“Just Refer Me to the Dean”: Why Some Students Ask for Consequences — and What to Do Instead
It was second period in late spring, and the classroom smelled like floor cleaner mixed with leftover heat from the hallway. Maya had her phone wedged under her thigh, screen glowing just enough to catch my attention. I walked over and said quietly, “Phone away, please.” She gave it another second, then looked up with a flat expression. “Fine. Just refer me to the dean.”
The room went quiet. A kid two rows over turned around. Maya had always been one of those students who doesn’t cause trouble—she does enough work, never talks back, disappears into the middle. So her words landed differently than if they had come from a student known for arguing.
I didn’t send her. I said, “I’m not referring you. Put the phone in your backpack and finish your assignment.” She blinked, tucked it away, and picked up her pencil. The moment passed. But it stayed with me.
In my first couple years teaching, I probably would have referred her. The phrase itself is a trigger. A student asks for a consequence, and something in the script says, Okay, they want punishment, let’s give it to them. But over time I’ve learned that when a kid asks to be sent to the dean, they’re not accepting responsibility. They’re asking for an exit.
Think about what a referral actually does. If I sent Maya, she’d walk down to the office, wait on a hard plastic chair, get a talking-to, maybe a detention slip. She’d miss the fifteen minutes left of class. She’d come back looking relieved, or angry, or sometimes both. And the problem—her phone, her attention, her place in the room—would still be there tomorrow. The referral wouldn’t solve anything. It would just give both of us a way out.
Maya wasn’t being defiant, at least not the way it looked. She wanted out of the moment. Out of the awkwardness of being caught. Out of the assignment she was stuck on. Out of a quiet room full of people. When a student says “refer me,” they’ve already decided that being removed is easier than staying and working through whatever just happened.
That’s why I’ve started treating requests for punishment differently. If a student asks, “Just send me to the office,” I don’t take the bait. I’ll say something like, “I’m not sending you. You’re staying here with us.” Not harsh. Just matter-of-fact. The message is: This is not a door. You don’t get to leave because things got uncomfortable.
At the same time, I’ve learned to keep my voice low and give a simple choice. “You can put the phone on my desk or in your backpack. Your choice.” Or, “You can move to the empty desk by the window, or you can stay where you are and get started on the first question.” This sounds small, but it matters. A kid who’s about to spiral needs a boundary that isn’t also a punishment. When you give them a choice between two acceptable options, they can save face and still stay in the room.
The interesting part was what happened when I asked Maya about it after class. I called her up to my desk while everyone else was packing their bags. I said, “Maya, when you asked me to refer you earlier, I want to know what was going on.” She shrugged and looked at the floor. Then she said, “My grandmother was supposed to text me after her doctor’s appointment. I was waiting for it.” That changed things.
The phone wasn’t rebellion. It was worry. It was a fifteen-year-old stuck in class with something on her mind, not knowing how to say it. I told her that if she had something urgent on her phone, she could come ask me and I’d help her figure out a way to check it—or she could write herself a note on the edge of her assignment so she’d remember to check after class. She seemed surprised. “You’d let me go to the bathroom to check?” I said, “If you came and asked, yes.” She didn’t end up needing to. But the conversation mattered more than the policy.
A few weeks later, I had a conference with Maya’s mom. She brought up the phone incident before I did. “She told me she asked to get sent to the dean,” her mom said. “I know she does that at home too. She’ll forget to unload the dishwasher, and when I call her on it, she says, ‘Just ground me then.’” The mom looked tired. “I did ground her once. She didn’t care. It was like she’d rather have the punishment than sit at dinner with us.”
This made me think about how often we assume punishment is the heaviest thing we can offer a kid. Sometimes it’s the lightest. Being grounded, being referred, being excluded—these are consequences that free a child from having to deal with the problem face-to-face. For a kid who feels anxious or ashamed, it can be a lot easier to take a punishment than to sit in the mess, apologize, and fix the damage.
What worked with Maya’s mom was shifting the focus from consequences to presence. Instead of grounding Maya, she tried something different: the next time Maya avoided cleanup, Mom didn’t argue. She just said, “You’re not grounded. You’re staying at the table while we talk, and we’re going to finish this before the TV goes on.” Same principle as the classroom. The child has to stay in the room and deal.
Not every situation can be handled this way. Sometimes a student needs to be removed because they’ve crossed a line and need a break, or because other kids need to feel safe. But when a student asks to be referred, I’ve learned to pause. Ask yourself: What is this kid trying to get away from? Then ask: How can I make this less about punishment and more about staying?
Maya finished the year in my class. She never asked to be referred again. That doesn’t mean she became a model student—she still occasionally drifted, still forgot her pencil, still had days when her head wasn’t in the room. But the moment she realized I wasn’t going to show her the way out? Something opened. Not a clean resolution, just a turning point. She knew I’d hold the door closed, kindly, and that was enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » “Just Refer Me to the Dean”: Why Some Students Ask for Consequences — and What to Do Instead