Why My So-Called “Nightmare Babysitter” Changed How I Screen Caregivers
I fumbled with my front door keys at 9:30 PM, the faint tang of anniversary wine still on my breath, already mentally running through the checklist I’d texted the babysitter that afternoon: toys put away, pajamas on, Leo in bed by 7:45, no screens after dinner. I’d been trying to get a date night with my husband for 18 months, ever since Leo’s last babysitter called mid-dinner to say he’d locked himself in the closet and wouldn’t come out. I wasn’t about to let anything go wrong this time. When I turned the handle, the first thing I heard was Leo’s cackle, followed by a wet splat against the living room wall.
The coffee table held a half-eaten pepperoni pizza directly on the wood, no plate. The dining room chairs were dragged into a lumpy fort draped with all my good guest towels. Glitter – the extra-fine craft glitter I hide on the top shelf of the linen closet for birthday parties – was everywhere: in Leo’s hair, on the couch cushions, even on the tip of the babysitter’s skateboard propped by the door. Jax, the 16-year-old from down the street, looked up from where he was taping a treasure map to the fort wall and didn’t even flinch. “Hey,” he said. “You’re 20 minutes early. Leo talked me into one more water balloon round before you got in. We did the reading you left, we just turned it into a pirate treasure hunt instead. No one got hurt, I promise.”
Three different moms from the neighborhood PTA had warned me not to hire Jax. Said he was a nightmare babysitter: he’d spray painted the old abandoned shed at the park, skipped three weeks of detention last fall, and never followed rules adults set for him. I’d been desperate, though. Every other babysitter I’d hired was a straight-A teen who followed my checklist to the letter. Every single one came back to me at the end of the night saying Leo had cried for an hour straight, refused to eat, hidden in the laundry room. Leo has always had a hard time with transitions, especially when my husband and I leave the house. A rigid routine just made him clamp up worse.
Leo came barrelling toward me before I could even process the mess, glitter flying off his hoodie, holding up a plastic dinosaur he’d buried as treasure. He didn’t cling to my leg and hide his face like he usually did after I’d been gone. He talked a mile a minute about how Jax taught him to do an ollie on the skateboard in the driveway, how they’d popped popcorn with extra butter, how Jax let him pick the music when they drove to get ice cream at the gas station down the road. I looked at the water stain on the wall, at the glitter that I knew would take me three vacuuming sessions to get out, and I couldn’t even make myself mad. For the first time in two years, Leo had a good time with a babysitter. He wasn’t walking on eggshells waiting for me to come home.
I hired Jax again the next week, and then every other Friday after that. I stopped writing out that 2-page checklist of rules, and started only writing down three non-negotiables, taped to the fridge: no going down to the creek by the neighborhood entrance, no peanut butter anywhere near Leo, call me immediately if he says his chest hurts (his go-to tell for a rising anxiety attack). That’s it. The rest was up to Jax. It turns out that all the “bad” behavior everyone warned me about made him good with my kid. He didn’t tell Leo to stop crying when he got upset that I was leaving. He let Leo pick what they did, instead of sticking to a pre-planned schedule. When Leo wanted to climb the big oak tree in the backyard that I’d forbidden for years, Jax didn’t say no. He stood at the base, told Leo to test each branch before he put his weight on it, and said he’d catch him if he slipped. Leo made it halfway up, climbed back down, and talked about that win for three days.
It’s not like Jax was perfect. Last month, he let Leo eat three chocolate chip cookies before dinner, and Leo threw up a little in the sink before bed. Jax called me right away, sounded mortified, apologized over and over, reminded me he knows it’s one cookie max next time. I wasn’t happy, but I also thought: I’ve given Leo three cookies when I was too tired to cook dinner, too. It wasn’t the end of the world. The thing no one tells you about screening babysitters is that we spend so much time looking for someone who will follow all our rules and keep the house clean that we forget the whole job is to keep your kid safe and happy, not give you a spotless house to come home to.
I now tell new parents asking for babysitter advice to do three small things that came out of this. First, when you list rules for a caregiver, keep it to three non-negotiables max. Anything more and you’re just prioritizing your convenience over your kid’s comfort. Second, when you interview someone, don’t just ask for references or how much experience they have. Ask what they’d do if your kid starts crying because you left. If their answer sounds stiff and scripted, that’s fine, but don’t write someone off if their answer is messy and kid-focused. Jax’s answer was “I’d let him pick whatever we do next, crying doesn’t hurt anything.” Third, don’t write someone off just because other people call them a nightmare. Rough around the edges doesn’t mean bad with kids.
Jax got a part-time job at the local skate park this summer, so he won’t be able to babysit for me much longer. I’ve been going through the neighborhood babysitting board, looking for a replacement, and all the top recommendations are for honor roll students with first aid certification and 5-star reviews from a dozen other moms. I’m grateful for the suggestions, but I keep catching myself looking for someone a little messy, a little willing to bend the rules. I know now that a spotless house and a perfect routine don’t mean a good babysitter. A good babysitter is someone who my kid wants to be with, even when I’m gone. There’s still a little voice in my head that worries I’m doing this wrong, that I should be pickier, that I should value following the rules more. But for now, the faint glitter still stuck in my couch cushions is worth it. Leo doesn’t get stomach aches before date night anymore. That’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My So-Called “Nightmare Babysitter” Changed How I Screen Caregivers