Why Some Quiet Kids In Chinese Primary Schools Fall Behind (And What Actually Helps)
Last Tuesday, I was brushing eraser shavings into a plastic cup after my after-school tutoring session ended, when I noticed 10-year-old Xiao Ming still hovering by the door. One strap of his faded blue school uniform had slipped off his shoulder, and he held his midterm math test crumpled tight in one fist. All the other kids had run out to meet their parents waiting by the gate, but Xiao Ming stayed. I pulled out the extra chair and told him to sit. He shuffled over, and spread the test out on the desk: 32 out of 100, the red ink blotted at the edges where he’d squeezed it.
I’ve been volunteering as a part-time tutor at a free center for children of migrant workers in Changsha for a year and a half. When Xiao Ming was assigned to me three months ago, the coordinator warned me he was “a problem kid” – won’t talk, won’t do work, falls asleep in every class. Most tutors had asked to swap him out after one session. I thought he was just another kid who’d checked out because no one expected anything from him. That first week, he didn’t say a single word. Just stared at his desk, chewed the end of his pencil, and left when the bell rang. I didn’t push him.
One day, halfway through the second week, he started clutching his stomach and wouldn’t do any work. I asked if he was sick, and he finally mumbled that he hadn’t eaten lunch. He’d left his lunch money on the kitchen counter that morning, and his mom had already left for her 12-hour shift at the garment factory before he realized. I bought him a steamed pork bun from the shop down the street, and he started talking a little after that.
Turns out, Xiao Ming was on track until third grade. Back then, his grandma lived with them and helped him with his homework every night. When grandma’s knees got too bad to walk, she moved back to their small village in rural Hunan, and Xiao Ming was on his own. That same semester, he got pneumonia and missed two weeks of school. By the time he came back, the whole class had moved on to multiplication. He didn’t know how to ask the teacher for help – she had 52 other kids in the class to worry about, after all. His parents work six days a week, and by the time they get home they’re too tired to sort through his backpack, let alone walk through confusing math problems. The gap just got bigger: no multiplication, no division, no way to follow the current lessons. So he stopped trying, started falling asleep in class, got moved to the back row, and everyone wrote him off.
I used to buy into the same line everyone repeats around here – that kids just need to work harder, that if you’re behind it’s because you’re not putting in enough hours. But working with Xiao Ming showed me that most of the time, when a quiet kid checks out, it’s not about effort. It’s about a small gap that no one stopped to fix before it turned into a chasm.
What I did first was throw out the 20-problem worksheet the center gave us. I cut his daily work down to three problems, max. That sounds counterintuitive when everyone is chasing higher test scores, but Xiao Ming would look at a page of 20 problems he couldn’t do and shut down immediately. Three problems? He can do three. We go through every step out loud, and if he gets all three right, we’re done with formal work for the day. That first week, he got all three right on the third day, and he actually leaned forward in his chair to show me. I noticed he collects rubber bands he finds on the playground to make keychains for his little cousin back in the village, so I started using them to practice. We count how many red versus blue rubber bands he has, multiply to figure out how many keychains he can make with his current stock. It’s math, same as the textbook, but it’s his math.
Next, I emailed his homeroom teacher. She’s a kind, overworked woman who just didn’t have time to focus on one quiet kid in the back. I only asked her to do one small thing: call on Xiao Ming once a day, to answer an easy question I knew he could get right. If he gets it right, just give him a small sticker from her reward box. That’s it, no extra work, no big changes to her lesson plan. She agreed, and last month Xiao Ming told me he got three stickers in one week. He taped them to the inside of his pencil case, where he keeps his best rubber bands.
Two weeks ago, he brought his latest unit test to me. It was 65 out of 100, folded neatly, not crumpled. That’s a passing grade for the first time in two years. He didn’t jump up and down or anything. He just put it on my desk, and waited for me to look. Then he pulled out a new pack of rubber bands and asked if we could make a keychain before he left.
A lot of people ask me how to help kids who fall through the cracks in China’s public school system, and everyone expects a big answer. But what I’ve learned is that it rarely takes big changes. It takes slowing down enough to ask the kid where they got lost, instead of just calling them lazy. If you’re a parent dealing with a kid who’s behind, cut their homework in half (or even a quarter) at first. Let them feel what it’s like to finish work and get it right, before you pile on more. If you’re a teacher, call on the quiet kid in the back once a day with a question you know they can answer. It takes 10 seconds, and it changes how they see themselves in class.
It’s not all good. Last week he failed a quiz because he forgot to study the new vocabulary words, and he hid in the hallway after class for 10 minutes before he would come show me. His parents still don’t have time to check his homework most nights, and the class pace doesn’t slow down for anyone. He still falls asleep in class sometimes, when he stayed up too late trying to finish homework on his own. But he talks now. He raises his hand sometimes. He brings me extra lychee candy his aunt sent from the village, and tells me stories about swimming in the river near his grandma’s house. We’re still taking it one problem at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Some Quiet Kids In Chinese Primary Schools Fall Behind (And What Actually Helps)