Why Your Child Might Get Passed Over For an AP Position (And What To Do Next)
The cherry blossom petals sticking to my 10th grader’s bike tire were still pink when she slung her backpack over her shoulder and said it, not looking at me: “I got passed over for AP Bio again.” I was holding a lukewarm iced coffee I’d grabbed from the gas station on the way, and it sloshed over the edge onto my wrist when I tensed up. Last year, she’d been passed over for AP World History, so this was the second time in 12 months that the email from guidance landed in my inbox with that same sinking twist.
She’d done everything they asked this time, too. The AP Bio teacher sent out an optional 3-page pre-course assignment back in January to sort through applicants, and Lila stayed up two nights after finishing her other homework to finish it, even drawing little diagrams of cell cycles in the margins because she likes drawing. She got a 92 on it, had a B+ in regular bio all year, and had her current teacher write a short note of recommendation for her application. Still, no seat.
We went home, she ate a granola bar and retreated to her room to scroll, and I didn’t push her to talk. I’ve learned that pushing doesn’t help much in these moments. A week later, I had my scheduled parent-teacher conference, and I stayed after to talk to the head of the science department, Ms. Henderson, about what happened. Her classroom smelled like dry erase markers and half-eaten Goldfish crackers someone had left in a desk, and a sunflower sticker peeled off the corner of her laptop. She didn’t dance around the issue, which I appreciated. We only have three sections of AP Bio this year, she said. Budget cuts cut a fourth section last spring. We had 42 qualified applicants for 27 seats. We prioritize juniors who need lab science for their college prereqs first, then we give extra weight to kids who already have a track record of passing AP exams, because that’s what the state uses for our school ranking.
So my kid is qualified, just not the priority? I asked. She nodded, yeah, basically. I don’t like doing it, but that’s how it works right now.
I left that conference with all the same questions any parent would have. Do I fight this? Do I email the principal, demand a seat? Is this going to ruin her chances of getting into a good college? But I stopped for a taco on the way home, and I thought about what Lila had said two nights before, when I asked what would happen if she didn’t get in. She’d shrugged and said “I mean, Mia got in, so I’d miss having her in class, but regular bio is easier and I can get more done on my portfolio.”
The first thing I did when I got home wasn’t draft a complaint email. It was ask her, point blank: On a scale of 1 to 10, how bad do you want that seat? I’d never thought to do that after the first AP rejection last year. I just assumed she wanted it because it’s what good students do, what colleges want. She thought for a second and said 6. It wasn’t that she didn’t want the challenge, it was that she cared more about the college credit than the actual work, and she was tired of being told she wasn’t “AP material” when she already pulled solid grades. The 6 meant she didn’t want me to start a fight over it, but she did want to see if she could get some extra challenge even in regular bio.
For any parent stuck in this same spot, I picked up a few concrete, low-friction things that work a lot better than stressing or arguing. If your kid’s score is higher than a 7, and they really want the spot, first just ask the department to add them to the official waitlist. A lot of kids drop AP classes in the first two weeks, even if they got a seat, once they realize how much work it is next to their other classes. A short, polite email from you or your kid asking to be added is way more effective than a long, angry complaint to the principal. If the waitlist doesn’t pan out, ask about independent study. Most schools let students study for the AP exam on their own even if they’re not enrolled in the class, and many teachers will even check in with you once a month if you ask. Lila’s friend did this for AP Psych last year, got a 4 on the exam, and didn’t have to rearrange her whole schedule to make it work.
If your kid’s number is lower, like Lila’s, you don’t have to push for a seat just to check a box for college. We asked Lila’s regular bio teacher if she could do small extra projects after they finished units, if there was extra reading she could do on the side if she wanted more challenge. Her teacher said yes right away; most teachers love when kids want to learn more, even if they’re not in the AP section. Lila does a 30-minute extra project after school once a week, usually on something she’s interested in like genetic inheritance in native plants, and that’s enough for her.
I still get that little twinge sometimes, if I’m being honest. Last week I saw a mom post in our parent Facebook group that her kid got into every AP they applied for, and I caught myself thinking maybe I should have pushed harder, maybe this will come back to bite us when she applies to college. But then last night I walked past Lila’s room, and she had her art portfolio spread out on the floor, a half-finished oil painting of her dog propped up on the easel, and she was singing off-key to that new pop album, and she didn’t look like a kid who’d been cheated out of something. She looked like a kid who had time for the thing she actually cares about.
We don’t know yet what will happen with college apps next year. We don’t know if not having AP Bio on her transcript will matter at all, or if it will knock her out of the running for some school she might apply to. But I know this: getting passed over for an AP position doesn’t mean your kid isn’t good enough. A lot of the time, it just means the school doesn’t have enough seats, or they’re prioritizing other things that matter more to them than to your kid. That’s not a failure on your kid’s part. It’s just how the system works right now, and you get to decide what matters more: checking the AP box, or letting your kid have space for the things that actually matter to them.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Child Might Get Passed Over For an AP Position (And What To Do Next)