Why My Toddler Is A ‘Menace’ (And Practical Tips For Managing Curious Toddler Behavior)
I stood in my kitchen doorway yesterday at 7:15 a.m., coffee still unsipped, and watched my 2-year-old son Leo squeeze an entire 12-ounce bear-shaped honey bottle over my new wool area rug. He was standing on the counter, bare feet propped on the toaster, and when he heard me suck in a breath, he looked up, grinned, and slapped the honey puddle with a wooden spatula. “Mess!” he yelled, delighted. Ten minutes later, when my sister texted to ask how our morning was going, I sent her a photo of the disaster, and she wrote back, “You are raising a total menace. LOL.” I laughed back, but I’ve been thinking about that word a lot lately. So many parents I know call their 1- to 3-year-olds little menaces, like it’s a given, but for the first six months of this behavior, I was convinced I was doing something wrong.
A week earlier, he’d fished my work ID out of my purse and dropped it into the cat’s water bowl. Two days before that, he’d climbed out of his crib during nap time, pulled all the band-aids out of the first aid kit, and stuck one to every single wall in the living room. Last month at the playground, he walked up to a stranger’s 1-year-old, gently pushed her over, and then clapped like he’d just scored a goal. I wanted to crawl into the mulch and disappear. I read all the parenting posts that said “toddler acting out means they need more attention” so I set aside more one-on-one time, and he still squeezed my entire bottle of foundation into the sink ten minutes after I finished playing blocks with him. I tried time-outs, gold stars for good behavior, everything. Nothing stopped the steady stream of small (and sometimes not small) disasters.
Then I talked to Leo’s pediatrician at his 2-year checkup, and she said something that shifted everything. She said that what we call “menace behavior” is usually just unregulated curiosity. Toddlers’ brains are building millions of new connections every day, and the only way they can test how the world works is by doing the thing they’re not supposed to do. They don’t have the impulse control to stop and think “mom will be mad if I do this” before they think “what happens if I drop this in the toilet?” It’s not that they’re bad, or that they’re trying to upset you. It’s that their version of science class is messing up your stuff. That clicked for me. I stopped seeing every mess as a failure on my part, and started looking for small, low-friction changes instead of trying to “fix” his behavior.
The first thing that worked was swapping “no” for an alternative. When I catch him reaching for the honey on the counter or my makeup bag, I don’t just yell “don’t touch.” I point him to the “mess bin” I keep on the back porch. It’s just a big plastic bin with old squeeze bottles, food coloring, water, flour, and old paintbrushes. I tell him “honey is for eating, but you can squeeze all the colored water you want on the driveway if you come with me.” Nine times out of ten, he drops what he’s holding and runs for the door. It takes 2 extra minutes, but it’s way easier than scrubbing honey out of a rug.
The second change was just locking up the stuff I can’t afford to ruin, instead of expecting a 2-year-old to remember not to touch it. I used to leave my phone and my wallet on the coffee table because I thought he should learn not to touch things that aren’t his. Now I keep them in a basket on top of the fridge, and I put latches on the lower pantry cabinets where we keep snacks and cleaning supplies. It took me 10 minutes to install the latches, and it’s eliminated at least three fights a day. I used to think this was “avoiding” bad behavior, but it’s just meeting him where he is. He can’t remember the rule 10 minutes after I tell him, so why make us both miserable by testing that over and over?
Last week, when my friend brought her 3-year-old over, Leo grabbed her phone off the couch and headed straight for the bathroom before I could stop him. I sighed, and I went after him, and sure enough, it was already in the toilet. I used to have a whole big meltdown about that kind of thing, but this time I just pulled it out, dried it off, and said to Leo “that’s a no, phones don’t go in the toilet. Let’s go throw your rubber duck in the tub instead, okay?” My friend, who’s a preschool teacher, laughed and said that’s exactly what she tells parents to do. She said the worst thing you can do is make a big scene when they do a menacing thing, because the big reaction is just more fun for them. They get that you’re upset, and that’s another data point for their little science experiment: “If I do this, mom yells really loud. Cool, let’s do it again.” Keeping the reaction calm and moving them to something else takes the fun out of the menace act, mostly.
Some days it still goes wrong. Last Tuesday, I was running late for a work meeting, and I forgot to latch the cabinet, and Leo dumped an entire bottle of maple syrup all over the kitchen floor. I yelled. I slammed the cabinet door. I sat on the stairs for five minutes after he went down for his nap and ate a cookie I’d hidden from him. He’s still a menace, most days. I still get texts from my sister calling him that, and I laugh and agree. But I don’t see it as a bad thing anymore, most of the time. He’s just figuring out how the world works, one ruined honey bottle and one sticky rug at a time. The small changes I made don’t stop all the messes, but they stop me from resenting him for being exactly the age he is. I don’t know what the next stage will bring, probably more messes. For now, this works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My Toddler Is A ‘Menace’ (And Practical Tips For Managing Curious Toddler Behavior)