Teacher shares: How my school’s new recess initiative cut playground conflict and what you can try
First Tuesday in October, first week of rolling out our new loose parts recess initiative, I’m patrolling the fence line of my 3rd grade playground, picking up the random stray socks kids leave behind, when a parent volunteer pulls me aside. She’s holding a squashed cardboard tube that split open when a kid swung it like a baseball bat, and her brow is furrowed. “Half this stuff is broken already,” she says, nodding toward the big blue bin in the corner of the blacktop. “Three kids just had a shouting match over a single refrigerator box. Do you really think this is worth all the time we’re putting in?”
She’s not wrong to ask. A year earlier, our school’s discipline data showed 60% of all K-5 office referrals came from recess conflicts. Most of it wasn’t even serious fighting—just kids who didn’t know how to work out a disagreement without running to an adult to fix it. The kids who didn’t like kickball or four square spent the whole 20 minutes leaning against walls, too shy to join the structured games everyone else played. We got a small $500 PTA grant to try something new: loose parts recess. The idea is simple: fill a big bin with clean, safe, donated odds and ends that kids can build, create, or play whatever they want with, no rules beyond no hitting and clean up before you go in. But we couldn’t do it alone—we needed parent and community help to sort donations, man the bin during recess, and learn how to step back instead of stepping in the second something goes wrong.
At first, we did everything wrong when asking for help. We sent a generic school-wide email that said “We need volunteers for our new recess initiative” and got two responses, both from retired teachers who already volunteer three days a week. We had hundreds of pounds of donated cardboard, fabric, and old plastic crates sitting in the janitor’s closet for three weeks because no one was available to sort it. That’s when we adjusted our ask, and that’s the first thing any teacher or parent starting a new school initiative should write down: don’t ask for “help.” Ask for exactly what you need, with a clear time commitment and a clear task. Most of the materials we needed were free anyway—we just asked for clean cardboard boxes, old cotton fabric scraps, and empty plastic crates people were planning to throw out, so we barely spent half our grant money. We sent a new note that said: “We need 1 adult per day, 20 minutes during recess, starting in October. All you need to do is carry the bin out, make sure no one swings big pieces of cardboard, and if kids fight, ask two questions: ‘What do you both want?’ and ‘What can you try to work this out?’ No experience needed.” Suddenly, we had 12 people sign up in three days.
That fight over the refrigerator box the parent pointed out? It turned out to be the perfect example of why this works. Two groups of boys both wanted the box for a rocket ship they were building. The volunteer wanted to step in, cut the box in half, and give each group a piece—what most of us would do, right? Instead, she remembered the two questions, and just said them out loud. Both groups stood there staring for a minute, then one boy said “What if we combine our rocket ship? It can be bigger and hold all of us.” By the end of recess, they had six kids crammed inside, drawing windows on the sides with sidewalk chalk. After that, the volunteer who’d complained came back to me and said “I’ve been solving my grandkids’ fights for years, I never thought to just let them work it out.” She’s been our most consistent volunteer every week since.
It’s not all smooth. We still have days where the bin tips over and cardboard rolls all across the blacktop, and we spend the last five minutes of recess herding it back into the bin. Some weeks we’re short on volunteers, so we just leave the bin in the closet and do regular recess that week. Last month, a kid got a small bump on the arm from a swinging cardboard tube, so we added a new rule that all big pieces have to stay on the ground. We haven’t solved all our recess conflict—we’re still down only 35% from last year, not 100%, which is what a lot of people expect from a new initiative.
What I didn’t expect was how much of this translates straight to home, for parents. I’ve had a lot of parents ask me at conferences what they can do when their kids bicker over toys or come running to them every five minutes to solve every tiny problem. The concrete thing I tell them is to steal the two questions we use at recess. Next time your kids come to you fighting over a tablet or a LEGO set, don’t take sides, don’t split the toy, don’t tell them to just be nice. Just ask: “What do you both want?” and “What can you try to work this out?” If they can’t think of anything, prompt them to each come up with one idea, that’s it. It feels weird at first, like you’re not doing your job as a parent or caregiver. But over time, kids stop expecting you to fix everything, and start figuring it out on their own. I’ve had three parents email me back after trying this to say their mid-day fight count dropped by half in two weeks.
This week, we had all-morning rain, so we dragged the loose parts bin into the gym for indoor recess. A group of 2nd graders built a giant tunnel out of crates and cardboard that collapsed halfway through. No one ran to a teacher crying. They just stepped back, looked at the mess, and started moving the crates to the outside to make it sturdier. I stood next to that same volunteer who questioned everything that first day, and we just watched. We still need more volunteers for next semester, we still haven’t found a storage bin that keeps mice out of the fabric scraps, and we’re still tweaking the rules every few weeks. It’s not perfect, but right now, that’s kind of the point.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Teacher shares: How my school’s new recess initiative cut playground conflict and what you can try