My Teen Wants to Major in Medicine: What I Wish I’d Asked First
The dryer was still humming behind me, cheese dust crumbing the edge of our kitchen table, when my 17-year-old Lila folded her soccer hoodie and dropped the question last October. “Mom, I think I want to do pre-med. Major in medicine, eventually.” I almost dropped the fitted sheet I was wrestling. My first thought was the number I’d seen floating online: $200,000 in average student debt for med school. Then ten years of school before she even earns a real paycheck. Then burnout, then all the sad stories you hear about overworked doctors. But I bit all that back, because I’d just talked to my sister, a high school guidance counselor, who’d said most parents mess this up before the kid even finishes their sentence.
Lila has always been the kid who stops to bandage every stray cat’s paw and tucks a first-aid kit in her backpack for every field trip. Two years ago, when my mom had six months of chemo, Lila showed up every weekday after school, kept a color-coded notebook of symptoms and medication times, and learned how to inject the anti-nausea pen when my hands shook too bad. That’s when she first started talking about working in medicine, and I’d brushed it off as a nice, kind thought for a teen to have. I didn’t expect her to bring it up as an actual plan.
My sister told me the common mistakes: either you immediately start bragging to all your friends about how your kid’s going to be a doctor, because it’s such a “good, impressive” path, or you immediately panic and start listing every reason it’s a terrible idea. Neither helps the kid actually think through what they want. Instead, she gave me a couple specific questions to ask, that don’t feel confrontational, but get past the surface level answer.
First, I asked her, “What’s the part of this that actually makes you excited, not the part that looks cool on TV?” I expected her to say something about saving lives or working in an ER. Instead she leaned back against the fridge and said it was the chemo appointment. After one visit, grandma came home confused, the doctor had changed her pain dose and didn’t write it down or tell anyone. Lila called the office, sorted it out with the nurse, and grandma slept through the night for the first time in a week. “That’s the part,” she said. “No one else was paying attention, and I fixed it. That felt better than any A I ever got on a test.”
Next, I asked, “What’s the hardest part you’ve already read about, and do you still think it’s worth it?” I didn’t have to bring up debt or long hours; she’d already done her reading. She said she knew most residents work 60 to 80 hour weeks, that she’d probably be in her 30s before she paid off all her student loans, that some days you’ll do everything right and a patient will still die. “That scares me,” she said. “But I’d rather do that than sit at a desk all day doing something I don’t care about, just because it’s easier.”
The next concrete step my sister suggested was a short job shadow, no fancy connections needed. I emailed our family doctor, who’s known Lila since she was little, and she agreed to let Lila tag along for two afternoons. It wasn’t a big shadowing program for pre-med students, just a couple days of seeing what the job actually looks like. Lila came home the second day and said she had no idea half the job was typing notes into a computer or arguing with insurance companies about coverage. She saw a patient yell at the doctor for 20 minutes because his pain medication wasn’t approved, and she said it made her stomach hurt so bad she had to step out into the hallway for a minute. But when I asked if that changed her mind, she just shook her head. “That’s just part of it, right?” she said.
After that, we sat down one night and wrote three different paths on a poster board, and taped it to the fridge. No ranking, no bias, just the facts. First path: full pre-med undergrad, straight to med school, 10 years total, estimated debt range. Second: get a nursing degree first, work as an RN for a couple years, then go to med school or become a nurse practitioner, less debt, earlier paycheck. Third: major in public health, work for a couple years, then decide if med school is still what she wants. It took an hour, it’s just hanging there where she can see it whenever she wants, and it’s a lot more helpful than me just saying “think about your options.”
A lot of my mom friends say I’m too laid back, that I should push her to pick something cheaper or faster. But when I was Lila’s age, my parents talked me out of majoring in environmental science because they said it didn’t pay well enough, and I still think about that sometimes. I don’t want that regret for Lila. At the same time, I don’t want her to jump into 10 years of school just because it sounds impressive, without knowing what she’s getting into.
Right now, she’s filling out college applications. She’s got six pre-med programs on her list, and two public health programs just to keep her options open. Last week, we were leaving the grocery store, and an older lady dropped her cane in the parking lot, spilled all her groceries too. Lila ran over, helped her pick everything up, got her cane, walked her to her car, and made sure she could drive okay. When we got back in our car, she grinned at me and said “That’s the good part, right there.” I nodded.
I still lie awake sometimes worrying about the debt, about her burning out before she even finishes residency. But that’s how all big choices go, isn’t it? We don’t get to know how it will turn out. All we can do is ask the right questions, help her see what she’s getting into, and let her decide. That’s where we are right now, and that feels like enough for today.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Teen Wants to Major in Medicine: What I Wish I’d Asked First