VHS AP Cybersecurity or Honors Spanish 3 for Junior Year: How to Decide for Your Teen
The crinkle of the course selection form cut through the hum of the fridge last February, when my son Javi pushed it across our kitchen table toward me, half-eaten boxed mac and cheese congealing at the edge of his plate. It was 8:30 PM, forms were due to the high school by midnight, and he’d been spinning his dented soccer water bottle for 10 minutes working up to the question. “Should I do the AP Cybersecurity through VHS, or just sign up for Honors Spanish 3 here?”
Javi was gearing up for junior year, and had talked for months about studying computer science in college, after building his own PC from used parts the summer before. Our local high school doesn’t offer AP Cybersecurity in-house, so the only option for the class is through VHS, the Virtual High School online program most districts in our area use to pad out AP offerings. On the other side, his Spanish teacher had already encouraged him to move into Honors, the soccer coach had mentioned a summer exchange program to Costa Rica that required at least Honors Spanish 3 to qualify, and Javi talks to his Puerto Rican abuela on the phone every week, so he already has a built-in reason to keep up with the language.
I almost defaulted to pushing the AP first. All the parent chats I’m in are full of people talking about loading up on STEM APs junior year, how every extra AP makes your application look stronger. That thought popped into my head immediately before I caught myself. I remembered last year, when he took AP Bio through VHS to get an extra science credit. He forgot to check the spam folder where his online teacher sent quiz reminders, missed two deadlines, and ended up cramming three units of material the week before finals. He walked away with a 3 on the exam, which his top choice school doesn’t give credit for anyway, and he was so burnt out he skipped our annual spring camping trip that year just to sleep.
Instead of jumping to an answer, I grabbed the junk mail envelope for a local roofing company that was sitting on top of the recycling bin, flipped it over, and drew a line down the middle. “Let’s just write down every real thing that matters, not the stuff people say is supposed to matter.” Left side: VHS AP Cybersecurity. Right side: Honors Spanish 3.
First line: Time per week. I pulled up the VHS course page and it clearly stated 5 to 7 hours of independent work a week, on top of Javi’s already scheduled AP Calc and AP Lang. Honors Spanish 3 meets every other day in person, and the school’s course guide listed homework at 2 to 3 hours a week max. That went down just as it was, no sugarcoating.
Second line: College credit. I pulled out my phone and pulled up UMass Amherst’s CS department AP credit policy, the school Javi’s had his eye on since we visited for a soccer tournament the year before. They don’t list AP Cybersecurity as eligible for credit at all, it’s still too new of an AP offering for most schools to have updated their policies. Honors Spanish 3, on the other hand, would let him take AP Spanish senior year, which UMass does give credit for if he gets a 4 or 5. That one was a clear split.
Third line: Support. For the VHS class, the website said the teacher only answers emails within 48 hours, no in-person help available. For Honors Spanish, Javi already knows the teacher, Ms. Lopez, and she lets students stop by her room before soccer practice for help twice a week. Javi’s not the kind of kid who chases down teachers for help when he’s stuck, so that point went firmly to Spanish.
Fourth line: Actual outcome, not just “looks good on a transcript”. Cybersecurity would just add another line to his list of classes. Spanish 3 gets him eligible for the exchange, keeps open the option of a Spanish minor in college, and lets him keep practicing for his weekly calls with abuela. Javi added his own line at the bottom: “Stress level”. He wrote “bad” under Cybersecurity, “fine” under Spanish. That was that, he checked the box for Honors Spanish 3 and submitted the form.
It’s easy to get caught up in the idea that every choice you make for junior year makes or breaks your kid’s college chances. I still scroll through parent groups sometimes and see people talking about how their kid has five APs junior year, and I get that little twinge of “did we mess up?” But this semester, I’ve seen what this choice looks like in real life. Javi leaves for practice at 2:30 every day, gets home at 5, eats dinner, does his homework, and still has an hour or so every night to work on that little soccer stats app he’s building for his team. That app’s the first thing he mentions when he talks to college admissions people when they visit our high school, way before he talks about his course load.
If you’re sitting in the same spot we were, with two course options on the table and everyone telling you different things, you don’t need to call ten different parents or hire a college consultant. Just flip over an old envelope and list the concrete stuff. Ask how much time the class will actually take, check if it counts for credit at the schools your kid is actually interested in, think about how much support your kid needs to do well, and what actual opportunity it opens up that the other one doesn’t. It doesn’t matter if it’s an AP or an honors class, what matters is that it fits where your kid is right now.
We won’t know for a few more months if Javi gets into the exchange, or if his application ends up being strong enough for UMass. But for right now, Javi’s not waking up dreading school, he’s got time for the things that matter to him, and that’s more than we had last year. That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » VHS AP Cybersecurity or Honors Spanish 3 for Junior Year: How to Decide for Your Teen