I Banned All Screen Time For My 11-Year-Old This Summer – Are We Doing The Right Thing?
It’s 2:17 pm on a Tuesday in mid-July, and I’m folding a mountain of damp beach towels while my 11-year-old son, Leo, leans against the kitchen fridge sighing. This is the seventh sigh this hour, loud enough to cut through the hum of the AC and the neighbor’s lawnmower. He doesn’t even reach for a granola bar from the snack drawer. Just stands there, staring at the blank spot on the counter where his tablet usually sits, and says, “There’s nothing to do.”
We made the call for a full device ban after this past school year. Leo’s teacher emailed me twice about him zoning out in class after late-night gaming sessions. On weekends, he’d turn down bike rides and birthday parties to stay home and play Roblox with his friends. My husband and I looked at each other after one particularly bad fight about turning the tablet off for dinner, and decided a full reset was what he needed. No screens at all, all summer long. We’d read the articles about boredom sparking creativity, how kids used to spend all summer outside without any devices, figured we were doing him a favor.
The first week was actually great. The neighbor boy down the street was still home, they built a fort out of old pallets in our backyard, caught tadpoles in the creek three blocks over, even finished half the Lego Millennium Falcon we got him for Christmas. We patted ourselves on the back, thought we’d nailed it.
Then the neighbor left for two weeks of sleepaway camp, and the temperature hit 92 degrees for 10 days straight. That’s when the moping started. The fort sat half-built, full of mosquito larvae in the old bucket they’d left out. The Lego set got moved from the coffee table to his closet, unopened. He’d trail after me around the house, sigh, say there’s nothing to do. When I suggested he read a book, he’d pick one up, read two pages, put it down. When I suggested he go to the community pool, he’d say none of his friends are there. Last night, he asked me if he could just text his cousin who lives out of state to ask how her summer was, and when I said no, he went to his room and shut the door hard enough that the framed picture on the hallway wall shifted. I stood there holding a dish towel, wondering how we’d gotten this so wrong. Were we just being punitive, for no reason?
I ran into Mrs. Lopez, who taught 5th grade at Leo’s school for 20 years, at the grocery store two days ago, and vented to her in the produce aisle while we picked out peaches. She didn’t tell me we were totally right or totally wrong. She said most parents don’t realize that for this generation of kids, screens aren’t just a bad habit – they’re the default. They’re how they connect to friends when they can’t see them, how they fill 10 minute gaps, how they entertain themselves when it’s too hot to go outside. Cold turkey zero screen time isn’t a reset for most kids, it’s just taking away all the skills and habits they’ve built to occupy themselves, and leaving them with nothing. That made sense, I thought. We grew up with phone calls and hanging out on bikes as our default, but that’s never been Leo’s default.
We didn’t give up and give him his tablet back 24/7, but we made three small changes that already made a big difference. First, we set 45 minutes of unstructured screen time every day after 4 pm. He can use it for anything: gaming, texting his cousin, watching silly Minecraft videos, whatever. No arguments about it, when the 45 minutes is up, it goes back on the counter by the router. Second, we let him use screens for intentional stuff anytime: if he wants to look up instructions to fix his broken skateboard, find a new recipe for microwave cookies, or see what kinds of constellations we can look for that night, he can grab my phone to do that. Third, I signed us up for one low-stakes free activity through the rec department every week – this week it’s a beginner bird walk at the local nature center, next week it’s open skate at the ice rink. He doesn’t have to love it, but he has to go.
It’s been four days since we made the changes, and the sighing is down to maybe once a day, not seven times an hour. Yesterday, he used his 45 minutes to play Roblox with the neighbor who’s at camp, chatted with him the whole time, then after he was done, he got his skateboard and fixed the broken wheel using a tutorial he pulled up on my phone. Then he rode it up and down the driveway for an hour. That’s more than he’d done all week before that.
It’s easy to fall into the trap that all screen time is bad, that a full ban is the only way to fix bad habits. What I’ve learned is that it doesn’t work to take everything away all at once, especially when that everything includes how your kid talks to their friends and fills dead time. Boredom is good, but constant, unrelenting boredom that leaves your kid feeling cut off from everything they know isn’t building anything – it’s just making everyone miserable.
We’re still figuring it out. Some days he complains that 45 minutes isn’t enough, and I still have to remind him that the rule doesn’t change. Some afternoons, he still flops on the couch and says there’s nothing to do. But it’s better than it was. I don’t know if we’ll try a full ban again next year, and I don’t know if this reset will stick once school starts back up. For right now, though, this middle ground feels a lot more right than the all-or-nothing we started with.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Banned All Screen Time For My 11-Year-Old This Summer – Are We Doing The Right Thing