Why Your Kid Always Physically Helps Other Kids (And What To Do About Cling-On Friendships)
I was leaning against my minivan last month, picking my 7-year-old Mia up from second grade, when I spotted her walking toward me across the blacktop. Her lopsided braid was slipping off one shoulder, and both her backpack and her classmate Lila’s backpack hung from her shoulders. Lila was clutching Mia’s free wrist so tight her knuckles were white, and Mia was stopping every three steps to re-tie Lila’s shoe, even though Lila mastered tying shoes back in first grade. When they got to me, Mia pasted on a smile and asked if Lila could come get ice cream with us. I said yes, of course, but on the drive to the shop, I watched Mia in the rearview mirror, shifting the backpack straps to ease the ache, and wondered when helping turned into something that felt heavy for her.
It wasn’t the first time. For weeks, Lila had been sticking to Mia like glue. She called our house every night to ask what Mia was wearing the next day. She waited outside our front door on weekends for impromptu playdates. And every single time, Mia was there, adjusting Lila’s jacket, pulling her up when she tripped, carrying her stuff for her. Last weekend, when we went to a birthday party at the trampoline park, Mia spent the first hour helping Lila climb up the wall ladders instead of jumping with the other girls. When we left, she fell asleep in the backseat before we even pulled out of the parking lot, and mumbled that her arm hurt from holding Lila’s hand the whole time.
I’ll admit, my first instinct was to text Lila’s mom and suggest we space out the playdates a little, or pull Mia aside and tell her it’s okay to say no. But when I brought it up at my monthly coffee with Mia’s teacher, Ms. Henderson, she put it in perspective pretty fast. She said this dynamic is way more common than most parents think. A lot of kids, especially empathetic, observant ones, default to physical helping as a way to show they care. It’s not that they can’t say no, it’s that they’ve learned helping makes someone feel good, and they don’t want to take that away. What turns a friendly helping habit into a cling-on dynamic is just habit: the other kid learns that help is always available, so they stop trying to do things on their own, and the helper ends up carrying more than they signed up for.
Ms. Henderson gave me a trick that didn’t involve me stepping in and embarrassing either kid, which was a huge relief. Instead of telling Mia what to do, we practiced 2 or 3 specific lines she could use when she started feeling tired of helping. Things like, “My shoulders are sore today, can you carry your own backpack?” or “I want to play four square with Zoe right now, I’ll catch up with you at lunch.” We role-played it a couple times at dinner, with me playing Lila, so she could say the lines out loud without feeling nervous. I also made a rule for myself: I wouldn’t turn down a playdate or make an excuse for Mia. If she wanted to say no, she could use the line, “I’m tired today, can we hang out next week?” and I’d back her up, but I wouldn’t do it for her.
I talked to Lila’s mom a couple weeks later, and she told me what she was doing on her end, which made a lot of sense. She didn’t scold Lila for clinging to Mia, but she started setting small, clear expectations: before Lila asks Mia for help, she has to try to tie her shoe or carry her backpack on her own first. She also started scheduling one playdate a week with a different kid from class, so Lila wasn’t relying only on Mia for company. It’s small, but it’s working, she said. Lila hasn’t stopped holding Mia’s hand, but she’s started tying her own shoes most days.
It hasn’t been perfectly smooth. Two weeks ago, Mia came home crying after recess. She’d told Lila she wanted to play on the swings with her cousin who was visiting for the day, and Lila had sat down by the classroom door and cried. Mia was convinced she’d been a bad friend. We sat on the couch and ate popsicles, and I didn’t tell her she did anything wrong. I just said, “It feels terrible to make someone cry, doesn’t it? But you get to choose how you spend your time, even if that makes someone sad for a little while.” She didn’t say much, but the next day she came home and said they’d played together at snack time, so everything was okay.
I used to lie awake worrying that Mia was growing into too much of a people pleaser, or that Lila was going to end up never learning to be independent. But now I don’t think it’s that deep. Kids are just practicing, right? They’re practicing being kind, and they’re practicing setting limits, and this is just how it looks when they’re learning. It’s messy, it’s a little unfair sometimes, but it’s not a problem that needs to be fixed overnight.
These days, some days Mia still carries both backpacks to the car. Some days she uses her lines and Lila carries her own. Lila still joins us for ice cream once a week, and she still holds Mia’s hand going into the school building. Right now, this is just what their friendship looks like, and that’s okay. We’re all still learning, one re-tied shoe at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Kid Always Physically Helps Other Kids (And What To Do About Cling-On Friendships)