Teacher Reflects: What I Learned When A Struggling Student Got Their Dream College Acceptance
The coffee in my reusable mug had gone cold an hour earlier, and I was picking at a hole in the toe of my sneaker from chasing a group of seventh graders across the soccer field at recess when my phone pinged with an Instagram DM. It was from Mia Carter, a student I had in my 7th grade ELA class six years ago. The message was short: “I got in. I got into the creative writing program at State.” Attached was a blurry photo, Mia grinning with the same side-swept bang I remembered, wearing her coffee shop work apron with a smudge of oat milk on the pocket.
It’s some of the greatest news a student can get, and it caught me completely off guard, mostly because I remembered what things looked like when she was in my class. Back then, Mia was the kid who always had her hood pulled up over her hair, never turned in a writing assignment the first three months of school, and would mumble “I forgot my notebook” when I called on her to share. I sent notes home, called her mom, got nothing back but a single text that said “Working double shifts, can we talk next week?” I marked her down for zero participation every week, frustrated that she wouldn’t even try, until one October afternoon.
We were doing silent reading, and I walked past her desk to see her scribbling furiously in the back of an old pre-algebra workbook she’d stuffed in her backpack. I leaned over to see what she was working on, and she slammed the book shut so fast her eraser clattered to the floor. I told her I wasn’t going to take it, I wasn’t going to give her a detention, I just wanted to see what she’d written. She flipped it back open, slow, and there was three pages of a story about spending the summer at her grandma’s farm, picking strawberries until her fingertips were stained pink for a week. It was vivid, funny, better than most writing I got from 12-year-olds, but half the words were misspelled and there were commas everywhere periods should be—she wrote so fast she never stopped to fix mistakes.
She told me she hated writing for school. Every time she turned something in, it came back covered in red ink, with “fix errors” scrawled at the top, and no one ever mentioned what she’d actually written. She suspected she had dysgraphia, but her mom couldn’t afford the testing or the accommodations back then, so she just stopped turning work in entirely.
I didn’t do anything fancy to fix things. I told her starting that day, she could record her stories on her phone instead of writing them by hand if that was easier, and I’d type them up for her. I told her I’d only mark one grammar skill per assignment to work on, instead of marking every mistake. I told her she could turn work in whenever she finished, no late points, no questions asked. It took almost no extra work from me, just a small shift in how I approached her.
Over the year, she started turning in one story a month. By the end of 8th grade, it was two or three. I saw little snippets of her writing after that, posted to her private Instagram story—poems about her grandma’s farm, about her little brother learning to ride a bike. I ran into her mom at the grocery store two years ago, and she said Mia had graduated high school, got the coffee shop job, kept talking about applying to writing programs but was too scared. Mia still thought she wasn’t a “real writer” because of all the bad grades she got when she was younger.
That’s the part that sticks with me, the part I want other parents and teachers to hear. We spend so much time focused on hitting benchmarks right on schedule, on fixing every gap before a kid moves to the next grade, that we forget growth doesn’t follow a school calendar. A lot of us treat a late start like a permanent failure, but what I’ve seen with Mia is that all she needed was space to grow on her own timeline, and someone to not write her off before she got started.
The practical parts are small, easy for anyone to try. If you’re a teacher working with struggling writers, stop marking every single error on a draft. Pick just one skill to focus on per assignment—this week, we’re working on ending punctuation, next week we’ll work on spelling. It takes 10 extra seconds to adjust your grading, and it keeps kids from looking at a page covered in red ink and deciding they’re just bad at writing. If you’re a parent whose kid doesn’t want to apply to college right after high school, don’t panic. A year or two of working, saving money, and building confidence doesn’t set them back. It gave Mia time to save for application fees, to get the dysgraphia testing she couldn’t afford as a kid, and to decide for herself that she wanted this, instead of being pushed into it before she was ready.
I wrote Mia back this morning, told her I’d buy her coffee next week and we can go over her class schedule if she wants. She wrote back that she’s still scared. She knows she’ll struggle with timed essays, that she’ll need accommodations, that it’ll be harder for her than it is for kids who’ve always had straight A’s in English. But she said she still wants to do it.
I don’t know how it’s going to go. She might love the program, graduate, and go on to write books, or she might decide it’s not for her and do something else that makes her happy. Either way, that DM was the best news I’ve gotten all year. It’s a reminder that the greatest news a student can get isn’t just a spot at their dream school. It’s the chance to go after the thing they love, long after everyone else thought they missed their shot. There’s still a lot of uncertainty ahead, but right now, that’s more than enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Teacher Reflects: What I Learned When A Struggling Student Got Their Dream College Acceptance