My Soon-To-Be 7-Year-Old Wants Coffee At Breakfast: Why This Happens And What I Tried
The jam jar is still open on the table, my 4-year-old is sweeping blueberry crumbs onto the floor with his sleeve, and Lila, six days out from her seventh birthday, is staring across the table at my steaming oat latte like it’s a unicorn she’s just spotted in the backyard. “Can I have some?” she says, not a question, more of a statement of what she’s decided she deserves. I’d automatically said no to this request a dozen times before, but this time I pause, the wipe I’m holding hovering over my son’s sticky cheek.
“You don’t like coffee,” I say. “Last time you had a sip you made a face like you ate a lemon.” “That was last year,” she says, sitting up straighter, pushing her pigtails over her shoulders. “I’m almost seven now. All the moms at soccer drink coffee at drop off. Mia gets a tiny cup every Saturday. Why can’t I?”
I gave her a tiny sip that morning, just a drop on the edge of her spoon. She made that lemon face anyway, but she wiped her mouth and nodded like she’d passed a test. “It’s good,” she insisted. “I want my own every breakfast now.”
I’d always operated under the assumption that coffee for kids was an automatic no, full stop. I flipped through the latest pediatric guidelines that night after the kids were in bed, just to check. Turns out, the official line is that caffeine should be limited for kids under 12, but a small amount (less than 100 mg a day, which is about the amount in a full 8oz cup of regular coffee) isn’t dangerous. That’s way less than the caffeine in a lot of popular soda and sports drinks kids sneak at birthday parties anyway, so this wasn’t exactly a public health emergency in my house. What it was, though, was a reminder that this age—six turning seven—isn’t about what they want, it’s about what that thing represents.
Lila’s been collecting little grown up privileges for months now. She begged to walk from the car to the school gate by herself, instead of holding my hand. She picked out her own “big girl” toothbrush with glitter on the handle, and insisted she can brush her teeth without me checking. She wears my old fuzzy slippers around the house even though they’re three sizes too big, because they’re mine. Wanting coffee isn’t about the bitter, warm drink. It’s about wanting to be the kind of person who drinks coffee at breakfast. The kind of person who does what grown ups do.
I didn’t want to just say no, because I’ve learned that automatic no’s just make the thing more interesting. If I told her coffee was only for grown ups, she’d spend the next six months sneaking sips out of my mug when I wasn’t looking, right? Instead, I met her halfway with a set of clear, specific rules we could both live with. First, I said, I’ll make you your own “breakfast coffee” on weekends only. Weekdays are too rushed, and I don’t want any extra caffeine making you wiggly during your morning reading block. Second, it’s mostly warm milk, with just a tiny splash of my coffee, so it’s not too strong. Third, you get to use the small chipped blue mug that was mine when I was a kid, so it’s your special grown up mug.
If I’d been uncomfortable with even that tiny bit of caffeine, we could have done the exact same thing with decaf chamomile tea or warm cocoa dyed a little brown to look like coffee, poured into that special big mug. The point isn’t the coffee. It’s the ritual, the feeling that she gets to participate in the grown up part of our morning, instead of just being a kid who drinks orange juice while mom drinks coffee. I gave this same advice to a friend when her 6-year-old started asking for wine at family dinner, and she did exactly that: gave him sparkling grape juice in a clear wine glass, and he never asked again. It works the same way for coffee.
The first Saturday after we made our rule, Lila carried that blue mug to the table herself, set it down right next to mine, and puffed out her chest like she’d just gotten a promotion at work. She drank maybe a third of it, because it’s still too bitter for her kid taste buds, but she sat there next to me while I read the news and she flipped through her Dog Man comic, and she looked prouder than she did when she lost her first tooth.
Last week, she begged for coffee on a Wednesday before school, because we had a snow delay and had extra time. I reminded her of our rule, and she pouted for a full two minutes, slouched in her chair and crossed her arms. But she didn’t throw a fit, because the rule wasn’t me rejecting her—it was a boundary we agreed on together. She got her orange juice, and that was that.
Last weekend, she brought her special blue coffee mug to her pre-birthday playdate, and showed all her friends how she drinks coffee just like mom. Mia’s mom laughed and gave her a tiny extra splash from her own mug, and Lila came home talking about how it was the best party ever. I don’t know if this is the perfect way to handle it. Some of my mom friends think I’m crazy for letting her have any coffee at all, and others say I should just let her have a full cup if she wants it. For right now, though, it’s working. She’s still asleep by 8:30 every night, she’s still growing just fine, and she gets to practice being a big kid in a tiny, low-stakes way. Growing up isn’t just all the big milestones people talk about. It’s a hundred tiny little requests, a hundred small ways they ask you to see them as the person they’re becoming, not just the little kid they used to be. This time, it’s coffee at breakfast. Next time, it’ll probably be something else. For now, this is enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Soon-To-Be 7-Year-Old Wants Coffee At Breakfast: Why This Happens And What I Tried