How I Handle Toddler Tantrums: Realistic, Low-Prep Tips for Tired Caregivers
Last Tuesday, I was grabbing milk and bread for dinner at the grocery store, my 2-year-old Lila strapped into the cart seat, my 5-year-old trailing behind staring at the seasonal candy display. We made it to checkout before Lila spotted the blueberry lollipops hung by the card reader. She pointed, grunting, and I shook my head: we’d already had one after playgroup that morning, and we’d be eating in 20 minutes. Before I could grab my credit card, she flung herself backward, the cart wobbled, and she screamed so loud the woman picking out apples two aisles over turned to stare.
I used to react two ways back when my oldest was a toddler. Either I’d be so embarrassed by the attention that I’d hand over the lollipop just to make the noise stop, or I’d remember some article I read saying ignoring tantrums teaches kids it doesn’t work, so I’d pretend I didn’t hear her while my shoulders climbed up to my ears and I rushed through checkout sweating. Once I left a full cart of groceries in the line because my oldest was screaming on the floor and I couldn’t take it anymore. That day with Lila, I did something different.
I leaned down until my eyes were level with hers, didn’t reach to grab her because I know she hates being touched when she’s already that upset, and said, “You are so mad we aren’t getting the lollipop. That feels really bad, doesn’t it?” Then I turned back to the cashier, swiped my card, and bagged my groceries while Lila screamed. I said one more thing before I lifted her out of the cart: “You can be mad, I’m right here.” By the time we got to the car, she was sniffling into my shoulder, and we didn’t talk about the lollipop again.
That’s my style, now that I’ve had two kids and a hundred tantrums in every public place you can imagine. It didn’t come from a fancy parenting book, just from figuring out what doesn’t work, and what makes the whole thing less miserable for everyone.
First, I always do a 20-second check before I do anything else. I run through a quick list: is she hungry? Tired? Is her sock bunched up inside her shoe? Is the tag in her shirt itching? Half of all tantrums I deal with come from a simple physical problem that’s easy to fix. Last month, Lila screamed for 12 minutes straight while we were getting ready to leave the house, and I was this close to just leaving her at home with my husband until I realized her boot was too tight and her foot was cramping. I loosened the strap, and she was fine. I used to skip this step, too busy being annoyed that she was throwing a fit, but it’s saved me so much time.
Second, I don’t give long explanations when they’re mid-tantrum. When I first started parenting, I’d rattle off all the reasons we couldn’t have the thing: “We already had sugar today, we need to save room for dinner, lollipops rot your teeth.” But a toddler having a tantrum can’t process that. Their brain is overwhelmed, the part that handles logic isn’t even online yet. All that extra talking just adds more stimulation and makes the meltdown last longer. Now I just name the feeling once, that’s it. “You’re mad we have to leave the park. That sucks.” That’s all they need to hear right then.
Third, I don’t leave them alone to calm down, and I don’t reward the tantrum, but I do give comfort. I used to buy the line that comforting a kid having a tantrum means you’re reinforcing bad behavior. But that never made sense to me. A toddler isn’t manipulating you when they scream, they’re stuck. They can’t calm down on their own yet. If I say no to something, I still mean no—no lollipop, no extra playtime, no drawing on the table. But I can sit three feet away folding laundry and say I’m here, or hold them while they cry into my shoulder if that’s what they want. The no is still there, but the shame isn’t. I don’t send them to their room to calm down alone, because that just tells them they can’t come to me when they feel bad.
I also do small things to cut down on tantrums before they start. If we’re going somewhere that might be overstimulating, I bring a snack and a small toy they like. I tell them the plan before we go in: “We’re going to the store for three things, no candy today, then we go home for lunch.” I move breakable stuff off the coffee table so they don’t get in trouble for touching something they can’t reach. But you can’t avoid all tantrums. Sometimes they just happen, because toddlers have big feelings and no good way to let them out yet.
I’ll also admit I give in sometimes, if it’s a tiny thing and I’m drained. Last week at the playground, Lila screamed because we had to leave to pick up her brother from school, and I was already running late, but I was so tired I let her stay five more minutes. It didn’t ruin her, it didn’t turn her into a spoiled kid. It just got us out of the parking lot without me being stressed the whole drive.
Some days I still get it wrong. Last week I had a migraine, and Lila threw a tantrum because I wouldn’t let her dump out the entire box of cereal on the floor, and I snapped and told her to stop screaming right now. Five minutes later, I apologized, and she climbed into my lap and patted my cheek. It wasn’t perfect, and that’s okay. This approach doesn’t stop tantrums from happening—nothing does. It just makes them shorter, and less stressful for me, and I think it makes Lila feel like her big feelings are safe with me. We’re still figuring it out, one meltdown at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How I Handle Toddler Tantrums: Realistic, Low-Prep Tips for Tired Caregivers