Why You Should Start Asking Kids What They See and Hear When They Solve Problems
The eraser crumbs were piled thick along the edge of Javi’s desk when I pulled up the blue plastic chair beside him. It was 3:45, after school, the hall still smelled like buttered popcorn the third grade team microwaved for their Friday reward, and half a bag of cheddar goldfish was crushed into the corner of his subtraction worksheet. He’d missed three straight regrouping problems, starting with 403 minus 167, and the end of his gray hoodie string was soaked through from chewing.
I’d worked with Javi twice a week for six weeks, and up until that afternoon, I’d done what most of us do when a kid gets stuck: lean over, point to the stacked numbers, and walk through my own steps. Start with the ones place. You can’t take 7 from 3, so borrow. If the next place is a zero, keep going left. I’d said it so many times I could recite it in my sleep, and every time, Javi would nod, do one problem right with me sitting there, and get every single one wrong when he worked alone.
That week, our intervention team had talked about asking kids about their internal representations instead of just quizzing their steps, so I didn’t reach for his pencil. “Hey,” I said, “when you look at this problem right now, what’s going on in your head? Do you see pictures? Do you hear a voice saying something? Anything at all, even if it sounds silly.”
He blinked, let go of his hoodie string, and stared at the paper like he’d just been asked to report what was on the other side of the classroom wall. “The zero rolls over,” he said after a second. “Every time I try to take one from it, it just rolls away. And I hear my dad saying you can’t borrow from nothing, but I don’t know what you do instead. So I just do 7 minus 3 and write that down.”
I sat back. I’d never once thought about a zero rolling over. I saw base ten blocks, flat hundreds squares and skinny tens sticks and tiny one cubes, the plastic set we kept in the closet by the door. Javi saw a stack of numbers with a slippery zero that wouldn’t stay put. No amount of repeating my step-by-step rule was going to stick to that picture.
This isn’t just a math thing, and I saw it long before I worked in a school. When my niece Mia was seven, she came home from second grade sobbing one afternoon, convinced her best friend Lulu hated her. She’d seen Lulu playing with the new girl on the swings at recess, and hidden under the picnic table for the whole 20 minutes. My first instinct was to say “just go ask her what’s wrong tomorrow” – the same quick, logical fix I reach for with a wrong math answer. Instead, while we sat at the kitchen table, popsicle juice sticky on the edge by her elbow and our dog curled up waiting for crumbs, I asked her to run the recess movie in her head and tell me what she saw and heard.
She listed the parts first: Lulu on the swing, pigtails flying, the new girl laughing, both of them glancing over toward the picnic table halfway through recess. Then she paused, and said “and I heard the new girl say I was boring, that’s why they didn’t ask me over.”
“Did you actually hear her say that?” I asked.
She stared at her scabbed knee for a long time. “No,” she said finally. “I just thought it. I put that part in there.”
Most of the time, when kids get stuck, the problem isn’t that they aren’t paying attention, or that they need the rule repeated one more time. The problem is that the picture or voice in their head doesn’t match the one in ours. Asking “how did you get that answer?” or “what happened?” feels like a test, especially when they already know they’re wrong. They’ll mumble “I don’t know” or shrug, because they think you’re asking for the correct answer, not a tour of the messy, weird, half-formed stuff happening behind their eyes. Asking what they see and hear takes the grade out of it. There’s no wrong answer to “what does the zero look like in your head?”
I’ve picked up a handful of low-fuss lines that work in all kinds of situations, no fancy training required. For school work, instead of “show your work,” which most kids think just means write more numbers on the paper, I’ll say “what’s the first thing that pops up behind your eyes when you read this?” For kids who don’t think in pictures, I ask “is there a voice talking in there right now? Whose voice is it, and what’s it saying?” More often than not, that voice is a half-remembered line from a parent, a teacher, a random kids’ video, that doesn’t actually fit the problem in front of them. For friend fights or broken Lego sets or arguments over the Switch remote, I ask them to play the movie of what happened out loud, one part at a time, no skipping straight to “he was being mean.”
You don’t have to fix the wrong picture right away, either. For Javi, I pulled out the base ten blocks that afternoon, and we acted out the slippery zero: we took the whole flat hundreds square, traded it for 10 ten sticks, and set one of those in the zero’s place. He could map that right onto the rolling zero he already saw, no memorization required. He still got one problem wrong that afternoon, but he got the next three right, and didn’t chew his hoodie string once. For Mia, just noticing she’d added that mean line out of thin air was enough to make her walk up to Lulu before school the next day; it turned out Lulu had been assigned to show the new girl around, and she’d been looking over to invite Mia over the whole time.
It doesn’t work every time. Some kids will tell you they see nothing at all, just blank, and that’s fine too – I just ask what their hand does first after they read the problem, or what their feet felt like when the fight started, and we work from there. Javi still slips up when there are two zeros in a row, and last week he stared at 500 minus 234 for five minutes before he remembered to go all the way to the hundreds place. Lila, a kid I work with who could decode any word on the page but never remembered what she read, told me for months she just saw black letters on white paper, no pictures at all. We still draw one quick sketch after every paragraph, and half the time she says she still can’t see anything, especially when the passage is about ecosystems or other stuff she’s never seen in real life. Mia still storms up the stairs sometimes when Lulu plays with someone else, and half the time she has to pause halfway up and admit she’s making up the mean lines again.
I still catch myself grabbing for the pencil, or jumping in with the quick logical fix before I pause to ask. Homework still takes longer than the 15 minutes the lesson plan says it should, and most problems don’t wrap up neat in one afternoon. But this one small question doesn’t require any worksheets, apps, or expensive tutoring tools. It just takes 10 seconds to stop talking long enough to find out what’s actually going on inside their head, instead of assuming it looks just like yours.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why You Should Start Asking Kids What They See and Hear When They Solve Problems