Why We Prepare Teens for College But Not for Life (And Small Changes You Can Start Today)
Last May, I stayed late after school to clean out my senior homeroom closet when Mia knocked on the door. She’d gotten her acceptance to in-state university a month earlier, had her navy striped dorm bedding picked out, and her graduation photos framed on the mantel at home. She leaned against the doorframe twisting her acceptance letter around in her fingers, and asked if she could ask me something dumb. “What do I do if my dorm room AC breaks?” she said. “Who do I call?”
Mia was one of my strongest students that year. 3.8 GPA, captain of the cross country team, volunteered at the local animal shelter every weekend. She checked every box on every college admissions list I’d ever seen. But when I asked her when the last time she’d called a stranger to fix a problem, she blinked and thought for a full minute. The only time she could remember was when her mom ordered her the wrong size birthday leggings, and her mom made her call customer service to exchange them. That was it.
That moment stuck with me. I’ve taught high school seniors for 11 years, and I see this every single year. We spend four years drilling SAT vocabulary, editing college essays, nagging kids about their AP exam scores and extracurricular sign-ups. We plan senior honor nights and post every acceptance on the fridge. But when it comes to the stuff they’ll need every single day after graduation? Most of us aren’t teaching that.
A friend of mine whose kid goes to a top private college told me last month that half the kids in her son’s freshman dorm called their parents to figure out how to work the communal washing machine. My own nephew graduated from an Ivy League school last spring; my sister handled every single one of his appointments, every bill, every conflict with a teacher or coach from the time he was 10. First semester of college, he got three unpaid parking tickets, got his car booted outside the library, and called her at 10pm crying because he had no idea what to do next. She had to wire him $250 overnight and talk him through the process step by step over the phone, while she was supposed to be at a work dinner.
It’s not that parents are lazy or overinvolved on purpose. The system pushes us this way. Colleges don’t ask if your kid can schedule their own dentist appointment or cook three meals that don’t involve a microwave. They ask for grades, test scores, and a list of activities. So we shift all our energy to what they’re grading us on. It’s hard to step back and let your kid mess up a small thing when you’re scared that a bad grade or a missed deadline will tank their chance at getting into a “good” school.
But the cost of that shows up the second they move out. I’ve had three kids drop out of good four-year schools in the last five years, not because they couldn’t handle the coursework, but because they couldn’t handle the day-to-day life of being on their own. One kid came home after two months because he had a persistent ear infection and didn’t know how to find a doctor or make an appointment. He waited until it was so bad he had to go to the ER, then called his dad to come get him.
The good news is, you don’t have to overhaul your whole family routine to fix this. The small, low-stakes things you start doing when they’re young add up more than a last-minute “adulting” crash course the week before they move to college.
For example, I tell parents of sophomores to let their kid schedule all their own appointments starting that year. Dentist, driver’s ed, college campus tours, haircut. They have to look up the number, call, write down the time and location, and reschedule themselves if they can’t make it. If they forget and miss the appointment, they have to pay the cancellation fee out of their own pocket money. That’s it. It takes five minutes off your to-do list, and it teaches them how to talk to strangers to solve their own problems.
Another small change: when your kid comes to you with a problem, whether it’s a bad group project grade or a fight with their best friend, don’t jump in to fix it. Instead of calling the teacher or texting the other kid’s mom, just ask them “What are three things you could try to fix this?” Nine times out of 10, they can come up with at least one good option, and you can talk through how it might go before they try it. If it doesn’t work, you can problem-solve again together.
By the time they’re seniors, they can handle bigger stuff: ordering their own textbooks, comparing cell phone plans, budgeting for their back-to-school clothes. When they turn 16, open a checking account with a debit card, put a set amount of money in it each month for their gas, going out with friends, and clothes. If they run out two weeks before the end of the month, they don’t get extra. It’s better to learn that lesson when you’re 16 and stuck at home for two weekends than when you’re 19 and can’t buy groceries for the last week of the semester.
I still hear from Mia. She just finished her first year of college, and she texted me a couple of weeks ago a photo of her and her new roommate standing outside a small off-campus apartment they’d rented for next year. She wrote that she handled all the emails and the meeting with the landlord, and talked him down $100 on the security deposit. The AC did break that first fall, by the way. She called maintenance herself, they fixed it that afternoon. She said it felt weird being the one to do it, but good, too.
We don’t have it all figured out, my colleagues and I, and there’s always going to be something a kid encounters for the first time after they leave home. But shifting even a little bit of energy from checking college admissions boxes to practicing small life skills makes the transition a lot less scary, for them and for you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why We Prepare Teens for College But Not for Life (And Small Changes You Can Start Today)