Why Your 6-Year-Old Can’t Recall Schoolwork or Tell You About Their Day (And What Actually Helps)
I’m leaning against the side of my minivan, crumbs of a cheese cracker stuck to the knee of my jeans, when my 6-year-old son Jax trundles out of kindergarten, dinosaur backpack dragging one wheel on the sidewalk. “How was your day?” I ask, like I do every single afternoon. He shoves his hand in the snack bin I left out and shrugs. “Fine.” That night, we sit down for his first ever homework: write down the three sight words his class practiced that morning. His teacher Ms. Lily sent a ClassDojo message midday saying Jax nailed every one during circle time. But he stares at the blank lined paper, blinks, and says, “I don’t remember any.” I ask again, gentle at first, then a little tighter. He just shrugs again, and starts drawing a dinosaur in the margin. That night I logged on to my local parent Facebook group and typed out the exact question I’d seen a dozen other parents ask: Have a 6-year-old that is having trouble with immediate recalling with schoolwork and seems to struggle with telling about his day, anyone else have a child like this? By morning I had 127 comments. Half the people said their kid did exactly the same thing. The other half offered a dozen scary possibilities: working memory deficit, dyslexia, ADHD. I called Ms. Lily, who’s taught kindergarten for 18 years, and asked if we needed to get Jax tested.
She invited me in for a 10-minute chat after school the next day, and said what no one on the internet had bothered to explain. Most 6-year-olds are brand new to full-time structured school. They go from a routine of 3 or 4 low-key activities a day at home to 8 different activities, 20 new peers, a dozen new rules, and half a dozen new skills every single morning. By dismissal, their working memory—that little temporary holding space in the brain for new information—is completely full. It’s not that they forgot what they learned or what happened that day. It’s that they can’t pull the information up on demand right now. It hasn’t had time to sort itself into long-term storage yet. For some kids, this is just how their developing brain works, not a sign of a problem.
We tried a handful of small, specific changes she suggested, and most of them have worked way better than I expected. First, we swapped the big, open-ended “how was your day” question for tiny, specific questions that give his memory a built-in cue. I check the one-paragraph weekly newsletter Ms. Lily sends every Sunday, so I know they’re growing bean plants this week, or that they practiced jumping rope in PE. I don’t ask “what did you do in science?” I ask “Did you get to water the class bean plant today?” I don’t ask “what happened at recess?” I ask “What’s the silliest thing someone did on the slide today?” At first it was still hit or miss, but after a week or so, he started answering with more than a shrug. Last week he told me, “Jake fell off the swing and he didn’t even cry, he just got up and ate a granola bar.” That was a whole, connected story, the first one I’d gotten from him in three months of school.
For homework and schoolwork recall, we made two small routine shifts. I used to insist we get homework done right after school to get it over with, but that was the worst time to ask a full 6-year-old brain to pull up new information. Now we walk in the door, he gets a popsicle, runs around the backyard chasing our beagle for 20 minutes, and no one is allowed to mention school. By the time we sit down at the table, his brain has had time to dump all the extra input, and the things he learned that day can bubble up. When he still goes blank, we don’t make him strain to remember. We play a quiet hint game instead of quizzing him. If he can’t remember his three sight words, I say “One of them starts with C, and it’s what you drink every morning with breakfast.” He grins and yells “COCOA!” and that’s that. No frustration, no sitting there staring at a blank paper. Ms. Lily even started a tiny trick for us: when Jax is struggling with a new set of words, she puts a tiny matching sticker on the back of his hand— a dog sticker for the word “dog,” for example. Halfway through after-school snack, he’ll glance at the sticker and suddenly go “Oh! We learned that today.” It’s such a small thing, but it works.
I still worry sometimes. Last month he had a 5-question quiz over color words, and he only got two right because he couldn’t remember what he’d studied the day before. I called the pediatrician just to check, and she confirmed what Ms. Lily said: as long as Jax can recall information when cued, as long as he participates and learns new things when he’s in the classroom, this is just normal developmental variation. Some 6-year-olds are great at immediate recall, some aren’t. It doesn’t mean they’re not smart, or that they have a learning problem. If it’s still a consistent issue in a year or two, or he can’t recall even with clear hints, we’ll look further. But for now, this is just where he’s at.
Some days it still goes the same way it did that first day. Yesterday I picked him up, asked “What did you do for art?” and he just said “Stuff.” We sat down for homework, and he couldn’t remember the last number they’d learned in math. But most days, we get a little story, or he remembers two out of three words, and that’s enough. I don’t hover over his homework anymore, quizzing him until he gets frustrated. We take our 20 minutes of popsicle and dog chasing first, we ask the small questions, we play the hint games. It’s not perfect, and I still have that little quiet voice in the back of my head that worries sometimes. But for right now, this is working. And that’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your 6-Year-Old Can’t Recall Schoolwork or Tell You About Their Day (And What Actually Helps)