Why Some Kids Are Kind In Public But Bully Privately (And What Adults Can Do)
Last month, I volunteered at my 7th grader’s fall bake sale, standing by the cookie table folding napkins and making change. I’d seen Mia, a classmate of my daughter Lila’s friend Jessa, around school a dozen times. She was the girl who always held the door for teachers, helped the office staff sort flyers, and stopped to compliment every parent’s scarf or kid’s new sneakers that day. Half the teachers walking by stopped to say how helpful Mia was, how she’s such a thoughtful kid who looks out for everyone. When the rush slowed down, Lila tugged my sleeve and nodded toward the parking lot, where Jessa was leaning against our car, wiping her eyes on her sleeve.
We got in the car, and Jessa didn’t say anything until we were a mile from school, then pulled out her phone and opened a group chat for their history group project. That morning, Mia had been all smiles, praising Jessa’s idea for their Great Depression exhibit, offering to bring extra poster board. Ten minutes after class ended, the messages started popping up: screenshots of Jessa’s sketch of a bread line she’d drawn for the project, with captions saying “this is so creepy why does she draw this” “she definitely smells like old cheese I can’t sit next to her tomorrow” “we’re not inviting her for ice cream after right? No one wants her there.”
Jessa told us it’s been going on for six months. Mia will smile and wave at Jessa in the hallway in front of adults, but when it’s just the two of them and a couple of friends, she’ll slide her backpack over to block Jessa from sitting at the lunch table, or “accidentally” spill water on Jessa’s notebook, then laugh and say she should have watched where she was going. Jessa’s mom emailed the homeroom teacher about it a month earlier, and the teacher wrote back saying she’d never seen Mia do anything unkind—Mia stays after class every week to organize the bookshelf, after all—that Jessa must have misread the situation.
I get why the teacher thought that, honestly. I’d bought into the “Mia is such a nice kid” thing too, before that day. It’s easy to judge kids by what we see in front of us. When a kid consistently performs kindness for adults, we don’t look for the other stuff. This isn’t some movie plot where a 12-year-old is an evil master manipulator. At that age, social approval is basically the whole world. Mia gets constant positive reinforcement for being the helpful, nice kid—teachers praise her, parents like her, other kids follow her lead because she’s the one adults trust. Picking on people privately lets her boost her own social standing without risking any of that praise. It’s a messy, hurtful habit a lot of kids pick up before they even realize what they’re doing, because it works for them.
After Jessa told us what was going on, I talked to a teacher friend of mine who works in the district, and she shared a few small, low-effort things that make a real difference that most adults don’t think about.
First, stop asking vague questions and start asking specific, low-pressure ones that don’t put kids on the spot. Instead of asking the whole class “is anyone being bullied?” which no one will answer in front of their peers, pull kids aside for 2-minute check-ins when you have a free minute, and ask things like “who do you sit with at lunch this week?” or “is there anyone in class that makes you feel uncomfortable sharing your ideas?” You don’t have to do it every day, just rotate through once a month. For parents, instead of stopping at “how was school?” which always gets “fine,” try “any kids did anything weird this week that made you feel bad?” It’s specific enough that kids know you actually want details, not a one-word answer.
Second, if a kid comes to you to report this kind of bullying, the first thing out of your mouth shouldn’t be “why didn’t you tell me sooner?” or “are you sure you didn’t misinterpret it?” The kid already worked up the courage to tell you, and they already know no one will take their side because the bully is so good at performing kindness for adults. The first thing to say is “thank you for telling me this. I believe you, and we’ll handle this slowly.” That’s it. You don’t have to fix it right that second. Just that phrase takes a ton of weight off the kid’s shoulders.
Third, if you confirm the behavior, don’t call the kid out in front of the whole class. That just makes them play the victim, gain sympathy from other kids and adults, and be more sneaky next time. Pull them aside one on one, no audience, and state exactly what you know, don’t beat around the bush. Instead of “I heard you’ve been mean to Jessa,” say “I saw the messages you sent in the history group chat about Jessa’s drawing. Those comments hurt her, and that’s not okay, even when you’re talking when no adults are around.” Then, if the kid has privileges they care about—like being a student council rep, leading the bake sale, helping the teacher after class—tie the consequence to that. Take the privilege away for a month, instead of giving them a detention that just makes them look wronged to everyone else. That makes the behavior have a real consequence that matters to them, without feeding the narrative that they’re the innocent one being punished.
After Jessa’s mom forwarded the screenshots to the principal, the homeroom teacher started doing those quick 2-minute check-ins with all her students, and pulled Mia aside to talk about the comments. Mia said she was just joking, apologized to Jessa, and hasn’t done anything overt since. Jessa still asks to switch seats if Mia is sitting next to her at lunch, and we don’t know if she’s still making comments to other kids when no one is looking. But Jessa knows now that if she says something’s wrong, we’ll believe her, which is more than she had before. This stuff doesn’t get fixed overnight, I think. You just have to stop looking only at what kids show you in public, and pay attention to the stuff that happens when the lights are off and the adults aren’t around.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Some Kids Are Kind In Public But Bully Privately (And What Adults Can Do)