Is your kid’s unstructured free time a waste of time? What I learned as a mom and 4th grade teacher
Last Tuesday, I was hunched over my kitchen table grading 4th graders’ book reports, half-listening to my 8-year-old, Eli, rustling around on the floor beside me. My neighbor popped in with a plate of her slightly burnt chocolate chip cookies, and nodded at Eli where he sat cross-legged, dumping a bin of old bottle caps and mismatched Lego bricks into little piles across the rug. He wasn’t building anything. Just moving the piles around, counting under his breath sometimes, then starting over. “Isn’t that a waste of time?” she asked, quiet enough so Eli couldn’t hear. “Shouldn’t he be working on his reading log or that math flash card thing you mentioned? It seems like such a shame to let all that after-school time go to nothing.”
I didn’t have an answer for her right then, but I get the question. Three years ago, I would’ve agreed with her completely. When I first started teaching, I filled every single minute of my class block. Bell ringer the second the bell rang, 20 minutes of grammar, 40 minutes of reading, no extra time for chatting, no doodling allowed because it distracted from the lesson. Last year, we got a new paraeducator who pulled me aside after read aloud one day and pointed out Javi, a quiet 9-year-old who drew tiny dinosaurs all along the margins of every notebook he owned. “He never looks up when you’re reading,” she said. “That’s a waste of class time, right? Should we make him put the pencil away?”
I almost did. I’d done it to a dozen other doodlers before. But that day, I stopped at his desk on my way to take attendance and leaned over. “You draw really good dinosaurs,” I said. He nodded, didn’t look up, but didn’t stop drawing either. Ten minutes later, I asked the class a question I’d been saving for our end of unit discussion: Why do you think the main character, an old T-Rex who wouldn’t let any other dinosaurs near his valley, acted so mean? No one had an answer that went beyond “he was bad.” Then Javi raised his hand. “He was lonely,” he said. “He didn’t know how to ask anyone to play, so he just made them stay away. I draw my dinosaurs alone like that when I miss my old best friend.”
That answer stuck with me. I went home that night, looked at Eli who was rearranging his rock collection for the third time that week, and realized I’d been seeing “wasted time” all wrong. For a long time, we’ve been told that any time kids spend without a clear, measurable goal is wasted. If they’re not learning a skill, if it’s not going to show up on a test or a report card, it’s just time thrown away. I bought into that hard, both at school and at home. Eli’s after school used to be scheduled down to 15 minute blocks: 30 minutes homework, 20 minutes reading, 20 minutes piano practice, 15 minutes flash cards, and only then could he have “free time.” He started having meltdowns every Sunday night, and by first grade his teacher told me he was wiggly and distracted during class all the time. I was the one who’d drained all his extra energy before he even got to school.
I started making small changes, first in my classroom, then at home. The first thing I do now is if I’m tempted to interrupt something that looks like a waste of time, I set a timer for 15 minutes and keep doing what I’m doing. More often than not, kids don’t need me to redirect them. Eli will sit and sort bottle caps for 20 minutes, then he’ll get up on his own, grab his reading log, and plop down on the couch to do it. Half the time, that “wasted” time is him working through something big: a fight with a friend, a scary test the next day, a weird dream he had. He can’t talk about it right away; he has to move his hands around something small while he sorts it out in his head. In class, I started giving 10 minutes of unstructured margin time at the start of the day, before we do any work. Kids can doodle, chat quietly about their weekend, fidget with stress balls, whatever they want. I don’t have to remind kids to stay on task anymore, because they got all their chatting and wiggles out before we start. I’ve also had way fewer kids asking to leave class for drinks or bathroom breaks mid-lesson, which saves more time than the 10 minutes we “lose” at the start of the day.
Another small habit I’ve picked up is I ask myself one question before I step in: Whose goal is this? If Eli’s homework is due tomorrow, and he’s playing right now, that’s not a waste of time to him. He’s taking a break after a full day of school. I can shift homework to after dinner, which only takes five minutes longer anyway. Last month, he spent an hour building a ramp for his toy car that only worked one out of 10 times. I almost told him to quit and get started on his spelling words. But I asked the question, and realized my goal was to check spelling practice off my to-do list. His goal was to figure out why the ramp kept tilting. That’s not a waste. He ended up propping it up on a stack of books and got the car to work three times in a row, and came running to tell me all about it. That’s problem solving I can’t teach him with a spelling worksheet.
I still have days where the doubt creeps in. When Eli spends a whole rainy Saturday doing nothing but rearranging his sticker collection and watching old clips of people opening slime, I catch myself thinking that this is all just a waste. Other parents tell me all the time that their kids do two sports and a coding class after school, and I wonder if I’m letting him fall behind. But last month, Javi turned that dinosaur doodle story he’d been working on in the margins of his notebook into a short story that won our school’s young writers contest. The other week, Eli looked up from his bottle cap piles out of the blue and said, “I think I know why Mia was mad at me yesterday. I didn’t let her pick the game at recess. I’ll say sorry tomorrow.” That answer came out of 25 minutes that looked like nothing to anyone on the outside. It’s not going to show up on any test score, it doesn’t check any box on my parenting to-do list. But it wasn’t a waste. And most of the time, the things that look like wasted time aren’t. They just look that way because we’ve forgotten that growing up isn’t all checking boxes. I’m still getting used to it, but it’s working for us, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is your kid’s unstructured free time a waste of time