Should I Put the Fries in the Bag? Parenting Tips For Encouraging Kid Independence In Small Daily Moments
It was 6:15 on a Tuesday, my back ached from sitting on splintered bleachers through 7-year-old Jax’s soccer practice, and the car already reeked of half-drunk blue Gatorade and clipped grass. We were next at the drive-thru, Jax’s turn for a post-practice treat, and the cashier handed him a crumpled paper meal bag and a separate cardboard container of fries. He held them for a second, looked up at me from the passenger seat, and asked, “Mom? Should I put the fries in the bag?”
The car behind us hummed, the cashier waited with her hand on the next order, and I had 2 seconds to decide. My first instinct was to reach over, take the container, tuck it into the bag myself, and hit the gas. We were already late for getting home to start dinner, and Jax would probably fumble it, drop half the fries on the floor mat that I just vacuumed last Saturday, and crumple the bag so the burger got squashed.
But I paused. I’d been noticing lately how often Jax asks me that question, for everything that’s not even a big deal. Should I hang my towel up? Should I put my sneakers by the door? Should I push the button for the crosswalk? I’d been doing so many small things for him without thinking, just because it’s faster, just because I can do it neater.
So I leaned back and said, “What do you think? Go for it.”
He frowned a little, adjusted his grip on the bag, and tilted the fry container to slide it in. One curly fry slipped out and bounced onto the center console, but the rest fit, lopsided as it was. He pushed the container the rest of the way in, crumpled the top of the bag to close it, and grinned at me. “I did it.”
I pulled forward to the window, and that got me thinking. We talk a lot about kid independence as this big, high-stakes thing: when do they get their first phone, when do they walk to the bus stop alone, when do they do their homework without reminding? But the question of putting fries in the bag isn’t about big milestones. It’s one of a hundred tiny, 10-second moments every day where we can choose to step back, or step in.
I volunteer in Jax’s first grade classroom once a week, and I see this play out all the time. A kid finishes an art project, holds up the paper and glue stick, and looks at the teacher asking if they should put it in their cubby. Before the kid can even move, the teacher takes the project from them, tucks it into the cubby, and hurries everyone to line up for recess. It’s faster, it’s easier, no one leaves their project on the floor by accident. But that kid doesn’t get to practice that small step.
Over the few months since that drive-thru trip, I’ve tested out a small routine that’s way easier than it sounds. When Jax asks “Should I [insert tiny mundane thing here]?” I don’t jump in to do it for him, and I don’t just give him a yes or no answer. I have three go-to phrases I use, depending on the situation: “What do you think?” “Give it a try, I’ll help if it goes wrong,” or “It’s okay if it’s messy.”
Last week, we were packing for his field trip to the zoo, and he held up his water bottle and asked, “Should I put it in the side pocket of my backpack?” My first thought was No, it’ll fall out on the bus, I’ll just put it in the main compartment like I always do. Instead I said, “Try it. Check if the pocket fits.” He stuffed it in, pulled the drawstring tight around the top, and shook the backpack a little. It didn’t fall out. It stayed put all day, and he told me on the way home that he could get it out when he was thirsty without asking a chaperone for help. That’s something he never would’ve figured out if I’d just done it for him.
Of course, it doesn’t always go right. Last month, he decided to put his unzipped juice box in his snack bag, and it leaked all over his crayons and his reading workbook. I didn’t clean it up for him, and I didn’t say I told you so. I just grabbed a stack of paper towels and said, “Let’s wipe this up together. What do you think you can do differently next time?” He thought for a second, and said, “I’ll check that it’s closed before I put it in.” That’s a lesson he’ll remember way longer than if I’d just checked it for him.
And I don’t do this every single time. Some days we’re running late for his older sister’s piano recital, or I’m exhausted and just want to get through the grocery store, and when he asks I just say “Honey, I got this, let’s go.” That’s fine. It’s not an all-or-nothing rule. It’s just about choosing to step back more often than I step in, when I have 10 extra seconds to spare.
We still get fries after soccer practice most Tuesdays. Jax still asks me sometimes, should I put the fries in the bag? More often now, he just does it without asking, even if the bag is lopsided and there’s always at least one fry on the floor. I vacuum it up at the end of the week. It’s a small mess, for a small win that adds up. I still mess this up a lot, I still do too much for him when I’m in a hurry. But that 2-second question at the drive-thru reminded me that independence isn’t something we teach kids in one big talk. It’s just letting them put the fries in the bag.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should I Put the Fries in the Bag