Why Your Teen Is Begging Someone Else to Read Their College Essay (And What To Do Next)
Last month I was folding a load of my husband’s work socks on the living room couch, half-watching a baking challenge I couldn’t be bothered to pay attention to, when my 17-year-old daughter Lila leaned in the doorway, picking at the chipped edge of her sage green nail polish. “Mom,” she said, twisting her phone between her hands. “Can someone please take the time to read my college essay? Not you. Wait, I mean, can you ask Aunt Meg? She teaches high school English, right? Will she read it for me?”
My first thought was a tiny, sharp sting. I’d read every single one of her middle school poems about her guinea pig, her 9th grade research paper on ocean plastic, her messy diary pages she left on her desk when she was upset. Why was this one too much for me? I texted my sister half-joking that my kid had replaced me as her go-to editor, and she wrote back immediately: I get this at least once a year from my students’ parents. Kids don’t want their parents reading this thing. It’s not personal.
That got me thinking. Over the past two months, three different parents from my PTA group had sent me almost the exact same question: My kid won’t let me near their college essay, they’re begging a random cousin or their old English teacher to read it, did I mess up? Am I a bad parent? It turns out this is far more common than most of us talk about. And it almost never has anything to do with how much your kid trusts you.
Two months before Lila asked for Aunt Meg, she’d let me glance at a very rough first draft. I’d scanned the first paragraph, about how she spent afternoons sitting with feral cats at the local animal shelter after her best friend moved across the country last year, and I opened my mouth and said the wrong thing. “Wait, shouldn’t you lead with how you organized the supply drive for the shelter? Admissions officers love to see community impact.” Lila grabbed her laptop off the kitchen table and shut herself in her room before I finished the sentence. She didn’t show me another draft after that.
It clicked after that. This isn’t about whether you’re a good editor or a good parent. This essay isn’t a 10th grade book report that you need to grade. It’s the first time most teens are writing something that’s supposed to be just them, for an audience that’s going to judge the whole of their future on it. They don’t want to mix that up with the person who’s known them since they were in diapers, who still sees them as the kid who forgot their lunch every Tuesday. They don’t want you picking apart the vulnerable parts they put on the page, because it feels like you’re picking apart them. And if you’ve ever accidentally (or intentionally) nudged them to write what you think colleges want to see, instead of what they actually want to write, they’ll be even more likely to look for someone else.
When Lila asked me to reach out to Aunt Meg, I didn’t argue. I didn’t pout or ask her why she didn’t trust me. I just said a line I’ve since passed on to those other parents in my group: “That makes sense, I’m glad you found someone you feel comfortable with. Can you tell me what kind of feedback you want from them, so I can stay out of the way where it counts?” She immediately relaxed. She said she just wanted someone to point out sentences that don’t make sense, and tell her if the story feels weird, not to tell her what to change to impress admissions. That was easy to respect.
I also offered to help with the boring stuff no one else wants to do. I said I’d proofread for typos after she got all the big feedback she wanted, and I’d format the document to the right size and print a copy for her to mark up if she wanted. That let me stay involved without overstepping, and it took a little stress off her plate. I’ve found that most teens are happy to let you do that, even if they don’t want you reading the whole thing for feedback.
Another small, concrete step: If your kid picks an outside reader, it’s okay to ask that reader to keep the focus on your kid’s voice, not on “fixing” the essay to meet some unwritten college standard. I texted Aunt Meg before Lila sent the draft, and just said “Remember, she just wants feedback on flow, don’t make her change the story to sound more impressive.” She agreed, and when the notes came back, that’s exactly what she did. She left the line about the feral cat that fell asleep on Lila’s shoe that I would have cut to save space, and wrote in the margins “This is the best line, don’t you dare touch it.” That’s exactly what Lila needed.
If your kid does ask you to read it, the same rule applies: start by asking what they want before you start editing. Say “Do you just want me to read it and tell you what I thought, or do you want me to catch typos, or do you want ideas for how to tweak clunky parts?” That way you don’t accidentally overstep the boundary they didn’t know how to tell you they had.
Lila submitted her early action application last week. We got the confirmation pop-up on the screen, she ordered a large mint chocolate chip ice cream to share, and we didn’t talk about the essay after that. I still haven’t read the whole final version, just the bits she read out loud when she was stuck on a transition. I don’t know if she’ll get into the school she applied to, and I don’t know if the essay will be the thing that gets her there or not. What I do know is that this part of growing up isn’t about us being involved in every single step. It’s about them figuring out what help they need, and asking for it on their own terms. Sometimes that means asking someone else to read the essay. That’s not a rejection of us. It’s just them taking the first step into a life that’s their own.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Teen Is Begging Someone Else to Read Their College Essay (And What To Do Next)