GED vs High School Diploma for College: What California Families Should Know
I was twisting my chipped ceramic coffee mug (the one my youngest made me for Mother’s Day in 3rd grade) on the scuffed linoleum desk of the Sacramento City College counseling office last month. My 16-year-old’s field trip permission slip was crumpled in the pocket of my jeans, and I’d just finished explaining that I got my GED after dropping out junior year, when I got pregnant at 17. I was there to map out a path to an early childhood education degree – I’ve run an in-home daycare out of my garage for 8 years, and I need the degree to get my own state license. My counselor, a woman in her 60s with a “Proud CSU Mom” sticker on her laptop, leaned back and said it straight: “I need you to hear this upfront. Quite a few four-year higher ed institutions here in California prefer applicants with a traditional high school diploma over a GED. It’s not a hard rule, but it’s a common preference.”
I just stared. I’d spent 18 years thinking a GED was exactly the same as a diploma. Every flyer I’d picked up at the workforce center back when I got mine said “accepted by nearly all colleges and employers.” What I didn’t know was how that “acceptance” really worked when it came to competitive four-year programs.
I drove home after the appointment, stopped at the Chevron on Watt Avenue for gas, and waited in the parking lot for my oldest to get out of soccer practice. I bought a blue raspberry slushie for her, leaned against my 2012 Honda Civic, and went over the conversation again. She came over, wiping sweat off her neck, asked why I looked so thrown, and I told her. She nodded, said her best friend Mia had been talking about dropping out last month because her generalized anxiety had left her missing more than half the semester, and she planned to get a GED instead.
That night I called my sister, who’s a guidance counselor at a public high school in Oakland, and she confirmed what my community college counselor said. She told me the preference isn’t just random. Most California public four-year schools (the UCs and CSUs) require students to complete a set list of college preparatory classes called A-G requirements to get in as a freshman. Students who get a GED often don’t finish all those requirements, and even if they do, admissions teams don’t have four years of high school grades and coursework to review. When two applicants have similar stats, the diploma holder almost always gets the spot. It’s not written into most schools’ admission policies loud and clear, but it’s common practice.
What’s surprised me most is how few people talk about this. Most parenting resources for kids struggling with high school frame a GED as an equal alternative. But from what I’ve learned over the past month, there are concrete steps California families can take to keep all options open. First, before anyone pulls out of high school to get a GED, call your local school district and ask if they offer an adult high school diploma program. Almost every district in California has one. They let you take classes part-time, work around work or mental health appointments, and when you finish, you get a full, traditional high school diploma, not a GED. Mia’s counselor confirmed that our district’s program costs nothing for anyone under 24, and you can take classes two nights a week to finish at your own pace. For someone like Mia, who’s already finished three years of high school, the program takes an average of 18 months to complete – which isn’t that much longer than it takes to get a GED.
For people who already have a GED, like me, don’t panic. You don’t have to go back and get a high school diploma. Community colleges in California don’t care if you have a GED or a diploma, they’ll accept you either way. The best path is to complete your general education requirements at community college first, then transfer to a four-year. When you transfer from a California community college, admissions teams weight your community college grades far more than your high school credential. I’m already enrolled in two classes this semester, and I’m planning to use the Transfer Admission Guarantee (TAG) program for CSUs, which guarantees me admission as long as I hit the GPA and course requirements. My counselor said my GED won’t even be a major factor in my transfer application at that point.
It’s not all bad, of course. GEDs are totally fine for trade school, community college certificates, most jobs, and getting into apprenticeships. If you know you don’t want a four-year degree, a GED is a perfectly good option. But it’s important to know the catch for California families if a four-year degree is a goal. I don’t think this preference is fair – most people who get GEDs have really good reasons for not finishing traditional high school: housing instability, having to work to support their family, mental health struggles, caring for a younger sibling or parent. It feels wrong to penalize people for circumstances that are often out of their control. But that’s the current system, so knowing the preference upfront saves you from the surprise I got last month.
Mia went to her first adult high school class last week. She texted me a photo of her new notebook, covered in cat stickers, and said the class was only 12 people, so she didn’t get overwhelmed by the crowd like she did at the big traditional high school. She still doesn’t know if she wants to go to a four-year after she graduates – she’s talked about being a veterinary technician, which only requires an associate’s degree. But now she has the option if she changes her mind. I’m still on track for my degree, it’ll just take a little longer than I originally planned. It’s not the path I would have picked 18 years ago, but it’s working, as long as I know what I’m working with.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » GED vs High School Diploma for College: What California Families Should Know