Why Your Child Loves A School Subject: It’s Usually The Teacher, Not Natural Talent
It’s 8:15 on a Tuesday last fall, and I’m leaning against the kitchen counter stirring coffee, when I hear it: the faint, steady wail of a clarinet seeping through my 13-year-old Mia’s closed bedroom door. Two years earlier, that sound would have been the result of 20 minutes of nagging, eye rolls, and heavy sighs after dinner. Back then, Mia would drag her clarinet out of its case only when I threatened to take away her phone, and quit practicing the second my back was turned. She told me over and over she was just not a band person. She wasn’t born to like practicing, or music, or any of that discipline that comes with learning an instrument. I was this close to letting her quit at the end of seventh grade.
Then the district shuffled our middle school staffing, and we got a new band director, Ms. Lopez, this year. The first week of school, Mia came home shrugging and said she seemed nice, but I didn’t think much of it. A month later, she told me Ms. Lopez had pulled her aside after full-band rehearsal. Mia had been fumbling through the opening notes of the fall concert piece, stopping twice to adjust her reed when the high notes came out all squeaky. Instead of moving on to the kid who’d played it perfectly, Ms. Lopez pulled Mia over and said, “I love that you stop to fix your reed instead of just forcing bad notes through. Most kids rush through that part, and it makes everything harder. That’s such good attention to detail.”
Mia told me that story while she was unpacking her after-school snack, like it was no big deal, but I saw the way she smiled when she said it. No one had ever said anything like that to her about band before. Her old teacher only ever commented on how many notes she got wrong, or that she needed to practice more to catch up to the kids who picked it up faster.
I started watching the change after that. She started leaving her clarinet out on her desk instead of shoving it back in its case the second she was done. She started practicing before school on her own, no reminders from me. Last month, she stayed after school three days in a row to help Ms. Lopez set up for the fifth grade band recruitment night, just because she was asked. She didn’t even get extra credit for it.
I’ve started noticing this pattern everywhere, now that I’m looking for it. My friend’s son hated writing until 10th grade, got an English teacher who laughed out loud at the zombie apocalypse side plot he’d slipped into a research paper, and now he writes 500 words a day on his own time just for fun. My cousin, a high school math teacher, told me she sees it every semester: kids who swear they’re “bad at math” and won’t do any homework start turning in every assignment when she starts leaving sticky notes on their papers that say “great job checking your work on this problem” instead of just marking wrong answers.
We talk a lot about natural talent, about kids finding their passion, about how some people are just wired to love the hard work of a certain discipline. But what I’ve learned from Mia is that most of the time, the love of the discipline comes first from the person who teaches it, not from some innate gift the kid was born with. Discipline feels like a chore when it’s only about proving you’re good enough. It feels worth it when someone sees the small, boring bits of effort you put in, before you’re any good at the end result.
The practical takeaway for parents and teachers isn’t some big complicated change. It’s small, specific things anyone can do. If you’re a teacher, stop saving all your specific feedback for the top 10% of kids. The kid who’s middle of the pack, who’s one bad comment away from quitting, that’s the kid who needs to hear that you noticed they fixed their reed, or that they checked their work, or that their joke in the essay was funny. Just one sentence a week is enough, most of the time. If you’re a parent, don’t assume your kid hates a subject because they don’t have a knack for it. Next time they complain, ask them “what’s one thing the teacher does that makes class feel crummy?” and “what’s one thing that would make it better?” More often than not, the problem isn’t the subject, it’s that the kid hasn’t had anyone connect with them on the work yet. If you need to reach out to the teacher, don’t just ask for them to give your kid more work. Ask them to point out one small, specific thing your kid does well in class this week. It’s a tiny ask, and it doesn’t take any extra time.
Mia still isn’t going to make all-state band this year. She still squeaks through high E flat more often than not, and some weekends she forgets to practice entirely because she’s too busy hanging out with friends or playing Minecraft. I don’t know if she’ll still be playing in five years, or if this is just a phase that’ll end when she gets another teacher she doesn’t click with. But right now, she gets up 15 minutes early every school day to practice, and she walks into band class with a smile on her face. That didn’t happen because she was born to love the discipline of playing an instrument. It happened because one teacher saw her effort, and said something about it. I’m still learning to stop asking what my kids are naturally good at, and start asking who gets to help them see why the hard work matters. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Child Loves A School Subject: It’s Usually The Teacher, Not Natural Talent