Why Younger Kids Always Want What Their Older Sibling Is Playing With (And Low-Effort Ways To Handle It)
The unicorn sticker was crumpled before I could even wipe the goldfish crumbs off the coffee table. Seven-year-old Lila had spread out her new birthday mosaic kit ten minutes prior, shoulders hunched in quiet focus, and three-year-old Milo had been perfectly content rolling his dump truck back and forth along the edge of the rug right up until he glanced over. One second he was making vroom noises under his breath, the next he’d launched himself at the table, grabbed the first sheet of stickers he could reach, and shrieked when Lila yanked it back.
“He always does this,” Lila yelled, holding the kit over her head. “I never get to play with any of my stuff without him bugging me.” Milo’s face crumpled, and he dropped to the floor wailing, pointing at the sticker sheet like Lila was holding a stolen lollipop. I reached for the spare mosaic kit I’d stashed in the closet for Milo’s Christmas stocking, the exact same one, and handed it over. He threw it at my foot. He didn’t want a sticker kit. He wanted her sticker kit, the one she was touching, the one that had all her attention.
This pattern plays out at least three times a day in our house. Last week, Lila spent 45 minutes building a Lego castle on the living room floor, and Milo stacked foam blocks happily at my feet the whole time—until she placed the tiny plastic princess on the tallest tower. Then he crawled over and knocked the whole structure flat before I could intercept. When Lila brings out her scented gel pens for homework, Milo tosses his own chunky crayons aside and screams for a “sparkly pink one” even though he refuses to touch anything pink on any other day. At the park last Saturday, he dug in the wood chips with his shovel for 20 solid minutes, then dropped it mid-dig to wail because he wanted the red four-square ball Lila was using with the older kids.
For a long time, I handled it the way I thought you were supposed to. I told Lila she had to share, that she was the big sister and needed to be nice. I tried to distract Milo with snacks or a different toy, which worked maybe one out of every four tries. I bought duplicate versions of Lila’s most popular toys, which felt like a waste of money when Milo always rejected the unopened one in favor of the half-used one his sister was holding. I figured he was just being stubborn, or going through a greedy phase, or liked getting a rise out of Lila.
I mentioned the constant battles to Milo’s preschool teacher at pickup a few weeks ago, while he was clinging to my leg and staring at a classmate’s truck that was identical to the one he’d left in the car. She laughed and said it’s one of the most common things parents of two kids under eight ask about. It’s not that the younger kid is being bad, or even that they want the toy that bad. It’s that older siblings are the center of their whole world. Toddlers and preschoolers take all their cues from the people they look up to most—if Lila is giving that sticker set every bit of her attention, it must be the most fun, most important thing in the whole room. The toy itself is almost beside the point. What they really want is a way into the play, to be close to the person they think is the coolest person alive.
They also don’t have the perspective yet to separate what someone else is doing from what they want. They can’t wrap their head around the fact that Lila is in the middle of a project, that interrupting her ruins the fun for her, that the sticker she’s holding isn’t just sitting there waiting for them to take it. It’s not entitlement. It’s just how their brains are growing right now.
That afternoon, after the sticker fight, I tried what she suggested first, instead of jumping to distractions or forced sharing. I knelt down on the floor next to Milo, who was still sniffling and wiping snot on his sleeve, and said, “You really want to play with Lila’s sticker set, don’t you? It looks like so much fun when she’s working on it.” He stopped crying for a second and nodded, like he was shocked I’d actually said the thing he was feeling out loud. I didn’t tell him he couldn’t have it, or that he was being silly. I just named the want.
Then I turned to Lila, who was still guarding her mosaic on the table, and said, “Milo doesn’t want to mess up your unicorn. He just wants to be near you while you work. Do you have a small job he can do to help?” She rolled her eyes, but thought for a second, then pulled out the empty plastic sorting tray. “He can sort all the blue stickers into here,” she said. “And he can’t touch the unicorn.” Milo scrambled up off the floor and climbed into the chair next to her, and he sorted stickers for 12 whole minutes—an eternity for a 3-year-old—before he got bored and went back to his dump truck. No more tantrum, no ruined mosaic, no hard feelings.
We also started building 20 minutes of “Lila’s quiet time” into our after-school routine, right after snack. She can do any activity she wants at the kitchen table, no little brother interruptions allowed, and Milo gets to play playdough or look at board books on the floor next to me. I tell Milo the plan before we even finish snack, so it doesn’t catch him off guard: “First we eat goldfish, then Lila does her own thing for 20 minutes, and then she’ll play dinosaurs with you.” It took a few days for him to get used to it, but now he usually doesn’t even protest. Lila says it’s her favorite part of the day, because she doesn’t have to hide her favorite toys in her bedroom closet to keep them safe. When her quiet time is up, she’s usually way more willing to let Milo join in whatever she’s doing, because she didn’t feel forced to give up her space.
The other big shift is that I stopped forcing Lila to share. If Milo grabs something of hers, I don’t make her hand it over to keep the peace. I turn to Milo and say, “That’s Lila’s thing, and she gets to decide if you can touch it. You can ask her nicely, and if she says no, we can go pick something else to play with.” At first, Lila said no almost every time, just because she could. But after a week or so, she started saying yes more often, because she knew her choice would be respected. Last week, Milo asked if he could use her grape scented gel pen, and she said no because she was using it to draw a cat. Five minutes later, she brought him an old silver sparkly pen she didn’t use anymore, and he sat there scribbling on a scrap of paper like he’d won a prize. It meant way more coming from her than it ever would have if I’d made her give it to him.
None of this works every single day, of course. Some days Milo is tired, or teething, or just in a mood where no amount of sticker-sorting jobs or pre-planned quiet time will calm him down. Last Monday, he threw a 15-minute tantrum because Lila got the blue cup at dinner, even though he has his own identical blue cup that he insists on using every other night. On those days, I just take him outside to blow bubbles or look for rocks in the front yard until he calms down, and we try again the next day. I don’t think there’s a magic fix that makes all the sibling toy fights disappear forever.
It’s not all fighting, either. Last weekend, Lila dug out her old giant wooden bead set from the back of her closet, the one she loved when she was Milo’s age, and he immediately dropped his truck and sat down next to her. She showed him how to hold the string and push the beads through, and they sat there for half an hour making a lumpy necklace for my mom, Milo’s beads all clustered at one end. He didn’t try to grab her beads, or knock over her pile. He just wanted to do what she was doing, next to her.
I know this phase won’t last forever. Someday Milo will have his own favorite hobbies, his own friends, his own stuff that he doesn’t want his big sister touching. For now, though, most days the small adjustments are enough. We still have crumpled stickers and knocked-over Lego towers and the occasional random tantrum over a cup. But fewer of them, and that’s all I can really ask for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Younger Kids Always Want What Their Older Sibling Is Playing With (And Low-Effort Ways To Handle It)