Why Sitting With Your Child When They Struggle Works Better Than Fixing It
The kitchen table was still sticky with Jax’s after-school apple sauce when he pushed his math homework toward me last month. Long division, the thing he’d been crying about for three nights straight. I’d already pulled up three different YouTube tutorials, printed a dozen extra practice sheets, and drawn little step-by-step checklists in the margin of his notebook that morning. I had my eraser out and was leaning in before he even opened his mouth, ready to walk through the first problem again like I had the two nights before. Then he said it: “Can you just sit with me? Not help. Just sit.”
I froze. My whole approach to Jax’s hard things has always been fix it fast. If he’s upset, solve the problem. If he’s stuck, show him the way. I nodded, put my eraser down, pushed my chair back a little so I wasn’t crowding the paper, and said “Okay. I’m here.” I folded the load of soccer uniforms I’d been working on next to me, one sock at a time, while he chewed on the end of his pencil. The dog curled up at my feet, the clock above the stove ticked, and I didn’t say a word for eight minutes.
He messed up the first multiplication step on the third problem, erased so hard the paper tore a little, and paused. I almost opened my mouth. I bit my tongue. He stared at the problem for another minute, crossed out the wrong number, and wrote the right one down. By the time he finished the whole page, he only had two wrong, and he caught one of them on his own before he turned it over. He didn’t cry. He didn’t crumple the worksheet and throw it across the room. He just closed his folder and said he was going to get a snack. That’s when it hit different, that quiet little moment I never expected.
I’ve worked as a paraeducator in the local elementary school for three years, so I’ve sat through dozens of trainings on helping kids with stress and learning blocks, but this moment landed different than any handout I’ve ever read. I always thought my job, both as a teacher and a mom, was to give the answer, or show the way, as fast as possible. What I missed is that most of the time, the big problem isn’t the long division or the tough reading passage or the fight with a friend. The big problem is the feeling of being alone with all that stress. When we jump in to fix it right away, we’re not actually solving the feeling. We’re just rushing past it to get to the “done” part.
It’s a small shift, but it’s really easy to do once you remember to try it. If your kid says they’re stuck or they’re upset, the first thing you do is put down whatever you’re holding that helps you fix it—your phone, your pen, the list of solutions you already made in your head. Say it out loud, clear: “I’m just here. I won’t help unless you ask me to.” If you need something to do with your hands so you don’t get antsy and start talking, fold laundry, or pet the dog, or just hold your coffee. Don’t scroll, don’t check your email—just be present enough that they know you’re not going anywhere, but not so present that you’re hovering waiting to jump in.
I tried this with a second grader I work with who shuts down completely during reading fluency checks. He freezes up the second I pull out the fluency sheet, and for months I’d prompt him, remind him of vowel sounds, give him hints, and he’d just stare at his shoes. Two weeks after Jax asked me to sit, I tried something different. When he froze, I put my clipboard down, pulled my chair a little back, and said “I’ll just sit here with you while you get ready. No rush.” It took 90 seconds, and then he started reading the first word out loud, and got through the whole passage without a single prompt. I would’ve never guessed that was all he needed.
I still mess this up all the time. Last week Jax was talking about how stressed he was for his science fair presentation, and I immediately started running through a practice schedule and listing what we needed to make his display board better before he even finished talking. He just looked at me and said “Mom, I just want you to sit.” I had to close my mouth, push my notebook away, and sit. It still feels weird at first, right? We’re so used to feeling like we have to do something when our kids are hurting or stuck. Doing nothing that looks like something is counterintuitive.
It’s been a month since that first day with the long division, and it’s become our new default. Some days he asks for help working through a problem, some days he just asks for me to pull a chair up next to his desk. The other day he told me that when I’m talking him through every step, his brain feels too full to think. When I just sit, there’s enough room for his brain to work. I still don’t get it right every time, and I still jump in to fix things when I shouldn’t. But I’m starting to see what he means. There’s no quick fix for every hard thing kids go through. But more often than not, just showing up and sitting is enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Sitting With Your Child When They Struggle Works Better Than Fixing It