Why We Can’t Hold Students to the Same Standards We Hold Teachers
Last month, I sat crammed into a too-small plastic desk at my 10-year-old’s parent-teacher conference, watching Ms. Lopez scroll through his online behavior tracker. Three missed homework assignments in six weeks, one unexcused tardy, one instance of forgetting his required reading book for silent reading. “We hold all our staff to these same consistent expectations,” she said, leaning forward. “It’s only fair to apply the same rules to the kids, right?”
I nodded because I’m a substitute teacher at this same school, so I know exactly what those staff expectations are. Lesson plans due by 3pm every Friday, turn in graded work within three school days, be at your morning duty post 2 minutes before the bell. Miss those, and you get a formal note in your personnel file. Miss three, and you go in for a check-in with administration. That’s the system, so it makes logical sense on paper to extend it to kids.
I left the conference and walked across the playground to pick up my 6-year-old from kindergarten, and that’s when the whole “same rules for everyone” thing started to feel off. I started thinking about the last time I broke one of those staff rules. Two weeks prior, I got called in to cover a 7th grade science class at 6am, when the regular teacher woke up with a stomach bug. I threw my clothes on, grabbed coffee on the way, and completely forgot to turn in my end-of-day sub report by the 4pm deadline. What happened? The admin assistant sent me a quick Slack message the next morning that said “Forgot your report? No worries, just send it when you get a minute.” No note in my file, no formal warning, no penalty to my pay.
If that had been my son, forgetting a homework assignment three times would have gotten him a lunch detention and a zero on all three assignments, dragging his math grade down 15% in a month. A few weeks before that, I covered a high school PE class, and a 16-year-old got detention for being 2 minutes late to roll call three times in a month. The same rule applies to teachers, sure, but this 16-year-old had to detour across campus every day to pick up his little sister from middle school because his mom couldn’t leave her early shift at the hospital. As an adult, if I had a recurring family obligation that made me 2 minutes late to a meeting, my boss would adjust my schedule, not penalize me.
The core of the issue is that no one stops to acknowledge the huge developmental gap between the two groups we’re applying these rules to. Teachers are fully grown adults. The part of our brain that handles remembering tasks, planning ahead, and adjusting to last-minute changes is fully done developing by our mid-20s. Most teachers at our school are between 25 and 60 years old. We’ve had decades of practice remembering to bring things, meet deadlines, and rearrange our plans when something goes wrong. A 10-year-old’s prefrontal cortex is still like a half-built house. Some days the wiring works great, he remembers to bring his frog project, lunch box, and soccer cleats all in one trip. Some days the wiring shorts out, and he leaves his homework folder on the kitchen table, even though he checked his bag three times before he left. That’s not a failure of character. That’s just how growing up works.
This doesn’t mean kids shouldn’t have any expectations, of course. But we can adjust our requirements to match where they are, the same way we cut adults slack when they need it. I’ve started trying small, low-effort shifts when I sub, and I’ve talked to a handful of teachers who’ve tested them out too. First, instead of automatic zeroes for late work, use the same penalty we give adults: a small point deduction, not a total loss. If a teacher turns in lesson plans a day late, they don’t lose their entire paycheck, so why does a kid lose all their points for turning it in a day late? I usually take off 5% for one day late, 10% for two, that’s it. Second, build three “oops passes” into every quarter. No questions asked, turn your work in a day late, no penalty, just use one pass. That accounts for the messy, unpredictable life kids have: their parent got a flat tire on the way to school, they stayed up late taking care of a sick pet, they just plain forgot. Adults get do-overs all the time, why can’t kids? Third, if you’re a parent, ask the teacher about a quick low-effort check-in: most schools already use online portals for assignments, but a 10-second text at 3pm if your kid forgot something lets you drop it off if you can, instead of a big penalty that derails their whole grade.
Last week, I was subbing for 5th grade, and a quiet boy named Javi turned in his reading log blank because he left it on the counter at his grandma’s house. He was this close to crying, said he’d read for 20 minutes every night that week, just forgot it when his aunt drove him to school. I gave him an oops pass, told him to bring it tomorrow, no points off. He exhaled so hard I saw his shoulders drop, and he spent the rest of the period working harder than any other kid in the room. That’s the difference: if I’d given him a zero, he would have checked out for the whole week.
I brought the oops pass idea up at our last PTA meeting, and three teachers said they’re going to test it out this semester. It’s not going to fix underfunded schools or overcrowded classrooms, and there are still days when my son forgets his homework and I have to drive 15 minutes back home to get it, which is annoying for everyone. But it makes sense: we don’t expect a new driver to have the same reaction time as someone who’s been driving for 30 years, right? We don’t hold a toddler to the same walking standard as an adult. It’s past time we stop acting like equal treatment means identical rules, when the people on either side of the rule are at totally different places in their development. Right now, it’s just a small shift, but it’s already making things a little less stressful for both kids and teachers.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why We Can’t Hold Students to the Same Standards We Hold Teachers