Why School Kills Kids’ Passion For History (And What Parents Can Do)
Sunday night, kitchen table, half-eaten buffalo mac and cheese congealing in a box, my 10th grader Jake slumps back in his chair and tosses his pencil across the table. “I don’t get why I even bother,” he says. “My school is killing my passion for history. What do I even do about it?”
I almost dropped the coffee I was pouring. Three years ago, that kid would have rather talked about medieval castle sieges than eaten ice cream. At 8, he spent his entire spring break cutting up cardboard boxes to build a 3-foot scale model of Dover Castle, complete with a working drawbridge made of popsicle sticks and yarn. We watched that same low-budget History Channel documentary about the Battle of Hastings four weekends in a row, because he kept pausing it to ask why Harold’s army made the choices they did, what the ordinary soldiers ate while they waited for the fight. I never thought I’d hear him say school killed that.
He pulled up his study guide to show me what he’s up against. Twenty-six dates to memorize for the upcoming French Revolution quiz, 12 names of key legislators, three acts of parliament to define word for word. Not one question asking what it felt like to be a 16-year-old factory worker living in Paris in 1789, or why the revolution’s ideas still pop up in every protest we see on the news now. Last semester, he’d asked his teacher if he could do his final research project on the history of our city’s downtown skate park—how local skaters fought the city council in the 90s to keep it from being turned into a parking garage. He skates that park three times a week, knows half the guys who’d fought for it. The teacher said no, it wasn’t on the approved list of topics for the semester. That’s when he started checking out.
I didn’t grab my phone and email the principal that night. I didn’t call the teacher and rant about bad curriculum. I’ve worked in education long enough to know most schools are just hanging on right now, sticking to state-mandated lists because they don’t have the bandwidth to do anything else. Instead, I sat down across from him and said, “That makes total sense. School has to check a lot of boxes right now, that doesn’t mean your history has to fit in those boxes.” That’s the first thing I think people get wrong—you don’t have to fix the whole system to save your kid’s passion.
The next morning, on our 20-minute drive to school, I didn’t turn on his usual rap playlist. I pulled up a 15-minute episode of The Memory Palace about that same skate park. I didn’t make a big deal out of it, just said “I found this last night, thought you might want to listen.” He rolled his eyes at first, but by the end he was asking me to pause it so he could re-listen to the part where the skaters chained themselves to the half-pipe. We started doing that three mornings a week—short episodes on whatever he’s curious about, no quizzes, no grades, just stories.
After that, I told him that as long as he got his required homework done to pass the class, we’d carve out one hour every Friday afternoon for his own history. No rules, no requirements. He can dig into whatever he wants, no one grades it, no one says it’s not “real history.” The first week he spent that hour digging through old punk show fliers on the public library’s digital archive. He’s into 70s punk now, so he wanted to see how the scene grew out of New York’s bankruptcy and white flight. He ended up making a little zine out of the scanned fliers and his own writing, just to give to his friends. I didn’t correct his grammar, I didn’t ask him to make an outline. I just asked him what the coolest thing he found out was.
After a month of that, I emailed his teacher. I didn’t complain. I just said Jake’s loved history since he was little, and he’s been frustrated by how much memorization the class requires right now. Would he be open to letting Jake add a one-paragraph personal reflection to every test, where he writes about what part of the unit he actually found interesting, just for a tiny bit of extra credit? The teacher wrote back the next day saying he’d be happy to—turns out he doesn’t love making kids memorize dates either, he just has to follow the district’s testing requirements. That’s the thing, most teachers are on your side here, you just don’t have to approach them like they’re the enemy.
Last weekend we went to a pop-up exhibit at our local historical society about civil rights protests at our city’s high schools in the 60s. Jake’s high school is the same building that was there back then. He spent an hour leaning over the display case reading old student newspaper clippings, talking about how his textbook only devotes one paragraph to civil rights outside the South, and nothing at all about what happened here. He left the exhibit with a photocopy of a flier for a 1965 walkout, and taped it to his bedroom wall.
He still complains about history class on Sunday nights. He still mixes up the dates of the Tennis Court Oath and the Storming of the Bastille on quizzes, so his test scores aren’t perfect. The school hasn’t suddenly overhauled its curriculum to fit his interests, and I don’t expect it to any time soon. But the passion didn’t die. It just moved off the textbook page, into the stuff that’s his. Some days that’s all you can do—hold onto the passion outside the system while you help your kid get through the hoops they have to jump. It’s not a perfect fix, but it’s working for us right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why School Kills Kids’ Passion For History (And What Parents Can Do)