Should My Teen Go to Boarding School? Questions to Help You Decide
The crumbs from Lila’s peanut butter toast stuck to the corner of the glossy boarding school brochure when she slid it across our kitchen table last month. I was folding her cross country uniforms, the TV was muted playing a rerun of the local high school’s championship game, and I almost dropped a sock when she said, “I’ve been thinking about this. Can we look into it?”
I grew up 20 minutes from where we live now, went to the same public high school Lila’s in, always assumed we’d do all the regular things: Friday night football games, driving her to and from friends’ houses, Sunday dinners with the whole family. My first quiet panic thought was, what did I do wrong? Why does she want to leave? We talked for 20 minutes that night before she headed out to practice, and it turned out it wasn’t about me. She was tired of the same small-group drama that had been circling her grade since the start of the school year, and our district only offers one AP science class for juniors. She wants to study marine engineering in college, and that one class wasn’t going to be enough.
I spent the next two weeks reaching out to every parent I knew who’d walked through this decision, and what surprised me most was how many different stories I heard. One friend I had coffee with told me her son with dyslexia started boarding school two years ago, after our local district couldn’t fit the one-on-one reading support he needed into the school day. The boarding school built 30 minutes of targeted tutoring into every student’s schedule, and he went from hiding his test scores from the family to bringing home B+ grades and joining the mountain biking team. Another friend’s daughter begged to go, but they noticed she still got homesick after every single sleepover, so they turned down the spot and signed her up for a six-week summer boarding program for STEM instead. That let her test the experience without committing to a full year.
Those conversations taught me more than any website or admissions brochure could. The first thing I changed from my initial approach was how I talked to Lila about it. Instead of just asking “do you really want this?” I asked her two concrete questions: what do you want to get away from here, and what do you want to find there? It’s easy for teens to romanticize a fresh start without naming what they actually need, and this question forces them to be specific. Lila wrote her answers down on a scrap of paper: get away from the girls who won’t stop talking about other people behind their backs, and get into a robotics team that actually goes to competitions and a marine biology summer research program that the school runs. That didn’t make the decision easier, but it made it clear what we were actually looking for.
Next, we didn’t just do the standard one-hour campus tour with the admissions office. We asked if Lila could do a three-day overnight stay with a current student who’s into engineering, which almost every boarding school will allow for prospective students. She came home with chipped nail polish from playing ultimate frisbee in the rain and a long list of small, real complaints: laundry machines cost $2.50 a load, lights out is 10:30 on weekdays, the cafeteria’s pizza is way worse than the place down the street from our house. She also said she stayed up an extra 20 minutes after study hall with three other kids working on a robot prototype, and no one had to leave early to catch a ride home. That’s the stuff you never see on the tour.
Before we even started applying, we sat down and wrote three non-negotiables, no exceptions. Ours were: first, we can visit any weekend we want, no restricted visiting periods that lock families out for a month. Second, the school has an on-campus mental health counselor that any student can see the same day if they’re upset or homesick, not just a once-a-month appointment with a visiting therapist. Third, we can pay tuition without taking out high-interest loans that would eat into Lila’s college savings or our retirement. We found one school that checked the first two boxes, but the tuition was $17,000 a year more than we could afford, so we crossed it off the list immediately. No sense stretching yourself thin for something that might not even work out.
When I asked a group of current students during our visit what the worst part of boarding school was, one girl told me it’s hard to keep up with old friends from home, and another said drama doesn’t disappear just because you’re not at public school—it just moves to the dorm hall. That honesty was way more helpful than any glowing testimonial on the school’s website.
Right now, we don’t have a final answer. Lila decided she wants to finish out this year at public school, and we signed her up for the four-week marine science boarding program at her top choice this summer. That will let her live on campus, take classes, and see how she actually feels being away from home full time for more than a weekend. The brochure is still taped to our fridge, next to her last cross country medal. We’ll revisit the decision after the summer. Some decisions don’t need to be made this week, or even this semester. Testing the waters in a small, low-stakes way works a lot better than jumping in blind, or saying no outright without giving anyone a chance to try.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should My Teen Go to Boarding School