Why Middle Schoolers Joke About Getting Beat With Their Chromebook: Understanding Dress Code Anxiety For Parents And Teachers
7:12 a.m. Coffee is still steaming in my mug, the bus is 8 minutes away, and my seventh grader is standing in the hallway mirror holding a faded concert hoodie up to her chest like it’s contraband. “Am I going to get beat with my own Chromebook for wearing this?” she asks, deadpan.
I almost snort coffee out my nose, because it’s such an absurd thing for a 12-year-old to say, but I also know exactly where it came from. Last week, her best friend Mia got called out of science class for wearing shorts that the assistant principal said ended an inch too high on her thigh. They sent her straight to the office, made her call her mom to bring a different pair of pants, and held her Chromebook hostage until she changed – our school holds devices for any rule infraction that requires a parent pick-up. By the time Mia got back to class, she’d missed the entire lab on cell division. That night, the joke blew up in their group chat, and “getting beat with your own Chromebook” became the catch-all for any ridiculous, over-the-top punishment for a stupid dress code violation.
I’d gotten the call myself the year before, halfway through a work meeting. Lila had raised her hand to answer a question in social studies, and her t-shirt rode up an inch, showing a sliver of her midriff. A hall teacher spotted it, walked her to the office, and I had to leave my presentation half-done to drive across town with an extra sweatshirt. By the time we got back, she’d missed an entire quiz, and refused to talk about it for three hours, just stared out the car window picking at her chipped nail polish.
I volunteer at the school library once a week now, so I see how this works up close, not just when my kid gets pulled. Last month, I watched an eighth grade boy get sent to the office for a pair of jeans with a small rip at the knee. Two weeks later, a non-binary student got called out for wearing a hoodie that was “too oversized” – it violated the school rule that all shirts have to be “fitted to the body.” Every time, it’s 20, 30 minutes of missed class time, public embarrassment, standing in the office waiting for a parent or a spare set of clothes that never fits right. People talk about dress codes being about minimizing distractions, but the only distraction I see is the dress code itself. I’ve watched Lila pull her shirt down 15 times during breakfast before school, rechecking the hem of her jeans after every step. That’s brain space she could be using to worry about her algebra test or her upcoming science fair project, not whether her hip bones are too visible for 8th grade lunch.
What do you do when your kid is standing in your hallway at 7 a.m., panicking that they’re going to get disciplined over a hoodie? I used to brush it off: “You look fine, stop being dramatic, no one’s going to care.” That never worked, obviously. It just made her shut down, take 10 minutes to pick a different, less favorite outfit she hated, and she’d still be stressed the whole bus ride. Now I do three small things that actually work, that any parent can do tomorrow morning. First, I keep an emergency outfit in the back of her backpack that she picked out herself – it’s a pair of jeans and a plain t-shirt she knows fits the school’s rules, that she still doesn’t mind wearing. If she gets called out, she can change right in the bathroom, no call to me, no missing class. Second, I don’t dismiss her worry. I just say, “That rule is so stupid, and it makes total sense you’re nervous. Admin has been way too picky about this lately.” Validation doesn’t fix the rule, but it takes the weight off her – she doesn’t feel like she’s overreacting for being upset. Third, if she does get sent to the office, I don’t blame her outfit. I go get her, we stop for her favorite fries on the way back to school or home, and I send an email to the principal and the PTA about it – not just for my kid, but for every other kid who’s going to go through the same thing.
For teachers who don’t agree with these strict rules but can’t change the whole policy overnight, there’s a small thing you can do too: keep a few cheap extra hoodies and pairs of sweatpants in your classroom, in a range of sizes. Thrift stores sell them for $3 or $4 each, and it means a kid who gets called out can just grab one from you instead of missing 30 minutes of class and sitting in the office embarrassed. I know several teachers at our school who do this, and the kids talk about it – it’s the small stuff that makes a huge difference for kids who already walk through the door with a hundred other things to worry about.
Back to Lila that morning: we looked at the hoodie, she pulled the bottom edge an inch lower, tucked it just a tiny bit into her jeans, confirmed the emergency outfit was still in her backpack, slung her Chromebook over her shoulder and headed for the bus. She turned and waved, and yelled over her shoulder “If I don’t text you by lunch, send search and rescue!”
Our school’s PTA has been talking about revising the dress code for a year now, cutting out all the arbitrary rules about hems and fit that mostly target girls, plus-size kids, and gender non-conforming kids. It’s moving slow, though, and there’s always a group of parents pushing back to keep the rules the way they are. For now, the Chromebook joke stays. Last week, she texted me from the bus line: “My shorts are 0.5 cm too short, odds I get Chromebook’d today?” I texted back “Emergency outfit is there, I’ll bring you a milkshake after school if you get sent home.” It’s not a fix for a bad policy. But it’s enough to get her through the day, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Middle Schoolers Joke About Getting Beat With Their Chromebook: Understanding Dress Code Anxiety For Parents And Teachers