How I Learned To Stop Comparing Myself To Other Parents: Small Changes That Actually Work
I’m leaning against the cold cinder block wall outside my third-grader’s classroom, half a stale chocolate chip cookie on a paper plate in one hand, nodding along as the mom next to me lists her son’s recent wins: first place in the school’s spelling bee, moving up to the elite U-9 soccer team, three chapter books finished in two weeks. It’s back to school night, and this is the part I always dread: the casual checklist of progress that every parent I know quietly uses to grade themselves, too.
She turns to me, smiling, and asks, “What’s Leo been up to lately?” I open my mouth, and the old line is already on my tongue: Oh, he’s still mostly into graphic novels, can’t stand team sports, just digs around in the backyard all the time. The little self-deprecating joke that leads with how my kid is falling behind, which means I’m falling behind as a parent. But I don’t say that. Because three days earlier, I had a conversation with Leo that shifted everything.
He was sitting at the kitchen table that night, crumpling his math quiz in his fist, a 72 scrawled in red pen at the top. He’s 8, shoulders hunched up to his ears, and when I asked what was wrong he mumbled, “Jake got a 100. I’m bad at math.” I said the automatic thing first: “No you’re not, you just rushed through the problems, that’s all.” But then he looked up at me, and his eyes were shiny, and he said, “You always ask how Jake did when I show you my grade. Do you want me to be better than him?”
I sat down next to him, and I couldn’t answer right away. Because he was right. I did that. I’d picked up that habit over years of comparing myself to every other parent I met. When Leo was a toddler, I compared my messy sleep training to the mom down the street who had her kid sleeping through the night at 8 weeks. When he started kindergarten, I compared how many sight words he knew to the list the PTA moms forwarded around in the group chat. I was constantly measuring my choices, my kid, against everyone else’s curated highlight reel, and I hadn’t even noticed that Leo was picking up on the habit too.
I didn’t do some big life overhaul after that. Big changes never stick for me, anyway. I just picked three small, low-effort changes to make, that I could fit into my normal routine without adding more stress. First, I cut the question “How did everyone else do?” completely out of my vocabulary when Leo talks about school. Now when he shows me a test or a project, I only ask one of two questions: “What part of this did you enjoy doing?” or “What are you proud of here?” It’s such a small swap, but it changes the whole conversation from how he measures up to someone else to what he thinks of his own work.
Second, when I catch myself scrolling through social media and feeling that familiar twist in my chest that comes from comparing, I close the app immediately and write one quick line in the notes app on my phone about something good Leo or I did that week, no comparison needed. I don’t do fancy journaling or anything – it’s just 10 seconds of typing. Last week I wrote: Leo taught the 4-year-old next door to identify three kinds of worms. I made sourdough that didn’t burn this time. That’s it. It just reminds me to look at what’s going right in my own house, instead of staring at what looks good in someone else’s.
Third, when I’m making small talk with other parents, I stopped leading with the downsides of my kid’s progress to fit into that unspoken comparison game. Which brings me back to back to school night. When the mom asks what Leo’s been up to, I tell her about the worm journal he’s keeping, the little 5-page story he wrote about his favorite earthworm named Gary, how he spends an hour every evening after dinner turning the compost pile and logging how many bugs he finds.
She blinks, then says, “That’s amazing. My son is obsessed with bugs too, but I never thought to have him keep a journal. I’ll have to suggest that.” We chat for another minute, then I go find Leo leaning against the water fountain blowing bubbles into his water bottle, and we walk out to the car together.
I used to think that not comparing myself to others was about being more confident, or ignoring what other people do entirely. But what I’ve learned is it’s just about shifting what you measure. I was measuring my parenting against what other people’s kids could do, instead of measuring it against what my kid needs. When I stopped comparing, I stopped signing Leo up for extra tutoring he hated and soccer practices that made him hide in the car before it started, just because other kids were doing those things. Now we spend that time digging for worms and reading graphic novels about decomposers, which is what he actually cares about.
It doesn’t always work. Last week I saw a post from a mom I know whose kid got accepted into the regional gifted program, and I felt that old familiar twist in my stomach for 10 full seconds before I remembered to close the app and pull up my notes. I still catch myself about to ask that old question about other kids’ grades sometimes, before I stop myself and correct it. It’s a habit I’m still unlearning, one small choice at a time. But Leo hasn’t cried about a grade or compared himself to Jake in a month. That’s enough for me, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How I Learned To Stop Comparing Myself To Other Parents: Small Changes That Actually Work