Why Overthinking Can Make Your Kid Feel “Dumb” (And What You Can Do About It)
Last Tuesday, I was wiping garlic bread crumbs off the kitchen table while my 11-year-old, Sam, worked through his 5th grade pre-algebra review quiz. The dog was curled up under his chair snoring, and half a glass of warm lemonade sat next to his notebook. Sam tapped his pencil for two minutes, circled 12 as the answer, and leaned back to stretch. Then he paused, frowned, and leaned in again. He erased so hard the paper tore a little, rewrote his work step by step, and put down 18. When I checked his work a minute later, the first answer was right. He pushed his notebook away and dropped his head into his arms. “Overthinking is making me dumb,” he mumbled.
This wasn’t the first time he’d said it. Sam has always been the kid who asks 10 follow-up questions about a one-paragraph homework assignment, who re-reads a text message three times before sending it, who reorganized his book shelf by genre then color then size over one weekend because he couldn’t decide which looked better. The pattern first popped up in third grade, when he started taking standardized tests. He’d finish in half the allotted time, then spend the rest of it changing answers, ending up with a lower score than he got on untimed practice. I used to tell him “just relax” and “you know this stuff” – useless words that did nothing but make him more frustrated.
It wasn’t until our last parent-teacher conference that Sam’s teacher, Ms. Henderson, framed what was happening in a way that made sense. She said she sees this at least once a week with kids in upper elementary and middle school, especially the ones who are used to getting things right. When kids grow up hearing they’re smart, she said, they start to associate one wrong answer with being bad at the whole subject. They get stuck in a loop: one bad experience second-guessing leads to more second-guessing, until all the extra “what if” thoughts clog up the space in their brain they need to actually solve the problem. That’s why it feels like they don’t know anything – it’s not that the information isn’t there, it’s that the overthinking is blocking access to it. They walk away feeling like they’re dumb, when really they just have too much noise going on upstairs.
Ms. Henderson gave me two small, concrete things to try that didn’t require any big schedule changes or expensive tools. The first is a two-minute pre-test brain dump. Before any quiz, test, or even big homework assignment, Sam takes a scrap of notebook paper and writes down every worried thought he has, no filtering allowed. It can be anything from “I forgot how to calculate area” to “I’ll fail and let everyone down.” Once it’s all out, he crumples it up and throws it away. She said this works because it gets all the noise out of your working memory so you can focus on the actual work, instead of carrying all those what-ifs around while you’re trying to think.
The second trick is the star rule for first answers. Any time Sam solves a problem, he writes down his answer and puts a tiny star in the margin next to it. If he finishes early and wants to check his work, he can only change the answer if he can point to a specific error in his first work – like “I multiplied instead of added” – not just “it feels wrong.” I used to badger him to check every single answer twice before turning anything in, which is part of why he started overthinking every single one. Now we only check the questions he already marked he was unsure of, not every single problem on the page.
We tried both tricks for the first time before Sam’s math quiz last week. He did his brain dump at the kitchen table before leaving for school, wrote “what if I mess up triangle area” and “what if I don’t make honor roll” on the scrap, and crumpled it up on top of an empty apple juice box in the trash. When he came home that afternoon, he had a 19 out of 20 on the quiz. The one he missed was a volume question he mixed up the formula for, not one he overthought. Three other questions he almost changed, but remembered the star rule and left them – all three were right. That night he said it felt weird not second guessing everything, but it also felt a lot easier.
I started adjusting how I talk to him about it too, when he does get stuck. Instead of saying “you’re not dumb,” which just makes him shut down, I ask: “Can you point to the thought that’s making you second guess? Is it a fact, or just a what if?” Nine times out of ten, he’ll admit it’s just a what if, and he can go back to his first answer.
It doesn’t work every time. Last night he was figuring out how much flour he needed for 4-H cookie bake sale, and changed the amount three times even though he’d baked the same recipe three times before. We still have bad homework nights where he erases half his paper and gets so frustrated he wants to quit. But it’s better. He can name it now, when he’s overthinking. He’ll stop mid-problem, grin a little and say “I’m doing it again,” scribble his thoughts on a scrap, and move on. He hasn’t mumbled that line about overthinking making him dumb in a few weeks, which is more than I could have asked for a month ago. Some days it’s still a fight, but we’re learning to spot it early, one star and one crumpled scrap of paper at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Overthinking Can Make Your Kid Feel “Dumb” (And What You Can Do About It)