Would You Buy Your Son The Boots He Wants? What To Consider Before You Say No
I was crammed in the Target shoe aisle last month, back-to-school list crumpled in one hand, a leaking pack of granola bars rolling around my cart, when my 10-year-old son, Jax, stopped short mid-complaint about boring black sneakers. He was staring at the winter boot display, one hand outstretched to the far end where the pink glitter pairs sat, tucked under the “girls’ footwear” sign. “Mom,” he said, voice clear and sure, “those. I want those for winter.”
I froze. The boots were mid-calf, waterproof, exactly what we needed for our 20-minute walk to the bus stop and weekly sledding trips. They were the same price as the plain brown boys’ boots I’d had my eye on, and they had his size in stock. All the practical boxes checked out. But for 10 full seconds, all I could think was what everyone will say.
I almost blurted out the question I’d heard my own mom ask me a hundred times when I was a kid asking for something outside the lines: What will other people think? But I bit it back. I remembered when I was 11, begging for a pair of scuffed black combat boots from the thrift store, and how she’d turned me down, saying they were “too tough for a little girl” and sent me home with a pair of frilly tan leather boots I hated so much I hid them in the back of my closet and never wore them. I still remember the tight, hot feeling in my chest that day, like the person I was wasn’t okay the way I was.
I looked at Jax, shifting from foot to foot, waiting for my answer. I asked the only three questions that matter now, the little checklist I’ve started using when something my kid wants throws me off: Is this dangerous? Is it unfair to anyone else? Does it cost more than I budgeted for? The answer to all three was no. “Okay,” I said. “Let’s try them on.”
He laced them up right there in the aisle, stood up, and grinned, turning his feet back and forth to see the stars glitter under the store lights. I swiped my card, and we left the store with the pink boots in the bag, my heart still doing a little flip-flop of anxiety.
The first day of school, he pulled them on first thing, laced them up himself, and ran out to the bus stop before I could even remind him to grab his lunch. I stood at the front window for 10 minutes after he left, overthinking every possible scenario. I’d already had the talk with him about how some people might make dumb comments, if he wanted me to pick him up early if anyone bugged him, he just rolled his eyes and said “Mom, it’s just boots.”
He got home that afternoon, kicked them off by the door, and pulled his granola bar out of his backpack (he’d remembered it, miracle of miracles) and said “Mia said my boots are the coolest in class. Jake asked if we can get matching ones for him. Can we buy rainbow laces for these?” That was it. One kid on the playground made a passing comment about them being “girl boots” and Jax just said “They’re my boots. Wanna see how high I can jump in the snow in them?” and that was the end of the conversation.
Last weekend we went sledding up at the county park, and Jax ran up and down that hill a dozen times, those pink boots kicking snow all over his jeans, glitter flying. My dad was there, and he pulled me aside later, half laughing, and said “When your brother was your son’s age, I would’ve dragged him out of that store before he could even ask for pink boots. But look at him. No one cares. We just make all that drama up in our heads, don’t we?”
He’s right. Most of the time when we say no to our kids for these small, seemingly unconventional requests, the no isn’t about them. It’s about our own anxiety. We grow up with all these unwritten rules about what boys can like and what girls can like, and we pass them on without stopping to ask if the rule even makes sense anymore. We worry about other people judging us for letting our kid be themselves, more than we worry about our kid feeling like they can’t be themselves around us.
That three question check I use? It’s not complicated, it takes 10 seconds, and it keeps me from defaulting to no out of habit. If the request doesn’t hurt anyone, doesn’t break my budget, isn’t unsafe, the default should be yes. I also started pausing for 10 seconds before answering any request that surprises me, instead of blurting no out of instinct. That small pause gives me time to separate my anxiety from what my kid actually needs.
It’s not that I say yes to everything. If he asked for a $200 pair of designer boots when we already have a perfectly good pair, I’d say no. If he wanted to wear boots to a pool party, I’d say no. But when it’s a low-stakes choice that matters a lot to him? The cost of saying no is way higher than the cost of any awkward glance from a stranger in the grocery store. Saying no here doesn’t teach him resilience or fit in; it teaches him that his preferences don’t matter, that he has to shrink himself to make other people comfortable.
Last night Jax left his pink boots by the back door, caked in mud and melting snow, one of the glitter stars already chipped clean off. He’s already talking about his birthday wish list for next month: a purple skateboard with unicorns printed on the bottom. I felt that same little twinge of anxiety when he said it, the old habit kicking in that says that’s not what 10-year-old boys want. Then I looked at those muddy boots by the door, and I remembered how it felt to be 11, wanting something that was mine, and being told no for no good reason.
I still don’t know what will happen. Maybe he’ll decide he hates pink next year and ask for a new pair of brown boots in six months. Maybe one day someone will say something mean that sticks, and we’ll have to work through that together. Either way, it’s just boots. It’s just one small choice I get to give him, right now, to be exactly who he is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Would You Buy Your Son The Boots He Wants