Worried About An 11-Year-Old Girl Pulling Away? What I Learned From My Cousin
Last month, we had our annual family Fourth of July barbecue, the one where my aunt grills too many burgers and my uncles argue about lawn care. Three years ago, Lila—my 11-year-old cousin—would’ve stuck to my side the whole time, begging me to help her sneak popsicles before dinner and show me the latest comic she’d drawn in her notebook. This year, she didn’t come out of the car once until it was time to leave. I walked over to knock on the window, and she rolled it down just two inches, phone pressed to her chest, and said she was fine, just tired. Her mom shrugged it off when I mentioned it: “She’s 11, that’s just what preteens do, right? All they care about is TikTok.”
I work as a paraprofessional at a local elementary school, so I see this shift a lot more than most family members. Most of the time, when a kid who used to participate, laugh, and turn in work suddenly pulls away, it’s not just a phase. I’ve just never seen it this close with someone I love. A couple weeks later, I went over to help my aunt sort through Lila’s school paperwork—she works two retail jobs, so she never has time to sort through the flyers and graded tests that come home. When I pulled Lila’s math notebook out of a backpack propped by the door, all the pages after the first month of school were completely blank. The margins, though, were covered in incredibly detailed drawings of winged cats, each with a tiny name scrawled under their paws. I was still looking when Lila walked in to get a water bottle. She snatched the notebook out of my hand so fast she knocked over a mug, and slammed her bedroom door before I could say anything. My aunt sighed from the couch: “She’s failing math, won’t let anyone help her, quit horse riding last month that she’s been taking since she was 6. I don’t know what to do with her anymore.”
I didn’t push Lila to talk that day. I knew from work that if you corner an 11-year-old girl and demand to know what’s wrong, you’ll get nothing but “nothing” and a slammed door. By that age, most girls have learned that being “good” means handling things on your own, that asking for help makes you look silly or weak in front of the people you care about. Big, awkward “we need to talk” conversations just make them shut down further.
So I tried something I use with the quiet kids I work with that usually works: I brought my own old middle school sketchbook with me the next time I came over. It’s full of terrible doodles of 2000s pop punk bands and rants about my own 6th grade math teacher, and I left it on the kitchen counter next to my water bottle where I knew she’d find it. An hour later, she knocked on the guest room door where I was folding laundry, and held it up. “You actually kept this?” she said. I told her yeah, drawing was the only thing that didn’t feel like work when I was her age too. That’s all I said. I didn’t jump right into asking what was wrong. Ten minutes later, she started talking.
Turns out, Lila had been placed into advanced math at the start of 6th grade, because she’d done really well in 5th grade. She didn’t understand any of the pre-algebra lessons from the first week, but when she stayed after class to ask her teacher for help, the teacher said she should’ve paid attention during the lesson instead of passing notes. Lila wasn’t passing notes—she just didn’t get it. She was too embarrassed to tell anyone, because her mom had already told so many family members how proud she was that Lila got into advanced math, how that would help her get into college someday. On top of that, her best friend since kindergarten started hanging out with the popular girls at school, and stopped sitting with Lila at lunch. She quit horse riding because the other girls in her group kept making fun of her scuffed hand-me-down boots, and she didn’t want to ask her mom for new ones because she knew money was tight.
We started with the small stuff, no big family meetings, no yelling about grades, no forcing her to “open up” on command. The first thing I did was start picking her up every Wednesday after school, just to get a blue raspberry slushie from the gas station and drive around listening to whatever music she wanted. I don’t ask her what’s wrong every time—half the time we just drive and don’t talk. That’s the first thing I’d tell other caregivers in this spot: don’t turn every interaction into a check-in. Just give her unstructured time where she doesn’t have to perform being okay for anyone.
Second, I did the scary talking for her where that made sense. With her permission, I emailed her math teacher, explained that Lila was embarrassed to ask for extra help, and asked if the teacher could just spend two minutes after class once a week going over the hardest problem with her, no big announcement, no extra homework to make up. The teacher agreed, and Lila got her first passing grade on a quiz two weeks ago. For the horse riding boots, we went to the local thrift store after school one day and found a pair in her size that were practically brand new for $12. I got them for her, no big deal, and she went back to her lesson last Saturday.
It’s not all fixed. She still spends most of her time in her room when she’s home, she still doesn’t come to most big family events, and there are weeks where she doesn’t turn in any homework at all. My aunt still forgets sometimes and yells at her for being lazy, though she’s started leaving Lila’s favorite chips outside her bedroom door when she’s upset, which is a big start. I still worry about her, some days more than others.
The thing no one talks about when you’re worried about a preteen is that it doesn’t need a big, dramatic intervention to get better. Most of the time, it just needs one person who doesn’t call it “just a phase,” who shows up with small, low-pressure things that don’t demand anything from them. You don’t have to fix it all at once. Right now, that’s enough for us.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Worried About An 11-Year-Old Girl Pulling Away