When A Quiet Student Won’t Ask For Help: What I Learned Helping A 10-Year-Old In China
Xiao Ming stood pressed against the whiteboard in my 4th grade ESL class, his presentation paper crumpled into a tight ball in his fist. It had been three minutes of silence, and the rest of the class was starting to snicker, poking each other in the sides under their desks. His bangs fell so far over his eyes I couldn’t see his face, and I remembered the blank homework he’d turned in two days before, with a tiny scribble in the margin: I’m sorry I didn’t get it. Please don’t be mad.
I told him he could sit down and finish his presentation after class, and he slid back into his seat so fast he nearly knocked over his water bottle. When the bell rang, he didn’t leave with the rest of the kids. He lingered by my desk, still twisting that crumpled paper, until the hallway cleared. I pulled a lemon candy out of the zippered pocket of my teacher bag— I keep them there for kids who get nervous— and held it out. He took it slow, unwrapped it, and finally mumbled that he’d practiced his presentation three times the night before with his mom. When he stood up, his throat just closed up.
His homeroom teacher had already warned me he was the quiet one. He never raises his hand, never asks for help, hides bad test papers in the back of his textbook so his parents don’t find them. His mom and dad both work in tech parks on the edge of the city, and they pay for three after-school tutors a week— math, Chinese, English— because they want him to get into one of the top high schools in the city. He’s tired most days, she told me, but he just won’t tell anyone when he doesn’t understand something. Most people write kids like Xiao Ming off as shy, or lazy, or not very bright. That’s what I used to think too, until I’d spent a few years teaching in Chinese public primary schools.
It doesn’t take long to see why kids stay quiet. From first grade, they learn that good students get everything right. If you answer a question wrong, the teacher might call you out in front of the whole class. Your classmates will laugh. Your parents will ask why you weren’t paying attention. Asking for help means you’re not keeping up, that you’re a burden to the teacher and a disappointment to your family. It’s easier to leave a question blank, to pretend you understand, than to admit you need help. That’s not shyness. That’s a survival habit kids pick up really fast.
I didn’t tell Xiao Ming he just needed to be more confident. I’ve never seen that work. Instead, I made two small changes in my class for him, and two small suggestions for his mom that I knew she could try without rearranging their whole lives. First, I stopped asking the whole class “does everyone understand?” after I explain an assignment. Every kid says yes, even when half of them don’t. Now I have everyone write any question they have on a sticky note and drop it in a box by the door, no names required. For Xiao Ming, I made a standing rule: he can opt out of speaking in front of the whole class any time, no explanation needed. He can write me a note or slip me a sticky note any time he has a question, and I’ll answer it before class starts when no one else is around.
When his mom came to pick him up one afternoon, we talked by the school gate while she waited for him to tie his shoes. She told me she’s always yelling when he brings home wrong answers, because she’s paying so much for tutors and she’s scared he’ll fall too far behind to get into a good school. I told her to try two specific changes. First, stop asking “did you finish all your homework?” when he gets home— that question only gets a yes, even when he hasn’t. Instead ask, “what was the trickiest thing you worked on today?” It opens the door to him talking about what he struggled with, instead of just lying to get you off his back. Second, when he does show you a bad grade or a wrong answer, say “thank you for telling me” before you start talking about how to fix it.
She thought that sounded too soft, like I was coddling him, but she said she’d try. Two weeks later, she sent me a WeChat message after dinner. He’d come home with a C on his math quiz, and instead of hiding it like he usually did, he set it on the table in front of her. She said what I told her to say: thank you for telling me. And he just sat down and cried. He told her he’d hidden three bad quizzes the month before because he was scared she’d cancel his weekly swimming class, the only thing he does that’s not homework or tutoring.
Small changes don’t fix everything overnight. Xiao Ming still won’t do a presentation in front of the whole class. He still sometimes leaves a question blank on his homework if he forgets to write me a sticky note. He still flinches a little when I call his name by accident. He’s not suddenly the loud, confident kid who raises his hand for every question, and he might never be. That’s okay.
Last week, after class, he walked up to me by the water cooler when no one else was around. He asked me how to spell “tyrannosaurus” out loud, no note. His voice was quiet, so quiet I almost had to ask him to repeat it, but he did it. I gave him another lemon candy, he tucked it into his pocket, and ran out to the playground to join his friends for soccer.
It’s just a small win. There’s still a long way to go, and there’s a lot working against kids like Xiao Ming— the pressure of exams, the focus on test scores over everything else, the idea that admitting weakness is something to be ashamed of. But you don’t have to fix the whole system to help one kid. You just have to change the small things that let him know he doesn’t have to be sorry for not knowing something. Right now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When A Quiet Student Won’t Ask For Help: What I Learned Helping A 10-Year-Old In China