Is My Kid’s Unstructured Downtime A Waste Of Time? What I Learned As A Mom And Teacher
I was standing at the kitchen sink last Saturday, wiping raspberry jam off my 7-year-old Luka’s toast plate, staring through the smudged window at our backyard. Luka was just sitting on the rusted old swing set, twisting the chain around his wrist over and over, staring at a line of ants crawling up the picnic table leg. My phone buzzed in my sweatpants pocket, the reminder I’d plugged in a week earlier popping up: 10am extra art practice, spring recital prep. The art teacher had emailed the night before to say Luka had real talent, and extra sessions would help him get a featured spot if we committed.
I wiped my hands on my apron and turned toward the back door, ready to call out that we needed to leave in 20 minutes and hurry him along. Before I opened the door, I caught myself thinking it: This is such a waste of time. What good is sitting here twisting chains and watching bugs when he could be learning something, working toward something?
As a 4th grade teacher and a mom, I have this thought at least once a week. It pops up when a parent emails me asking if our daily 20 minutes of silent reading is a waste of time when their kid could be doing extra math worksheets instead. It came up last month at parent-teacher conferences, when a grandma asked if we should make her grandson stop drawing Pokemon on every worksheet margin—wasn’t that taking time away from real learning? I’ve had it when Luka spends an hour rearranging his rock collection by size instead of finishing his weekly reading log, when he builds the same easy Lego set three weekends in a row instead of tackling the new, harder set I bought him for his birthday. We’re all conditioned to think that every minute needs a clear goal, a tangible outcome, a skill to check off a list. If it doesn’t, it’s wasted.
That Saturday, I paused. My retired neighbor, who used to run a preschool out of her house, was walking her dog past our fence, and she stopped to watch Luka too. She waved and called over, “Looks like he’s working hard to me.” I laughed and said I was just thinking it was a waste of time. She shook her head and said, “I spent 20 years of my career telling parents that the stuff that looks like nothing is actually the stuff that does the most.”
I thought about Mia, the student I had last semester who spent the first 10 minutes of every writing workshop just doodling in the corner of her paper. I’d been reminding her for weeks to get started on her story, her parents had asked multiple times if she was falling behind, we all wrote off the doodling as a distraction, a waste of class time. Then one day I stopped by her desk to check in, and I looked closer at her drawings. She’d drawn 17 different cats, each with a little hand-drawn name tag: Moira the baker, Gary the mail carrier, Lila the vet. When I asked her about them, she started talking, and by the end of the period she’d turned those doodles into a 3-page story about a cat neighborhood that solved a mystery. That story ended up winning our district’s young writer’s award a few months later. If I’d made her stop doodling and start writing the second the bell rang, she never would’ve come up with it.
That’s the thing I’ve started to learn: it’s not a waste of time just because you can’t see the product right away. I’ve come up with two quick questions I ask myself now before I interrupt Luka or a student to redirect them to something “more productive.” First: Is anyone getting hurt, or is anything getting broken that can’t be fixed? Second: Are they engaged, even if what they’re doing looks silly or pointless? If both answers are yes, I step back for at least 15 minutes. If I’m feeling antsy about the lost time, I set a timer on my phone so I don’t give in to the urge to interfere. If I’m curious what they’re getting out of it, I ask one simple question: “What are you working on?” More often than not, they’ll tell you exactly what’s going on—they’re decompressing after a hard week, they’re following an idea that popped into their head, they’re practicing a small skill without even realizing it.
That Saturday, I texted the art teacher and said we’d skip the extra practice that week, we’d stick to our regular class. I grabbed my coffee and went outside to sit on the grass next to the swing. Luka told me the ants were moving crumbs from his dropped peanut butter sandwich to a new nest under the oak tree, and he’d counted 12 different worker ants so far. He’d been there 45 minutes, and he’d already figured out that the bigger ants carried bigger crumbs, and they left a trail so other ants could find the food. That wasn’t nothing.
That’s not to say nothing is ever a waste of time. I step in when Luka mindlessly scrolls short videos for an hour after school—he’s not engaged, he’s just zoning out, and he always ends up cranky and bored. The difference is active engagement vs. empty distraction. The unstructured stuff that holds their attention isn’t empty.
In my classroom, I started leaving 10 minutes at the end of every day for unstructured time a year ago. Kids can draw, talk quietly, play with the bin of blocks in the corner, or just sit and look out the window. I used to fill every minute with instruction, worried that any gap was wasted. Six months in, two students who’d been struggling with multiplication built their own dice practice game out of construction paper during that free time. They played it every day for two weeks, and by the end they both passed their times tables test. I never would’ve assigned that game, and it worked better than any worksheet I had.
I still have bad days where I get caught up in the productivity hype. Last weekend, when Luka spent two hours building a cardboard fort that collapsed 10 minutes after he finished it, my husband asked if we’d just wasted a whole afternoon we could’ve used to grocery shop and go to the park. I still worry sometimes that all this “wasted time” will add up, that Luka will fall behind his peers who have more structured afternoons, more trophies, more checked-off skill lists.
But last week, Luka brought home his first big science project for school. His topic was ant colony social structure. He got an A, and he told his teacher he got the idea from that Saturday he spent sitting on the swing watching ants. I don’t know if he’ll remember that afternoon 10 years from now, or if it’ll get him into college, or if it’ll turn him into a biologist. But it taught me something. The time that looks wasted from the outside isn’t always wasted. Some of it’s just growing that we can’t see yet.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Unstructured Downtime A Waste Of Time