What Are Y’all Being? I’m Being This: How Pretend Play Builds Social Skills
At 9:40 on a Tuesday, my classroom looks like a small tornado hit it. Blocks are scattered across the reading corner, glitter glue has migrated to the craft table, and three kids are arguing over who gets the purple dragon head. Sam has it. He’s wearing it backward, and he says, “I’m being this, okay?” He turns to the wall and flaps his arms like wings. He doesn’t need anyone’s approval. He already knows what he is.
Leo has been crawling around the carpet for a while, rolling his eyes back, waiting. He doesn’t have a costume yet. He hasn’t decided what he is. Maya comes back from the bathroom, sees the group, and walks straight up to Leo. She puts her hands on her hips and asks, “What are y’all being?”
Leo stops. Thinks. Then he curls his fingers into claws. “I’m being this,” he says. “A wolf. A wolf that lives in a cave and doesn’t come out for anyone.”
Maya looks at him. She looks at the dragon. Then she says, “Well, I’m being the one who brings food to the wolf’s cave. So you have to let me in.”
And just like that, the play begins.
I’ve been teaching for eleven years. In that time, I’ve heard one question more than almost any other. It sounds so simple you could miss it entirely: “What are y’all being?”
When I first started teaching, I used to jump in and answer that question for kids. If a child approached a group and I could see they were looking for a way in, I’d say, “How about you be the doctor?” or “Maybe you could be the little sister.” I thought I was helping them join. I thought the problem was that they didn’t have a role.
I’ve learned to stop doing that.
“What are y’all being?” is not actually a request for information. It’s a negotiation. It’s a way of saying, I want to play with you. What do we agree the world is right now? And “I’m being this” is the answer. It’s not a role, exactly. It’s a claim. The child is saying: this is what I am, in this moment, in this space. You can play around it, or resist it, or join it. But I get to define myself before you do.
That’s what makes pretend play so different from everything else we do in a school day. On a worksheet, the answers are already decided. In play, the world is being decided in real time, by the players. Leo’s wolf lasted about four minutes before he got up to get a drink of water. When he came back, the dragon had become a dog, and Maya had become a baby dinosaur. He didn’t insist on his wolf. He just sat down at the little table, looked at what was there, and said, “Okay, but I’m being the dad.”
No one said, “You can’t be the dad because you were the wolf.” They just took it in.
That moment is not trivial. It’s the same set of skills adults use every day: reading the room, figuring out what’s expected, making a bid for inclusion, handling rejection, adjusting course when the plan changes. Kids are practicing all of it. And because the stakes are low—nobody actually gets hurt, nobody is actually left out forever—they get to practice with more bravery than most adults I know.
Here is something I think parents and teachers worry about: what to do when play goes wrong, or doesn’t start. You set up the play area. You put out the dress-up bin and the toy kitchen. And then the kids just stand there, like they’re waiting for something. Or one child takes over. Or a child says, “We’re playing, and you’re not invited.”
I’ve learned that most conflict in imaginative play is not a problem to be fixed. It’s part of the play itself. When a child says, “No, you’re not being a lion, you’re being the sister,” that’s not a rejection—it’s an edit. It’s a suggestion. The play gets stronger when kids are allowed to edit each other, as long as no one is being pushed out entirely.
One thing I try to do now when I see a child hesitate at the edge of a group: I don’t swoop in with a costume. I don’t assign a role. I wait. Most of the time, they have their own doorway. They ask their question—”What are y’all being?”—and they find the crack where they can fit.
If they stay stuck, instead of directing them, I ask the question back: “What would be fun to be right now?” Usually, they already know. They just weren’t sure anyone would take them up on it.
I’ve also stopped thinking of pretend play as a break from real learning. I put it on the schedule the same way I schedule reading. I don’t mean I’m timing it or tracking who can hold an imaginary ice cream cone the longest. I mean I’ve stopped apologizing for it. When a parent walks in and sees the dramatic play corner turned into a submarine, I don’t say, “We’re just playing.” I say, “We’re practicing the hard stuff.”
But not everything in that corner is learning. Some of it is just life. And that’s the part I like best.
On Friday, we were cleaning up. Leo and Maya were carrying costumes back to the wooden box. Maya picked up the purple dragon head and put it on. Her friend asked, “What are you being?” Maya didn’t answer. She just walked toward the shelves, the dragon head swinging. She was being something. She just didn’t have to explain it to anyone.
A minute later, the play ended, the way play always does. Someone’s grandmother arrived early. The snack bell rang. The costumes got tangled, and the argument moved on to who had to untie the knot. There was no neat finish. No final bow. The moment just dissolved.
I don’t know what Maya was being at the end. Probably she didn’t know either.
That’s the lesson I keep coming back to. Adults want certainty. We want to know what we’re being, what the role is, what the plan is. Kids don’t. They’re comfortable leaving the question open. They can say “I’m being this” and let “this” shift into something else five minutes later without needing to explain why.
I’m trying to be more like that. Less like someone who needs to announce the role before stepping into the room. More like a kid who, when asked what they are, simply says, “I’m being this,” and trusts that the rest will follow.
We don’t always need to know what we’re being. We just need to be with people who let us find out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Are Y’all Being