Is It Safe To Use Photos Of Your Child For Personalized Products On Websites? What Parents Need To Know
Last week, I stood in the checkout line at the grocery store, scrolling my phone while my 7-year-old picked out a blue raspberry lollipop, and a pop-up ad caught my eye. It was for custom back-to-school sneakers: upload a photo of your kid, get their face printed all over the toes, $25, free shipping. A quick scroll through the comment section was full of moms gushing about how cute their matching lunch bag and water bottle sets turned out. I’d gotten similar ads for months—custom Christmas ornaments, personalized storybooks, photo puzzles for family game night—so I tapped through, stared at the grid of my daughter’s soccer photos on my camera roll, and then paused. I’d just sat through a 90-minute digital safety workshop for parents at her elementary school the night before, and the facilitator’s offhand question was still ringing in my head: when you upload that photo to a random website, do you know where it ends up after your product ships?
I’ll admit, I’d never thought about it before. Two years ago, I ordered a personalized step stool for my niece’s third birthday, uploaded a candid my sister sent me of her covered in cake, and never gave it a second thought. Three years ago, I ordered a custom storybook for my daughter’s fifth birthday, where she was the main character, and uploaded her preschool photo for the dedication page. That photo sat in my camera roll until last month, when I did a reverse image search to find the original file to print for her grandma, and it popped up on a random discount parenting product site I’d never visited. It was being used as the example photo for their own line of custom storybooks, right there next to three other kids I didn’t know, all pulled from customer uploads, I assumed.
That same night, I texted my cousin who works in operations for a large print-on-demand company to ask what the deal was. She didn’t beat around the bush. Most of the big, well-known brands have clear policies: they delete uploaded photos from their servers within 30 to 90 days after your order ships, and they don’t sell or share customer photos to third parties. But the smaller, no-name brands that pop up all over social media ads? A lot of their terms of service have a line that most people never read: by uploading your photo, you grant the company a perpetual, royalty-free license to use that image for any purpose they want. That can be anything from using it in their own ads to selling it to stock photo sites, and there’s not much you can do about it once you hit upload.
I followed up with the digital safety facilitator from the school workshop a couple days later, to ask if this was actually a big deal, or just another thing to add to the endless list of things parents are supposed to panic about. She said the risk isn’t always that the photo will get used for something harmful, though that’s a small possibility. The bigger issue is that most parents don’t realize they’re giving up control of their child’s image before they even know it. Most of us think twice before posting a full photo of our kid with their full name on a public Instagram account, but we don’t think twice about uploading that same photo to a random website to get a $20 mug. It’s a blind spot most people don’t even know they have.
She wasn’t saying we should never order personalized products, though. She just said it takes a couple extra minutes of checking before you hit upload, which is way easier than trying to get a photo taken down later. I’ve started doing those checks lately, and they don’t take more than five minutes, tops. First, I Google the company name plus “terms of service photo upload” to see if they explicitly say they don’t share or sell customer photos, and that they delete them after orders are fulfilled. If I can’t find that information anywhere, or the terms are vague, I don’t order from them. Second, if I still want a personalized product and I’m not 100% sure about the company, I skip the face photo entirely. For this year’s back-to-school backpack, instead of uploading a clear photo of my daughter’s face, I uploaded a photo of the unicorn drawing she made for art class. It’s still totally personalized—all her friends know it’s her drawing, she loves showing it off—and there’s no image of her face floating around some company’s server that I don’t control. For a mug I ordered for my mom for Mother’s Day this year, I used a photo of my daughter from the back, standing at the beach holding her bucket, so you can’t see her face, it’s still a sweet, personal photo.
This year, our PTA did a fundraiser for custom school sweatshirts, and you could add your kid’s photo to the front. I asked the PTA coordinator what company they were working with, checked their photo policy in two minutes, saw that they delete all photos after printing, and felt fine ordering one. If the policy had been unclear, I would have just ordered the plain sweatshirt with her first name on it, no photo.
I still have that custom ornament on my Christmas tree from five years ago, with my daughter’s toddler photo on it. I’m not going to take it down, or throw it out, because I made it before I thought about this stuff, and it’s a sweet memory. I’m not here to shame anyone who has a whole closet full of custom photo products, either. It’s just one of those small, easy-to-miss things that nobody tells you about when you’re a parent, right? You’re just trying to get a cute backpack or a nice gift for grandma, and you don’t think about the fine print.
Last week, my daughter carried her unicorn drawing backpack to the bus stop for the first day of school, and all the other kids crowded around to look at it. She was so proud, and I was too, not just because the backpack turned out good, but because I got the personalized thing she wanted without giving up something I didn’t need to. I still get those ads for photo sneakers in my feed every day, and sometimes I still think about how cute that would be. Next time, I’ll just spend five minutes checking first. That’s all I can do, really.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is It Safe To Use Photos Of Your Child For Personalized Products On Websites