Why Your Kid Writes In Secret Code After You Read Their Journal: Parenting Tips For Rebuilding Trust
I was grabbing my 13-year-old Lila’s forgotten gym bag at 6 a.m. last month, when I spotted her leather-bound journal propped open on her nightstand. We’d bought it together two months earlier, after her first panic attack at the new middle school. Our family therapist had suggested journaling as a low-pressure outlet for all the messy, unspoken feelings that come with switching schools and making new friends, and I’d stood in the bookstore staring at the covers promising her, “This is yours. No one will ever read a word of this without your permission. I swear.”
I’d been worried, though. She’d skipped dinner three nights in a row, locked her door right after school, and I was convinced she was struggling with something she wouldn’t tell me. So I glanced at the open page. Then I read the whole entry. Then I read half the journal before I heard her boots coming up the stairs and stuffed it back where I found it, my heart hammering.
A week went by, and I noticed the journal never left the nightstand anymore. She didn’t tuck it into her backpack after school like she used to. Instead, she was always on her PC, Minecraft open for hours after homework. One night she ran down to grab a popsicle and left her screen unlocked, and I wandered past, saw what she’d been doing: she had an enchantment table set up in a creative world, a book and quill open, and a folder of screenshots labeled “my stuff” tucked in her images. I’d heard of the Minecraft enchantment table language before—its weird, squiggly characters that translate to English, but only if you know the cipher. Most adults don’t. She’d figured out that if she wrote her entries in the enchantment table, even if someone stumbled on the screenshots, they couldn’t read them. It was a perfect lock, better than any cheap diary from the drugstore.
I sat with that for a couple days. I remembered when I was 14, my mom read my journal after I snuck out to a concert once, and I started writing my entries in a code I made up out of Greek letters I copied from my high school textbook. I didn’t stop writing, I just stopped writing where anyone could find it. Trust broken doesn’t mean you stop needing a private space—it means you stop letting other people have access to it.
As a 4th grade teacher, I see this all the time, too. We do free writing journaling in class, and I promise the kids every year that I only read what they want me to. The ones who’ve had their private writing read by parents or older siblings are the ones who draw doodles all over the page, write tiny code in the margins, or just leave the whole page blank. They don’t trust that the promise of privacy will be kept, so they build their own locks.
Saturday morning, we were making chocolate chip pancakes, Lila’s favorite, and I brought it up. I didn’t beat around the bush. I said, “I found your journal open a couple weeks ago, and I read it. That was wrong. I promised I wouldn’t, and I broke my promise, and I’m really sorry.” She just flipped a pancake and shrugged, said “It’s fine.” But her jaw was tight, so I kept going. I said “I saw the enchantment table stuff on your computer the other day, too. I looked it up. It’s a good code. I get why you need that.” That made her look up, surprised. She said “You’re not mad I’m not using the stupid journal you bought?” I said “No. That journal wasn’t the point. The point was you having a place to put your stuff. If the enchantment table is that place, that’s fine by me.”
I didn’t ask for a translation key. I didn’t beg her to let me read her thoughts so I could “help” her. I did three specific things that I now tell other parents to do when this happens: First, I apologized specifically, not just “I’m sorry if you felt hurt” but “I’m sorry I broke my promise. My worry doesn’t make what I did okay.” Second, I gave her full control over her space going forward. I drove her to the store that afternoon, let her pick any lockable notebook she wanted with her own allowance, told her I would never ask for the key, never try to pick it, never go looking for it. Third, I told her exactly what I would do if I was worried about her in the future, instead of breaking privacy. I said “If I’m ever that worried again, I’ll say it to your face. I’ll say ‘I’ve noticed you’re really quiet lately, and I’m worried about you. Can we talk about what’s going on?’ I won’t go reading your stuff behind your back again. That’s my commitment to you.”
It’s been three weeks, and she still uses the enchantment table more than the new lockable journal. That’s okay. Last week, I walked past her open door, and she was laughing with her best friend on FaceTime, translating an entry back to English to show her, and she quickly minimized the window when she saw me. I just waved and kept walking, didn’t stop, didn’t ask what it was. We’re not back to totally open, I don’t think we will be for a while, and that’s my fault. But she’s starting to leave her door open more often, she’ll sit with me on the couch after dinner and complain about cross country practice, the little day-to-day things that add up to connection.
A lot of parents I talk to think that if we encourage journaling for mental health, we have a right to check in on it, that it’s part of keeping our kid safe. But the truth is, the mental health benefit of journaling comes from the fact that it’s 100% yours. If you’re writing knowing someone might read it, you’re not writing the real stuff. You’re writing what you think they want to see. Lila’s enchantment table code isn’t a sign that she’s hiding something terrible, or that she doesn’t trust us at all anymore. It’s a sign that she’s claiming the privacy every teenager needs to grow.
I still mess up sometimes, I still worry more than I should. But for now, the enchantment table works for her. That’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Kid Writes In Secret Code After You Read Their Journal: Parenting Tips For Rebuilding Trust