Why My 10-Year-Old Refuses To Use AI For Schoolwork (And What I’m Doing About It)
The goldfish crumbs are scattered across Leo’s notebook, half his post-its are crumpled in the junk drawer by the fridge, and it’s 7:30 on a Sunday night. He’s working on a state report on Ohio for 5th grade, and he’s been stuck on his outline for 20 minutes. I’m leaning against the dishwasher wiping down plates, and I almost automatically say what I’ve been told to say: “You know Ms. Henderson said you can use AI to get your outline started if you’re stuck. It’d save you a ton of time.”
He slams his pencil down hard enough that the eraser flies off. “I don’t want to use AI,” he says, and that’s the first time he’s said it outright, even though he’s turned it down three other times this semester.
I pull out a chair next to him, because I was expecting this eventually. All the parent emails from school, all the articles I scroll past on my phone, say the same thing: kids need to learn to use AI now, or they’ll be left behind. It’s just a tool, everyone says. What’s the big deal? I pulled up the app a month ago to show him how it works, after he complained about how long it took to find facts for his dinosaur project. He stared at the screen for two minutes, then turned back to his dog-eared library book and said it “felt like cheating, but not the fun kind.”
At first I pushed. I told him AI could pull all the basic facts about Ohio’s government and capital in 10 seconds, so he could spend more time on the parts he cared about. He shook his head. “I like finding the facts myself,” he said. “Last week I spent 20 minutes scrolling Wikipedia and found out the first heart pacemaker was invented in Cleveland. No one else in my class is going to have that. If I asked AI, it’d just tell me about the football team and corn. That’s boring.”
He’s not wrong. I started thinking back to when I was his age, doing a report on Mars. I spent three afternoons in the school library pulling out old encyclopedias, scribbling down facts, getting lost in a chapter about the first rover that I never would have found if I’d just had an outline handed to me. I still remember that random fact about the rover’s solar panels getting covered in dust, 25 years later. I can’t tell you a single thing from the canned book report I got an A on in 10th grade that I half-copied from a study guide.
That’s when I stopped pushing. I’d been so focused on making sure he was keeping up with the new technology that I missed what he was actually telling me: the messy, slow, meandering part of doing schoolwork is where the learning sticks. When he scribbles out an outline, crosses out three bad main ideas, and stumbles on a good one, he’s practicing how to sort his own thoughts. When he spends 20 minutes wandering through random links looking for one fact, he’s practicing how to follow his curiosity. AI skips all that.
I don’t ban AI in our house, by the way. We worked out three small rules that work for us right now, and they’re easy enough for any parent to try. First, Leo gets to decide when to use it. If he just needs to check what year Ohio became a state, or what the capital is, he can pull it up. If he’s brainstorming, outlining, or writing the part of the project that’s supposed to be his, he does it on his own. Second, when he says he’s stuck, I don’t offer AI first anymore. I ask him one of two questions: “What’s the one thing you’ve found so far that you think is coolest?” or “What do you want people who read this to walk away thinking?” That gets him unstuck way faster than any AI outline, and it’s his own idea. Third, I shifted our evening homework routine 15 minutes earlier. That way he has time to wander and get stuck without us rushing to finish before bedtime. No more pushing him to cut his curiosity short just to check the box.
Last week he presented his Ohio report to the class. His conclusion was all about how the state should set aside more land to protect the ice caves he read about in the northern part of the state. He drew a little doodle of a cave in the corner of his last slide, all messy with blue crayon. Ms. Henderson wrote on his rubric that it was the most original conclusion any student turned in, and gave him extra credit. His friend who used AI to write his whole outline got a good grade, but when I asked him what he wrote about after the presentation, he shrugged and said he couldn’t remember.
I don’t know if this is the right choice long term. Next year he’ll be in middle school, and the work will get harder, and he might decide he wants to use AI to keep up. He might need it for work someday, obviously, and he’ll learn how to use it when that time comes. Right now, though, when his main job is to learn how to think his own thoughts, I’m okay with letting him say no. It’s not that AI is bad. It’s just that right now, his own slow, messy, interesting thoughts are more important. I don’t need him to check the box of learning the latest tool this year. I need him to know what his own ideas feel like, before he starts borrowing someone else’s. That’s the part no tool can teach him, anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My 10-Year-Old Refuses To Use AI For Schoolwork (And What I’m Doing About It)