Why We Now Use Post and Comment Approval (and New Flairs) in Our Classroom Blog
I was sitting on the couch Sunday evening, laptop open to our class blog, when I saw it: a comment from a quiet, usually careful kid that just said, “Good job.” Not even a period. It was attached to a really thoughtful post about a character’s motivation in the novel we were reading. The post had taken that student hours to write. And this comment was like a drive-by wave.
That was the tipping point. Earlier that week, the comments section had gotten a little scrambled too. Someone had responded to a classmate’s post about animal testing with, “but they don’t feel pain like we do,” which started a mini-war of back-and-forths that had nothing to do with the post. I had spent fifteen minutes of our Friday morning mediating a disagreement about whether goldfish have feelings. I love when kids argue, actually. But not like that—not in the wild, unsupervised corner of our class blog.
So that Sunday night, I went into the settings and turned on comment approval. I also added a new set of “flairs”—little labels that students could choose when they left a comment. The options were simple: I Have a Connection, I Have a Question, I Respectfully Disagree, and This Made Me Think. I’d seen something similar on a teacher forum months ago, but I’d never bothered to try it. Now I felt like we needed some guardrails.
The next morning, I told the students about the changes. I kept it low-key. “We’re going to try something new on the blog,” I said. “Your comments won’t show up right away anymore. I’ll read them first.” I explained the approval as a way to keep our space respectful, not because I was hunting for mistakes. “And when you comment, you’re going to pick a flair. It’s like a little sign that tells everyone what kind of response you’re giving.”
The reaction was mixed. One student groaned and said, “So we’re going to have to, like, think before we comment?” I laughed and said yes.
The first few days were quiet. Several kids forgot to pick a flair, and their comments sat in the approval queue with a notification that said “Please select a label.” I didn’t approve them. Instead, I sent them a quick message: “Hey, can you resubmit with a flair?” A couple of students just deleted their comments instead. That stung a little. But the ones that did come through were noticeably different.
A shy student wrote, “I have a connection. When we read the part about the dog waiting by the door, it reminded me of my neighbor’s dog. That dog waits all day for her owner to come home. So I think the character feels lonely too.” The flair didn’t make that student smarter. But it gave her permission to start with something personal instead of trying to sound like a literary critic.
Another student chose “I Respectfully Disagree” and wrote, “I see it differently. I don’t think he’s lonely. I think he’s angry, because of what happened with his brother. But I didn’t think about the dog part, so maybe both.” That’s not a perfect argument either, but it was a step up from “you’re wrong.”
The post approval did something I didn’t expect: it slowed everything down. On the blog, there used to be a certain frantic energy—posts went up, comments flooded in, and everyone was checking to see who replied first. Now there was a lag. A student would post a response, and we’d have to wait for me to approve it before the rest of the class could see it. That waiting made some kids uncomfortable. I had one student ask, “Why do we have to wait? It’s just a comment.” I told her that waiting actually gives us a chance to think about what we want to say. She rolled her eyes, but she waited.
The flairs mattered more than I expected because they made the label part of the process. Before, a comment could be anything. Now, kids had to decide what kind of thought they were having. That’s harder than it sounds. It made them pause for a second. “Do I have a question? Or is this a connection?” That pause is exactly what I wanted.
I also started modeling it during our live class discussions. I would say, “I have a connection to what Mia just said—when I was growing up, I had a similar experience with my brother.” Or, “I respectfully disagree, because I read the same scene differently.” It felt a little formal at first, but the kids didn’t seem to think it was weird. They started using the phrases with each other. “I have a question, but not a real question, more like a wondering.” That was okay too.
There are some things I haven’t figured out yet. The approval queue can pile up if I don’t check it regularly. I’ve had to remind myself to log in at least once a day, or else the conversation stalls and kids get frustrated. Also, a few students still pick “This Made Me Think” for every comment, even when the comment is really just a question. I’m not going to police that too strictly. The labels are a tool, not a test.
I’ve also noticed that the flairs aren’t magical. They don’t stop unkindness by themselves. Last week, someone used “I Respectfully Disagree” and then wrote, “No offense but this post is confusing.” That comment got approved, because it wasn’t hurtful, exactly, but it wasn’t helpful either. I could have rejected it, but I wanted the student to see that the flair doesn’t excuse the tone. We talked about it during our morning meeting. “If you respectfully disagree, the respect comes first,” I said. “The disagreeing can come second.”
Our class blog is still a work in progress. Some comments are thoughtful, some are just okay, and some get written in the bathroom in a hurry. But the approval has made me more aware of what’s actually being said in that digital space. I’m not standing over their shoulders, but I am there, reading what they write, sending things back when they need another look. That’s not a bad thing.
The student who posted “Good job” on Sunday night hasn’t commented much since. I’m not worried. He’s still doing his posts, and he’s a good writer. When he does leave a comment again, I hope it’ll be because he has something to say, not because the blog felt like a place where you just shout out a quick “nice work” and move on.
I’m curious to see if the flairs will feel natural by spring, or if we’ll have outgrown them. Maybe we’ll need different ones. Or maybe we’ll get to a point where approval isn’t necessary anymore. But for now, this is what we need. A little more waiting. A little more thinking. A little more intention in how we talk to each other, online and off.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why We Now Use Post and Comment Approval (and New Flairs) in Our Classroom Blog