Why Schools Need to Prioritize Emotional Education Over Just Test Scores
Last month I volunteered to cover study hall during 4th grade math makeups at my kid’s elementary school. The room was half empty, most kids were out at recess, the fluorescent lights hummed, and there was a half-eaten bag of Goldfish left on a desk by the door. Liam, a quiet kid who sits in the back, had been staring at his half-blank test paper for 20 minutes. His eraser was ground into crumbs all over his desk, and when I leaned over to ask if he needed help finding a problem, I saw he was crying silent, shoulder-shaking tears he was trying to hide from me. He whispered, “I’m just stupid. I’ll never get this right.”
The classroom teacher, Ms. Lopez, came back from the copy room a minute later and spotted what was going on. I expected her to tell him he was fine, that he knew the material, just calm down and keep working. That’s what I would’ve done a few years ago, that’s what most teachers I had when I was a kid would do. Instead, she just nodded at the door and said, “C’mon, let’s step out for a minute. The test can wait.”
They leaned against the hallway wall outside, visible through the classroom’s glass door. She didn’t stand over him or talk down to him. She asked, “What does this feel like in your body right now?” Liam shrugged for a minute, then said his chest was tight, like someone was sitting on it, and his hands felt all tingly. Ms. Lopez said, “That’s a really common feeling when we’re scared we’ve messed up. It’s called performance anxiety. I get that same tight chest before every parent-teacher conference, honestly.” She counted through four seconds of breathing in, four holding, four breathing out with him, right there in the hallway, for two minutes. Then she said, “You don’t have to finish this today. Do one half now, the other half tomorrow, whenever your chest doesn’t feel tight anymore. No rush.”
After study hall, I helped her stack worksheets, and we got to talking. She said this is the first year the school has allotted 10 minutes at the start of every day for emotional check-ins, and it’s changed everything. Before that, the only time anyone talked about feelings at school was after a fight, or after a kid had a full meltdown in class. It was never about teaching kids what feelings are, how to name them, how to handle them before they get that big. She said half the kids she had last year couldn’t name more than three feelings: happy, sad, mad. That’s it. When something complicated happens, like they’re jealous of a friend, or nervous about a test, or embarrassed they got a question wrong, they just call themselves stupid or bad because they don’t have another word for it.
That lines up with what I’ve seen with my own daughter, Mia, who’s in 5th grade at the same school. Six months ago, if she came home saying she had a bad day, that’s all I’d get. “I don’t know, I just hate everything.” Last week, she came home from school, paused, and said, “I felt jealous today because my best friend got a new bike that I’ve been asking for, and then I felt guilty for being jealous because it’s not her fault I don’t have one.” I almost fell over. That’s the kind of emotional awareness most adults I know still struggle with. She learned that in her daily check-ins, where they go through a printed feelings chart every morning and every kid shares one word if they want to. It’s 10 minutes. That’s all it takes.
A lot of people push back on this kind of work, right? They say we don’t have time for this, we’ve got to get through the reading curriculum, we’ve got to raise test scores, there’s state testing to prepare for. Ms. Lopez told me that in the first semester of this year, her number of detentions and minor office referrals dropped by 30%. Kids aren’t acting out because they can name what they’re feeling before it builds to that point. And when kids are walking around with a tight chest from anxiety they can’t name, they don’t have any extra brain space to memorize multiplication tables or write a book report. It’s not like emotional education takes away from academic learning. It makes academic learning possible.
It’s not just up to schools, either. If your kid’s school isn’t doing this yet, you can start small at home, no extra time required. I stopped asking “how was school” at dinner, and I started asking “what’s one feeling you had today, and what caused it.” It takes two minutes, and it’s already made Mia more comfortable talking about things that bug her before they blow up. If you’re a teacher, you don’t need administrative approval to do five minutes of feelings check-in at the start of class, or to pause and ask a kid what they’re feeling instead of telling them to calm down. Next time a kid shuts down on a test, instead of pushing them to keep going, try asking what it feels like in their body first. It doesn’t take more time, it just takes a different priority.
Liam ended up getting a B on that retake, by the way. I saw his paper posted on the achievement bulletin board a week later. But that’s not the big takeaway. The big thing is he left that day knowing that the tight feeling in his chest wasn’t a sign he was stupid. It was just a feeling, it had a name, and it would pass.
Our school is still just piloting this daily check-in program. Some days it gets skipped for a holiday assembly or a last-minute test prep session. Some teachers haven’t gotten the small amount of training they need to feel comfortable leading it. There’s no guarantee the school board will keep funding it next year, and we don’t know yet if it’ll move the needle on state test scores in a couple of years. But right now, I see 9 and 10 year olds who can talk about how they feel instead of shutting down, or hitting someone, or calling themselves bad. That’s a bigger win than any test score I can think of.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Schools Need to Prioritize Emotional Education Over Just Test Scores