Should My Teen Go To Boarding School? Practical Tips For Deciding
I was folding my 14-year-old daughter Lila’s crumpled soccer uniform at the kitchen table last month, halfway through a half-eaten blueberry pop-tart, when she pushed her phone across the Formica. The screen glowed with an open house invite for a boarding arts high school an hour and a half from our house. “Mia from bio goes there,” she said, kicking the leg of my chair gently. “Says there’s none of the middle school drama that follows everyone to high school here.” I tucked the uniform into her drawer and didn’t say anything for five minutes, because I’d been casually tossing the idea around in my head since she came home crying last fall after her best friend spread rumors about her, but I didn’t expect her to bring it up first.
Two weeks later we drove up for the open house. The campus was draped in old oak trees, the dorms smelled like fresh paint and lemon cleaning spray, with two girls per room, built-in desks, and little window seats looking out over the soccer fields. We ran into a mom in the campus coffee shop who told us her 10th grader had been there a year, and they used to fight every single night about homework and screen time. Now they text once a day and have a long, slow dinner every time he comes home, and most of the fighting is gone. Lila pulled me into the hallway after the art studio tour, her cheeks pink, and said “They have open studio until 9pm every night. I never get that here.”
I started overthinking after that. I texted my sister, who’s a public high school counselor, and she said half the parents she works with ask about boarding school now, and most don’t know where to start. Everyone online either says it’s the best thing for building self-reliance or it’s cruel to send your kid away that young, no in between. I didn’t know what to do, so I started small, with stuff any family can do, no extra cost or stress.
First, instead of asking “do you really want to go?” which is too big a question for a 14 year old to answer honestly, I asked her three specific questions when we stopped for ice cream on the drive home. First: “What’s the first thing you’d do on your first free weekend there?” Second: “What’s the one thing you’d miss most that you can’t get at school or from a vending machine?” Third: “If you hate it after one semester, what do you want us to do?” Her answers weren’t what I expected, and they told me more than any big vague talk ever could. First, she said she’d go straight to the pottery studio and make a mug, no rushing because of homework or soccer practice. Second, she said she’d miss our weekly taco Tuesdays and the dog’s morning snuggles in my bed when I’m getting ready for work. Third, she said “I want to come home. No guilt, no ‘you have to stick it out for a year.’ Just come home.” That told me she wasn’t running away forever, she just wanted a do-over, and she knew we had a back door. That was a big relief for both of us.
Next, I called the admissions office and asked them to connect me to two parents: one whose kid was still attending, and one whose kid left within the first two years. Most schools only connect you to happy parents who’ll sing their praises, but this one said yes, no questions. The mom whose kid left told me her daughter had bad asthma and couldn’t handle the 10-minute walk from the dorms to the main building in winter, and the school didn’t allow exceptions to the sports requirement for kids with health issues. She said she wished she’d asked about flexible requirements before putting in the application, not just after things fell apart. The mom whose kid was still there told me her son has social anxiety, and the 10-minute morning check-in with his dorm parent works way better than me nagging him about his mood every night, because he doesn’t see it as nagging, just a quick routine check-in. That made me let go of the old idea I had that boarding school is only for “troubled” kids or wealthy kids; it’s just a different setup that works for some kids and not others.
The concrete step I’m doing right now, before we even send in the application, is a two-week independence trial. I stopped reminding Lila to do anything that she’d have to do on her own at boarding school. She sets her own alarm, packs her own lunch, does her own laundry on her schedule, and schedules her homework and practice around her after-school activities, no reminders from me. The first two days were messy: she slept through her first period, forgot her lunch and had to buy a sad bag of chips from the vending machine, and turned her favorite pink hoodie gray when she washed it with her dark jeans. But by the end of the first week, she moved her phone from under her pillow to the dresser outside her room so she could hear her alarm, and she remembered to add detergent to the grocery list when we went shopping, which I didn’t even have to mention.
We still haven’t decided. We’re putting the application in this week, just to have the option, and we’ll see what happens over the rest of the trial. Some nights I lie awake worrying that she’ll think I’m pushing her away, that she’ll get a stomach bug in the middle of the night and no one will take care of her like I would. Other nights I think about how she comes home every day drained from all the drama here, and how she lights up when she talks about that pottery studio, and it feels like the right call. There’s no perfect answer here, I think. The big mistake I see other parents make is deciding based on what other people think, or what they read online that’s all black and white. The small steps – asking specific questions, talking to parents who had both good and bad experiences, testing out what independence would actually look like for your kid at home first – that’s the stuff that actually helps you figure it out, no matter what you end up choosing.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should My Teen Go To Boarding School