Caring For My Younger Sister As A Young Caregiver: Why I Worry I’m Doing It All Wrong
I burned the oatmeal again this morning, and Lila, my 8-year-old sister, leaned against the fridge picking at her chipped unicorn nail polish while I scraped charred oats into the trash. “It’s okay,” she said, too quiet. I’d already yelled five minutes earlier because she left her colored pencils all over the bathroom floor again, the same place she leaves them every single night.
Our parents left six months ago to stay with my grandma while she goes through cancer treatment, and I, 22, fresh out of college with a half-done remote marketing job, became the primary person in charge of everything from field trip forms to dentist appointments to buying new socks when her feet grow. I knew it would be hard, but I didn’t know how much time I’d spend lying awake at night replaying my mistakes, counting all the ways I’m not doing it right.
Last week she came home from school crying because no one saved her a seat at the lunch table. I was on a deadline for a work project, my computer dying on the kitchen counter, and I brushed her off: “Just go sit next to someone new, it’s not that big of a deal.” She ran to her room and didn’t come out for dinner. I ate cold mac and cheese alone staring at her closed door, and wondered how I could be so stupid. I let her watch two hours of TikTok most afternoons while I answer emails. I forget to restock her favorite granola bars. I once sent her to school with her shirt inside out and didn’t notice until she texted me (she has a kid phone) from the bathroom asking me to bring a new one. Every misstep feels like proof I’m messing her up long term.
After the lunch table incident, I finally worked up the courage to reach out to the family counselor her school connected me with when we first got this arrangement. I’d put it off because I didn’t want a stranger telling me I was unfit to care for my sister. But when she came over to our small rental house last week, she didn’t do that. She just drank my bad instant coffee, listened to me list all my mistakes, and gave me three small, concrete things I didn’t know I needed.
The first was to stop pretending I don’t mess up. Instead of walking away from a fight and hoping Lila forgets I yelled, I just say what happened out loud. “I was too angry earlier. I’m sorry I snapped. The mess frustrated me, that wasn’t your fault.” That’s it, no long explanations, no guilt-tripping her about how hard I work to take care of everything, just a plain apology. I tried this the night I snapped at her for getting glitter slime all over my work laptop. I walked into her room, said that line, and she immediately said she was sorry too—she knew she wasn’t supposed to bring slime to the dining table. We cleaned it up together, no hard feelings. Before this, I’d have avoided the topic all night and felt guilty for hours.
The second thing was the one good enough rule. I was trying to copy everything my mom does: home-cooked dinners every night, clean floors every day, weekly playdates, perfectly packed lunches with cut up fruit and handwritten notes. When I couldn’t keep up, I thought I was failing. The counselor told me to pick three non-negotiable things each day, and let everything else slide. My three are: she eats at least one vegetable, we spend 15 minutes together without any phones, and I don’t yell more than once. If the laundry sits unfolded for two days, that’s fine. If we eat frozen pizza three nights in a row, that’s okay. If she watches an extra hour of TikTok because I have a last minute work call, I don’t beat myself up about it anymore.
The third thing was to stop fixing every problem before she even finishes talking. I’m used to problem-solving for work, so when Lila comes to me upset, my first instinct is to tell her what to do to make it better. The counselor told me to just repeat what she says back to her first. If she says “Mia was playing with someone else at recess and wouldn’t play with me,” I say “That sounds really hurtful, right?” instead of “Why don’t you go play on the slide by yourself?” That’s all I have to do. Nine times out of ten, that’s all she wants. She doesn’t need me to fix her friendship or talk to the teacher or come up with a plan. She just needs me to listen. I brought up the lunch seat incident again a few days later, and she just sighed and said yeah, it was the worst, then went back to talking about her art project.
I still worry, of course. I still lie awake some nights thinking about how I’ll mess up her parent-teacher conferences, or forget to sign her up for soccer, or that she’ll grow up remembering this year as the one where her big sister was always stressed and always yelling. I still carry that guilt around, even when things go right.
This morning, after we ate cereal instead of burned oatmeal, I walked her to the bus stop. She held my hand, which she hasn’t done in months because she says she’s too old for that now. She told me she wants to make glitter slime after school today, and I said yes. I know there will be glitter in the couch cushions for months, but that’s okay.
I still reach out to the counselor when I get stuck, and I still bug my parents for help over the phone every Sunday. Some days I still feel like I’m just fumbling through from one meal to the next. But Lila taped a drawing she made of us to my laptop last week, it says “Best Sister Ever” in sparkly marker, and the E in Best is twice as big as all the other letters. Right now, that’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Caring For My Younger Sister As A Young Caregiver: Why I Worry I’m Doing It All Wrong