commentary of everything she was doing wrong.
At the time, it would have helped me to hear something simple: When you feel like your child won’t start, try sitting next to her instead of across from her. Try saying, “Let’s find the spot where it gets confusing,” instead of “You know this.” Try doing one problem together and then letting her do the next one while you stay quiet.
I didn’t know that. I had been operating on a script that said good parents step in, good parents explain, good parents make sure their child gets it. But my stepping in was making my daughter believe she couldn’t get it without me.
It wasn’t just homework. The same pattern showed up when she couldn’t find her shoes, when she resisted putting on her coat, when she stopped wanting to read out loud. I would offer a solution within two seconds of her showing difficulty. She would turn fidgety or tearful. I would feel like the room was collapsing into a pile of undone tasks.
What finally helped wasn’t a technique. It was a shift in what I thought my role was supposed to be.
One evening, I decided to stop being the teacher and start being the observer. We sat down for homework, and I put the worksheet in front of her. I had one rule for myself: Don’t speak until she asks a question. No hints. No corrections. No “good job” after every answer, because even praise, when overused, becomes pressure.
It was one of the hardest thirty minutes I’ve ever spent. I watched her add 27 and 15 on her fingers, get it wrong, erase, do it again. I watched her bite her pencil and look at the clock. I wanted to say something. I physically pressed my lips together.
And then something happened. She talked to herself. “Wait, no. You add the ones first. Twenty-seven plus ten is thirty-seven, plus five is forty-two.” She wasn’t asking me. She was figuring it out.
When she finished, she looked up. There was no triumph on her face, just relief. “I did it,” she said. Not “I did it, Mom!” She said it to the room.
I learned that my silence was more useful than my instruction. Not because instruction is bad—she’s not a child who can learn everything by herself. But because I had been giving her information she hadn’t asked for. It wasn’t landing. It was just noise on top of her own thinking.
Another thing that changed was our setup. We moved homework to the low counter in the kitchen, where I could stand on one side and she could stand on the other. We stopped using the dining table, where the chairs faced each other like we were on opposite teams. Side by side, I could look at the paper when she wanted me to, but she didn’t have to watch my face while she worked.
I also started saying certain phrases on repeat, until they felt less like scripts and more like truth.
“I can see you’re stuck. Let’s find the exact spot.”
“Tell me what the question is asking in your own words.” If she couldn’t, we read it out loud together and then she explained what she heard.
“You don’t have to finish the whole page. We’re just doing these three.”
That last one was huge. So many of her meltdowns were about the size of the task, not the difficulty. A page of twenty problems looked like a mountain. Three problems looked like a staircase. It sounds obvious, but I had never thought to shrink the task. I was too busy trying to motivate her through all twenty.
There were still bad days. Once, she got stuck on a word problem, and I felt that familiar twitch in my jaw. I could hear my own breathing get louder. I caught myself leaning toward her pencil. I had to physically step back and wipe my hands on my jeans. “I think I need a minute,” I told her. I walked to the sink and filled a glass of water. She looked surprised that I was the one who needed a break.
I think that was the moment I understood that the struggle wasn’t all hers. I was bringing my own urgency to her learning. I was treating her hesitation as a problem that needed immediate solving, and she could feel that urgency everywhere. In my sighs. In my hovering. In the way I said “finally” when she finished a problem.
We’re not all the way through the woods. Last week she still refused to practice spelling and announced that she was “too tired to think.” Some days, doing three problems turns into doing fourteen, because the momentum comes back and she wants to keep going. Other days, we close the workbook after four minutes because nothing is landing. I have learned to let that be okay.
I still don’t know exactly what I’m doing wrong. That’s the honest truth. Every time I think I’ve figured out the puzzle, there’s a new piece—a new mood, a new assignment, a new excuse that sounds suspiciously like mine. But I know one thing now: when my daughter says “I can’t,” she usually doesn’t mean “I refuse.” She means “This feels bigger than me.” And if I take a breath, sit beside her, and make the job smaller, she can usually find her way into it.
She might not ever thank me for sitting through that subtraction unit with my mouth shut. But the other day, she looked at a long reading passage and said, “I can do the first paragraph by myself.” She didn’t look at me for approval. She just started reading. I stood there with my hands still, and I didn’t say a word.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Please Tell Me What I’m Doing Wrong: A Parent’s Honest Look at the Homework Wars