What 8th to 12th Graders Wish Adults Understood (From a High School Classroom Teacher)
Last Wednesday, I was erasing algebra notes off my whiteboard after the final bell, half of my students’ essays still stacked ungraded on my desk, and a box of leftover granola bars from student council’s bake sale sitting open by the door. The heat was still cranking from the morning, even though it’s 70 degrees out in April, so I’d cracked the back window to let in the breeze from the football field. That’s when Mia, a 10th grader I’ve had since September, knocked once and leaned in, not with a question about homework like usual. She just asked if she could sit down for a minute.
She slouched into the chair closest to my desk, pulled her hood over her hair, and didn’t say anything for a full minute. I pushed a granola bar across the desk and went back to stacking essays, no pressure. After a bit, she said she couldn’t do it all. The college essay workshop her mom signed her up for is Saturday, that’s the same day she was supposed to work the soccer team car wash and finish her art portfolio for the after-school art class she’s taking to “bolster her college apps.” Her book report for my class is due Monday, and she hasn’t gotten past the second chapter. She kept repeating that she didn’t want to be lazy, she just couldn’t fit it.
That’s the thing no one tells you about teaching 8th through 12th grade: this happens at least once a week. Last year, an 8th grader named Javi stayed after because he failed a history quiz. He didn’t cry about the grade—he cried because he stayed up until 11 helping his little sister finish her volcano project, his mom was working a double shift at the hospital, and he forgot to study. He didn’t want to ask me for a retake because he didn’t want me to think he was making excuses for being irresponsible. Last month, a senior named Leo told me he’d rather fail my quiz than ask for an extension; he works 20 hours a week at the grocery store to help his mom pay for car insurance, and he doesn’t want anyone at school to think he can’t handle college.
Adults look at these kids and see moodiness, or laziness, or lack of motivation. I see kids who’ve been told since 7th grade that every single choice they make now determines the rest of their life. They’ve been told they need to be responsible, they need to build their resume, they need to learn to handle adult pressure now that they’re not little kids anymore. So they learn to carry it all quietly, until they snap or shut down or fail a quiz they could have aced if they’d just had one extra day.
After Mia finished talking, I didn’t pull out a planner and help her rearrange her whole schedule right away. I just said, “That sounds like way too much for one person to handle.” She cried a little, wiped her eyes on her sleeve, and then we talked through what she actually wanted. She already knew she wanted to skip the September college workshop—they offer the same one in October, anyway. She just needed someone to back her up when she told her mom. I sent her mom a quick email that day, I gave Mia an extra two days on the book report no questions asked, and she texted me the next day that she swapped her car wash shift with a teammate who needed extra service hours. None of that was hard. It just required someone to not immediately jump to “you need to manage your time better.”
Over the years, I’ve picked up a few small, concrete things that work for both parents and teachers, and none of them take a lot of extra time. First, stop asking “how was school?” It’s too easy to say “fine” and shut down. Instead, ask “what’s one thing that bugged you this week?” or “what do you wish you had more time for?” I started asking that at the start of class once a week, and half the time I get answers that tell me exactly what’s going on with a kid before they even have to come ask for help.
Second, if they start venting about being overwhelmed, validate it before you problem solve. Say “That’s too much for one person” before you tell them to quit a club or plan their time better. 9 times out of 10, they already know what they need to cut. They just need an adult to agree that it’s okay to cut it, instead of pushing them to keep going for the sake of a resume or a grade. Mia already knew the September workshop wasn’t a big deal; she just needed me to confirm that it wasn’t a failure to skip it for something that mattered more to her.
Third, give them an out that doesn’t require excuses. I give every student one free 48-hour extension per semester, no explanation needed. They don’t have to tell me if they’re sick, or swamped, or just forgot. They just send me a two-line email, and that’s it. A lot of parents have told me they started doing the same thing at home: one free “skip” a week for chores or extra practice if the kid is just too wiped out. It takes away the pressure of having to beg for help or make up a reason to get a break.
Last week, Mia stopped by my room after school and dropped off a chocolate chip cookie from the bake sale. She had her art portfolio printed and tucked under her arm, and she said her mom now asks her before signing her up for anything new. That’s a small win. It’s not a big fix for all the pressure these kids are under, and I still see too many of them carrying more than they should. Some still won’t take the free extension because they’re afraid it’ll look bad to colleges, some parents still think pushing harder is the only way to get them ahead. There’s no big, perfect solution to the weight kids carry these days. But it’s a start. For all the 8th to 12th graders out there reading this: I get it. You don’t have to be done with everything all the time. And for the adults? You don’t have to fix every problem. You just have to give them permission to say they can’t do it all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What 8th to 12th Graders Wish Adults Understood (From a High School Classroom Teacher)