Why Teaching Basic Ethics Isn’t Enough: How to Help Kids Work Through Real Ethical Problems
I was grading 5th grade spelling quizzes at my desk after recess last month when Mia showed up, one hand twisting the end of her neon pink braid, the other stuffed in the pocket of her overalls. Our class hamster Nibbles had gone missing 20 minutes earlier, after someone left his cage lid unlatched during morning cleaning. “I know who did it,” she mumbled, staring at my scuffed sneakers. “But I can’t tell you. It was Lila. She’s my best friend.”
A couple of years ago, I would’ve given her the standard answer I’d been taught to give. I’d already covered the basic ethics rules in our class: honesty matters, covering for someone who made a mistake is wrong, doing the right thing even when it’s hard is what good people do. I would’ve patted her shoulder and said, “Lila will understand eventually. It’s the right thing to tell.” That’s what I did two years ago when a similar situation came up with a stolen set of art markers, and what happened? The kid told, the friendship ended for six months, and no one came to me with a secret again after that. So this time, I pushed my grading aside, grabbed two stools from the reading nook, and poured us each a small handful of cheddar goldfish from the jar I keep for upset kids. I didn’t give her a rule. I asked her a question: “What’s the worst that can happen if you tell? What’s the worst that can happen if you don’t?”
She talked it through slowly. If I tell, Lila won’t sit with me at lunch anymore, and she won’t come to my birthday party next weekend. If I don’t tell, Nibbles could crawl into the wall and starve, and everyone in class is upset because we all love him. I nodded, then asked her: “What are all the options you can think of, besides just tell or don’t tell?” She thought for a minute, twisting her braid again, and said “Can I tell you right now, but you don’t say it was me? And can you say you figured it out from the cage, and no one gets in trouble? It was an accident anyway, right? We just need to find Nibbles.” I never would’ve come up with that solution first, but it made perfect sense. I said that sounded fine. She told me, I rounded the whole class up to search, said I’d confirmed the lid had been left unlatched by accident, no one was in trouble we just needed our hamster back. We found him 10 minutes later, tucked in a box of picture books in the back of the closet, nibbling on a lost granola bar. He was fine.
I’ve been thinking a lot lately about how we teach ethics to kids. Most of the time, we stick to the basics: don’t lie, don’t steal, don’t cheat, be kind. Those are good starting rules, but they don’t cover the messy stuff that kids actually face every day. The choice between being honest and keeping your best friend’s trust. The choice between joining in on a joke that hurts someone’s feelings and getting made fun of yourself for not joining. When kids only learn the rules, and not how to sort through conflicting right answers, they either freeze up or do what they think you want them to do, instead of what works for everyone involved.
It’s not just a classroom thing, either. My own 10-year-old son Jax came home last week upset because his best friend cheated on their big math unit test. My husband’s first instinct was to say “Cheating is wrong, you have to tell the teacher.” That’s the basic rule. But I pulled Jax down to the kitchen table and we went through the same exercise I did with Mia. First, name every person who’s affected by whatever you choose. He said: My friend, he’ll fail the test and have to go to summer school if he gets caught. Me, I’ll be the snitch and he won’t hang out with me anymore. The whole class, it’s not fair to everyone else who studied. Then what are all the options, not just tell or don’t tell. He came up with three: I could ask him to tell the teacher himself, I could go to the teacher privately and not give his name, I could just help him study for the next test so he doesn’t have to cheat again. He ended up asking his friend to tell the teacher, and they studied together after school two days that week. The teacher gave him a retake, no big fuss, and their friendship is fine.
This approach doesn’t require fancy lesson plans or big parenting overhauls. The steps are small enough to do in a 5-minute hallway chat or a kitchen break after school. First, don’t give your answer right away. Let the kid talk through who is affected and what each person stands to lose. That turns a vague, stressful “what do I do?” into something concrete they can wrap their head around. Second, push them to come up with more than two options. Kids know their own social worlds better than we do, and they almost always come up with more creative, kinder solutions than we would. Third, after they make their choice, talk about what worked and what didn’t, instead of just declaring it right or wrong.
It doesn’t always work out perfectly. Last semester, a girl named Zoe came to me because she’d been sitting with a group of girls who were leaving a quiet autistic kid out of our class Snapchat group, and saying mean things about his special interest in trains. She didn’t want to tell me who was doing it because they were her only friends in class. We brainstormed a few options, and she ended up just asking the kid to sit with her at lunch and added him to the group herself. The other girls still make quiet comments sometimes, and Zoe still worries they’ll stop being her friend. It’s not a perfect fix. But she worked through it on her own, instead of me just telling her she needed to report the other girls and end her friendships to do the right thing.
I still teach basic ethics, of course. Kids need those starting rules. But I’ve stopped thinking that’s enough. When these kids grow up, they’re not going to face multiple choice ethics questions where one answer is clearly right. They’re going to have to figure out how to balance loyalty to their friends and coworkers with doing what’s best for other people. They’re going to have to sort through messy, conflicting options that no rule book can cover. Right now, what I’m doing is just pausing long enough to let them sort it out themselves, instead of jumping in with the answer. Some days it works great, some days it’s still messy. But it feels like we’re actually preparing them for the real world, instead of just teaching them to recite rules.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Teaching Basic Ethics Isn’t Enough: How to Help Kids Work Through Real Ethical Problems