What Makes a Great Teacher? Lessons From The One That Helped My Anxious Son
I was hovering outside my son’s third grade classroom during back-to-school night, crumpling the note he’d scribbled to me that morning in my jacket pocket. Don’t make me talk to the new teacher, it said. I already knew what I’d likely hear: that he was quiet, that he needed to push himself more, that we should keep working on his anxiety at home. Milo had spent half of second grade hiding in the girls’ bathroom during recess, leaving me to pick him up early with his hoodie pulled over his head and his hands stuffed in his pockets. Mrs. Henderson’s desk sat by the door, covered in sticker sheets and a half-empty mug of cold coffee, and next to the name tag was a jar of extra hair ties and a stack of dinosaur band-aids. When she looked up and smiled, I didn’t expect her to say my son’s name before I even introduced myself.
She pulled out a beat-up spiral notebook, flipped to a page marked with a sticky note, and pointed to a short line: “Milo rearranges picture books by cover color after dismissal. Likes order, no rush needed.” She told me he’d been doing it since the first day, and she hadn’t asked him to stop or suggested he go out to recess with the other kids if he didn’t want to. “Most kids who need that sort of routine just need someone to let them do it,” she said. That’s when I exhaled for the first time all month, and told her about the bathroom trips, the early pickups, the reward charts and breathing exercises that hadn’t changed a thing.
Three weeks in, I got a text from her on a Tuesday afternoon. It was a blurry photo of Milo sitting cross-legged on the reading rug, surrounded by the chipped plastic box of rock samples he carried everywhere, other kids leaning in to look over his shoulder. The caption said: He asked to share today. Didn’t have to stand up. When Milo got in the car that afternoon, he didn’t ramble about it like I expected. He just pulled a smooth gray granite rock out of his pocket and said, “Mrs. Henderson said this one looks like a mini moon. I gave it to her.” That was it. No big fanfare, no proud speech from either of them.
A month later, I got a call from the front office saying Milo had hidden behind the auditorium stage after a surprise fire drill, which had messed up his entire morning routine. I grabbed my purse and was halfway to the door when my phone pinged again, a text from Mrs. Henderson: Found him. We’re sorting broken crayons in the work closet. He’s fine. No need to come. I’ll send him home with a normal report. When he walked in the door that afternoon, he told me she let him count the broken crayons and sort them by shade until his heart stopped racing. He didn’t even get a warning for leaving class, which was what he’d been scared of most.
I’ve thought about that day a lot over the last two years, because so much of what we’re told about good teaching and good parenting is about pushing kids to get out of their comfort zone, to exceed expectations. We walk them through breathing exercises, bribe them with extra screen time for making it through a full day, cheer so loud when they do something scary that they never want to do it again – all that attention ends up being scarier than the thing itself. What Mrs. Henderson taught me, though, translates to any home or classroom, and it doesn’t cost anything or take extra planning.
First, when a kid is overwhelmed, you don’t have to make them talk about it right away. Give them a small, low-stakes job that uses their hands. It can be sorting crayons, straightening a book bin, feeding the class pet, or unloading the silverware at home. For anxious kids, being forced to put big, messy feelings into words when their brain is already in overload just makes everything worse. A simple, repetitive task lets them calm down on their own time, without pressure. I started doing this at home when Milo gets worked up about homework or a party he doesn’t want to attend, and it works far better than sitting down to “process” his feelings immediately.
Second, let kids rewrite the rules for scary things. Presentations don’t have to be at the front of the room. A kid doesn’t have to shake a stranger’s hand if they don’t want to – you can just say “he’s more comfortable waving today” instead of pushing them. When Milo got invited to a big birthday party last year, we agreed he only had to stay for 45 minutes and could leave right after cake, no questions asked. He ended up staying an hour and a half, but knowing he could leave early took all the pressure off. That’s the trick: the option to opt out makes most kids want to stay, far more than forcing them to tough it out.
Third, don’t make a big deal out of small wins. When Milo did his rock share, Mrs. Henderson didn’t call me after school to gush about how far he’d come, or make the whole class clap extra loud for him. She just treated it like any other share. Big celebrations make kids feel like everyone expected them to fail, that this was some big surprise. Quiet, normal recognition works far better.
Milo’s in fifth grade now. He still keeps the mini moon rock Mrs. Henderson gave him back on his desk. He still gets anxious before big tests, and he still leaves the room when there’s too much loud noise at family gatherings. He doesn’t hide in the bathroom at school anymore, though. Last month, he did a 5-minute presentation about rock formation in front of the whole class, standing at the front the entire time. He didn’t tell me about it for three days. When I asked how it went, he just shrugged and said “It was fine. Mrs. Henderson came to watch. She sat in the back so I could look at her if I needed to.”
We still have bad days where he doesn’t want to get up and go to school. Progress isn’t linear, and it’s never perfect. But that’s what makes that one great teacher stick, isn’t it? They don’t fix your kid. They just meet them where they are, one sorted book bin and one broken crayon stack at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Makes a Great Teacher