Is My Kid’s Backpack Socially Acceptable? What Parents And Teachers Need To Know
Last Wednesday, I stayed late to pack up progress reports when Mia’s mom knocked softly on my 5th grade classroom door, one hand tucked behind her back like she was hiding a half-eaten candy bar. “I know this is silly,” she said, pulling out a frayed canvas backpack covered in hand-drawn Bluey stickers, its fraying handle wrapped in peeling neon pink duct tape, “but Mia begged me to ask you: is this backpack socially acceptable?”
The question caught me off guard at first, but it shouldn’t have. I get some version of this question at least twice a semester. Last year, a 3rd grade dad asked if a battery-powered dinosaur backpack that roared every time you opened it was too much for morning line. Two years ago, a 7th grade mom emailed me worried about her son’s backpack covered in hand-sewn My Little Pony patches, asking if I’d heard other kids saying anything about it. Almost always, the question isn’t really about the backpack. It’s about parents wanting to keep their kid from getting hurt, and not knowing where the line is between letting them be themselves and stepping in to smooth the way.
Mia has had this backpack since she finished second grade, when her family went on their first camping trip together. She drew every sticker herself, right there at the campsite. The duct tape went on after she dropped it down the stairs at the city pool two years ago, and she picked the pink shade that matched the paint on her late hamster’s cage. The front pocket zipper broke last fall, but she just shoves her crayons and extra hair tie in the main compartment now. When we talked before conferences, she told me a couple of girls in her homeroom pointed it out at lunch last week and said it was babyish. She’d gone to the bathroom and cried for five minutes, but still wouldn’t let her mom buy a new one.
I didn’t give her mom a yes or no answer, because that’s not the point. Instead, I told her to ask Mia three specific questions when they got home that night, instead of jumping to a solution. First: “What part of this is bugging you right now?” Second: “Do you want me to do something about it, or do you just want me to listen?” Third: “What would you carry if no one was going to comment on it at all?” That’s the system I give all parents who ask me this kind of question. It keeps you from projecting your own middle school social trauma onto your kid, which is the most common mistake I see. Mia’s mom admitted she still remembers being 10, when her mom made her wear scuffed hand-me-down sneakers and the whole class teased her for a month. She was already gearing up to buy a $60 neutral backpack that night before she even asked Mia what she wanted.
They went through the questions, and Mia told her mom the teasing stung, but she didn’t want a new backpack. She just didn’t like that people kept bringing it up. Together, they came up with a middle ground: they ordered one small new sticker of Olivia Rodrigo, Mia’s current favorite singer, and stuck it right in the middle of the Bluey stickers. It added something that felt like 10-year-old Mia, without getting rid of all the old stuff she loved.
That middle ground works way more often than the two extremes parents usually default to. I’ve seen parents refuse to buy a new backpack even when their kid begs for one, because they want to teach their kid not to care what other people think. Last year, a 6th grader I had refused to bring his old Minecraft backpack to school for three weeks after his mom pulled that move, and ate lunch in the bathroom stall because he was embarrassed. That’s not teaching strength—that’s teaching your kid you don’t care that they’re hurting. On the other end, I’ve seen parents throw out a perfectly good loved backpack just because they’re worried what other parents will think, which sends the message that fitting in is more important than what their kid actually wants.
For teachers, there’s a small, easy thing we can do too, if we notice a kid getting teased about their stuff. You don’t have to stop the whole class and give a speech about being kind—that just draws way more attention to the backpack and makes the kid more embarrassed. All you have to do is make a quick, casual, positive comment when it’s just the two of you. When I see Mia in the hallway now, I just say “I love that new sticker” as I walk by, and that’s it. It validates her without making a big deal out of the whole situation.
I saw Mia yesterday, leaning against her locker between classes, that same Bluey backpack slung over one shoulder. The new sticker was tilted a little, and the oldest sticker by the bottom was peeling at the corner. She was laughing with her best friend, who was leaning in to read all the hand-drawn ones. No one was pointing or teasing. Mia’s mom sent me a quick text last night that just said “No new backpack this year.” I texted back that that was fine by me.
Next year, she might come in with a plain black backpack that all the 6th graders are carrying, and that will be fine too. The point isn’t to force your kid to be a nonconformist, or to force them to fit in. It’s just to let them be the one to decide what works for them, one backpack at a time. No answer you give today will be the last answer you need, and that’s okay. Kids change, and their stuff changes with them. Most of the time, all we have to do is step back and let them lead the way.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Backpack Socially Acceptable